Mafia Call the Ships to Port: Game Thread - END GAME - TOWN VICTORY!

[Heyden]

Dolby was scum in Smash 2 mafia. He also N1'd the detective that game. Coincidence? I THINK NOT.

 

[cornimer]

I really don't know Ness I said in my reads post I suss Dolby and I proved his blue sniping abilities and I think it made ppl realize how scummy he is
I feel like one or two ppl were suspicious before that too

 

[N e s s]

Dolby was scum in Smash 2 mafia. He also N1'd the detective that game. Coincidence? I THINK NOT.

Let me just say that I think using "Omg Dolby blue sniper!!" as the only reason to vote him is a pretty arrogant idea, unless there is something I've missed here. I haven't seen a single case on him, so I'm going to analyze his content and make my own judgement.

 

[cornimer]

Let me just say that I think using "Omg Dolby blue sniper!!" as the only reason to vote him is a pretty arrogant idea, unless there is something I've missed here. I haven't seen a single case on him, so I'm going to analyze his content and make my own judgement.

I think he's just been fishy in general the whole game and Id make my own case if I had time but I don't so I'm just going off my memory

 

[illunie]

just curious when did so many people collectively begin come out and be like "OMG lynch dolby!!", really how did this start

i'm doing meta analysis on Dolby right now and I can't remember the last game he was scum other than Caxnival, which I'm reluctant to completely use it because he was a rep in that, anyone possibly remember to make my life easier?

- - - Post Merge - - -



I thought of it as a townslip but I was instantly discredited so I mean :shrug:

i had my suspicions after how well scum bluehunted last night, idk about everyone else tho

- - - Post Merge - - -

im gonna make an iso when i have the time but im also sus of how quick he was to sus tom and locket, im pretty sure he was the first on both of them, could be misremembering tho

- - - Post Merge - - -

o and i didnt call it a scumslip i just was saying what other people thought was a scumslip

 

[Heyden]

Let me just say that I think using "Omg Dolby blue sniper!!" as the only reason to vote him is a pretty arrogant idea, unless there is something I've missed here. I haven't seen a single case on him, so I'm going to analyze his content and make my own judgement.

Nah I'm kidding. But I do have this underlying feeling about Dolby being scum. Town Dolby usually feels way more involved and a little bit less decisive (ie like he's unsure and corrects himself and it feels really genuine) while here it feels like everything's been planned or scripted in a way where he's like so sure of his reads. IDK how to put it into words, but yeah I'm definitely gonna ISO him if I get this research paper done quicker than I hope.
As of rn, still gonna go for Tom. Anyone wanting to lynch Ryumia can fight me personally.

 

[amazonevan19]

if you read my latest reads list, I've been uncomfortable about dolby based on how he's been reading me and his Trundle interactions. Seems like there's something going on there between those two. The bluesniping thing is a decentish point but certainly not lynch worthy imo

 

[cornimer]

Yeah overall I feel Dolby's been less involved, less of a leader and just doesn't have as strong cases and reasoning as usual

- - - Post Merge - - -

Oops I've been in the game for like 4 hours and have more posts than half the playlist, I'm going to sleep

 

[EpicGamer12]

I have like > 40 pages to catch up on, but I just wanted to react to the lynch for the people who are waiting for it:

Whyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy


Now here's my reaction to night kills:

Whyyyyyyyyyy but i'm also kinda glad they killed toads no offense your way my dude

Quick questions:

Who is Vanessa replacing?
Is FireNinja still being lazy?

Quick Reads/Thoughts:
amazonevan = town
Bluesnipes makes me doubt my Dolby read but I'll have to read the thread
Honestly if we can't find a good lynch candidate we should policy lynch inactives

 

[Dolby]

Wtf

Why did like Heyden turn against me like that. that honestly feels off
Why is everybody ignoring that Vanessa LITERALLY COPIED WORD FOR WORD sections of two other players post
Why is everybody ignoring the fact that Tom has been superbly different from every other game
And why is everybody also ignoring that I'm also on vacation

Who the **** would give Jacob double voting power to there of all people.

I'm gonna have to go forward assuming that Kate was a maf kill from this point forward. I'm pretty sure that everybody who could feasibly been a kill target has been accounted for. Oath could have simply withheld his shot as well

 

[illunie]

Who is Vanessa replacing?

locket

Honestly if we can't find a good lynch candidate we should policy lynch inactives

not this again, we have at least 3 valid lynch candidates rn, even suggesting this makes me feel off

- - - Post Merge - - -

I'm gonna have to go forward assuming that Kate was a maf kill from this point forward. I'm pretty sure that everybody who could feasibly been a kill target has been accounted for. Oath could have simply withheld his shot as well

why dont u think oath shot kate? seeing how good maf is at bluehunting based on their kills on oath and toad, why would they kill kate?

 

[EpicGamer12]

locket


not this again, we have at least 3 valid lynch candidates rn, even suggesting this makes me feel off

- - - Post Merge - - -



why dont u think oath shot kate? seeing how good maf is at bluehunting based on their kills on oath and toad, why would they kill kate?

> i haven't read the thread so plz read into the IF

 

[Dolby]

why dont u think oath shot kate? seeing how good maf is at bluehunting based on their kills on oath and toad, why would they kill kate?

No idea why they would kill Kate, but I am still thinking that maf has 3 KP. Yes this is an experimental game, but it fits the traditional KP system and scum:town ratio

 

[illunie]

> i haven't read the thread so plz read into the IF

but antonio was being sussed yesterday, so u should know that at least someone is acting scummy

- - - Post Merge - - -

No idea why they would kill Kate, but I am still thinking that maf has 3 KP. Yes this is an experimental game, but it fits the traditional KP system and scum:town ratio

im sry but u didnt answer my question, why do u think that mafia killed kate instead of oath?

 

[Dolby]

but antonio was being sussed yesterday, so u should know that at least someone is acting scummy

- - - Post Merge - - -



im sry but u didnt answer my question, why do u think that mafia killed kate instead of oath?

Because I think that there's 3 kp

 

[illunie]

Because I think that there's 3 kp

so the only reason that u think maf mustve killed kate is bc of the likelihood of there being 3 kp?

 

[Dolby]

so the only reason that u think maf mustve killed kate is bc of the likelihood of there being 3 kp?

Yes

 

[illunie]

Yes

alright, thanks for clarifying

 

[iLoveYou]

Okay let's play assume .. If Dolby is such a blue sniper, then why would he target Kate ?

- - - Post Merge - - -

How did she give blue vibes to be their Night One target ? Because obviously looking at her posts there is nothing there.

 

[illunie]

Okay let's play assume .. If Dolby is such a blue sniper, then why would he target Kate ?

- - - Post Merge - - -

How did she give blue vibes to be their Night One target ? Because obviously looking at her posts there is nothing there.

ive already explained this, check my previous reply

- - - Post Merge - - -

although according to ur teammate neither of u know what a doctor is : )