Mafia Call the Ships to Port: Game Thread - END GAME - TOWN VICTORY!
- Thread starter Chris
- Start date
From my understanding Tom is being suss'ed pretty hard for his inactivity. I'm just saying that if he's active in this game, i.e. Participating in the scum chat and helping with kills as mafia, he would have seen that he's being sussed hard and being voted. He'd want to come in and say something to get people off him.
But he isn't doing ANYTHING which tells me that he probably isn't mafia, and if he is mafia, he's not participating on their end either.
cornimer
grab acorns 'til you're delirious
I am not ok with lynching Tom unless he talks. The number of people already voting for him not even halfway through the day is concerning to me. He is a little suspicious to me because even in Kingmaker, where he was pretty inactive, he posted more than this, but I think we should at least see if he posts content before the lynch before making our minds up. Idk why he would be so obviously scummy as scum, he's a good player
Thank you.
How long can he slip under the radar and not posting before being modkilled? Not too long I'd imagine, those are the posts that can be analysed as he get literally forced to participate to save himself
cornimer
grab acorns 'til you're delirious
I am also not ok lynching Ryumia because she acted the exact exact same as this in Kingmaker. I am confident in her being town
- - - Post Merge - - -
Ahhh stop posting guys all of these were supposed to merge
- - - Post Merge - - -
Ahhh stop posting guys all of these were supposed to merge
I just want to add that I don't think coasting = inactive, I think coasting is posting weak and not thought out reads and posts, while inactivity is just not being present.
Coasting is scummy, being inactive really isn't
Tom has posted near the end of Day One.
Oh really? I definitely missed that, I wrote all those recent posts thinking he hasn't talked since the beginning of day 1
- - - Post Merge - - -
Anyway, here's where I'm standing on some other players. I want to get this out because I'm not sure how much longer I'll be online today irl time, brother is back from college :
Won’t be voting:
Panda
FireNinja1
GhostKid
RED FLAGS FROM:
Dolby
Evan
Mog
Antonio
(I trust myself and definitely think there's at least 1, likely 2 in this list)
Hi all, I’ve promised you some reads and won’t deliver on those right this moment (SoonTM). Just caught up with the game so I’m mostly mulling over the deaths at the moment. Three votes on me is disappointing, but not entirely unexpected along with threats of more to come. I do think it’s really interesting that Kayla (iLoveYou) is super eager lynch me though, especially without knowing my recent meta? Dolby I get, he expects more from me, but Kayla seems really eager for blood ya know?
Mmm I was scumleaning him D1 but he slipped his role harder than a banana peel with that post.
It's not AI for someone like him who is on his second game to be saying something like that. Unhelpful? Yes but I don't really see what motivation there could be for a scum player to say that. It's pretty obvious that he is not blue, anyone in the thread can get that because this is a plain as day townie claim from him. So yeah he's either townie or some kind of mafia role, but even then, you would think that he would *probably* know what a blue role was anyway since scum usually has safeclaims of some kind. Dunno if Tina provides safeclaims but you would expect them to at least talk about it in the scum chat especially since scum killed 2 blues.
So yeah I personally think that Antonio slipped town.
cornimer
grab acorns 'til you're delirious
About the Antonio blue thing I find it sus. I specifically remember explaining to him what power roles were before he ever played a mafia game. It's in the Mafia General Thread if you don't believe me. I didn't specifically use the word blue but I mean...all you have to do is look at the colour of the people's names.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Like when I was reading the thread before I knew I was replacing in and I saw that I was like ???
- - - Post Merge - - -
Like when I was reading the thread before I knew I was replacing in and I saw that I was like ???
Read above post
Hmm the way I saw it was he was looking for a way to appear a little clueless for the killing situation, hoping people would clear him for being a little disconnected. You believe he just didn't read the EoN post and saw literally blue role names? You believe there was actual reason for him to ask that question? It's not like anyone asked him directly about the blue roles. I really do apologize if I'm coming off ignorant to a new player, but I have played the clueless town card as mafia and it's worked before. I'm also maybe being a little sensitive to red flags? In either case I don't want to ride it off as a town-slip because it's really not
did u just
did u just
how do you claim to not know what a blue role is but earlier you claimed that dolby's assessment of mafia-town ratio was "spot on"
- - - Post Merge - - -
no joke antonio just hard-claimed mafia lol
cornimer
grab acorns 'til you're delirious
I don't think I have time to make a full reads list right now so I'll just sort people into categories
People I am relatively certain they are town
Rune (very obviously different from scum Rune, I don't think he would make such a giant ISO as he did with Evan as scum)
Kammm (BTW you're playing really really well for your first game!
)
Heyden (same tone as in American Politics, very different tone from in RHOM)
FireNinja (his actions at the beginning of the game were kracko and no scum would act like that in my mind)
Ryumia (literally the exact same as in kingmaker)
People who I mostly townlean
Punchy - seems the same as always
Trundle - purely based on tone tbh, he hasn't posted much content. I don't really see scumdle saying things like "why isn't dolby townleaning me"
Ness - Someone (I think Rune?) said he wouldn't be so reluctant to play the game if he was scum, and I agree
Ghostkid - just seems really noob town
Null
Mog
Panda
iLoveYou - I townread her before but I reeeeeally don't like the way she is pushing for Tom
Jacob
About The Godfathers (TM)
One of Dolby, Dad, and glow is 100% scum in my eyes. Idk who else would think Oath was blue. The pure fact that there were two blues killed makes me eye Dolby, and frankly I find him the most suspicious of these three. I don't like how he just agreed with Dad about glow but didn't really look into her himself, I know he defended himself on that already but I just don't like it! Glow is the second most sus of the group. I was a bit confused why she would say "oh if I was maf I would kill oath" as maf, but maybe it's a reverse psychology tactic. I don't like how she's just been tunneling Dad the whole game. Dad is the least sus of the three but I've still got my eye on him. Oh and I wouldn't rule out two of them being scum either.
Concerning
Evan - his tone sounds very towny but I feel like he just keeps flip-flopping!
Antonio - reads make no sense and I don't believe he didn't know what blues are
Gig - do I even need to explain this, who the kracko is inactive and then shows up just to say who they will vote and then doesn't even vote
Tom - but DON'T EVERYONE GO AND VOTE FOR HIM HOLD YOUR HORSES YOU EAGER FOLKS LOOK SO SCUMMY YEESH
I guess that's basically a full reads list oops
People I am relatively certain they are town
Rune (very obviously different from scum Rune, I don't think he would make such a giant ISO as he did with Evan as scum)
Kammm (BTW you're playing really really well for your first game!
)Heyden (same tone as in American Politics, very different tone from in RHOM)
FireNinja (his actions at the beginning of the game were kracko and no scum would act like that in my mind)
Ryumia (literally the exact same as in kingmaker)
People who I mostly townlean
Punchy - seems the same as always
Trundle - purely based on tone tbh, he hasn't posted much content. I don't really see scumdle saying things like "why isn't dolby townleaning me"
Ness - Someone (I think Rune?) said he wouldn't be so reluctant to play the game if he was scum, and I agree
Ghostkid - just seems really noob town
Null
Mog
Panda
iLoveYou - I townread her before but I reeeeeally don't like the way she is pushing for Tom
Jacob
About The Godfathers (TM)
One of Dolby, Dad, and glow is 100% scum in my eyes. Idk who else would think Oath was blue. The pure fact that there were two blues killed makes me eye Dolby, and frankly I find him the most suspicious of these three. I don't like how he just agreed with Dad about glow but didn't really look into her himself, I know he defended himself on that already but I just don't like it! Glow is the second most sus of the group. I was a bit confused why she would say "oh if I was maf I would kill oath" as maf, but maybe it's a reverse psychology tactic. I don't like how she's just been tunneling Dad the whole game. Dad is the least sus of the three but I've still got my eye on him. Oh and I wouldn't rule out two of them being scum either.
Concerning
Evan - his tone sounds very towny but I feel like he just keeps flip-flopping!
Antonio - reads make no sense and I don't believe he didn't know what blues are
Gig - do I even need to explain this, who the kracko is inactive and then shows up just to say who they will vote and then doesn't even vote
Tom - but DON'T EVERYONE GO AND VOTE FOR HIM HOLD YOUR HORSES YOU EAGER FOLKS LOOK SO SCUMMY YEESH
I guess that's basically a full reads list oops
yeah i suppose I can agree with you that it seems as if he is playing the clueless card, but again, to what reason is there for him to try and do something like that? what benefit does he gain from asking that? nevertheless i kinda wanted to keep it a secret because in the off chance he did eventually claim blue I planned on tunneling him into the ground but I don't know if I really see scum motivation from that post
