Mafia Call the Ships to Port: Game Thread - END GAME - TOWN VICTORY!
- Thread starter Chris
- Start date
well, I can respect that, but you better have another candidate
Also, wasn't the Dedenne lynch kinda based on her non-contribution, not her meta?
people on the bw were saying that she was acting differently from last game, yeah
It only makes sense that she is super eager because she doesn't know your recent meta. You used to be a more involved player when she was still around so your inactivity is a justified red flag for someone like her. And tbh at this point it even is for me. I've been jumping back and jumping ahead here and there so I forget who said it and when, but somebody cautioned that they were giving you a complete safety blanket to play a coasting scum game.
You saying you are mulling over the deaths specifically is something I don't like because in your one semi-big post on day 1 you mentioned that your excuse for not doing much on day 1 was that you prefer to scumhunt based on who dies so you mentioning it here in this post, immediately upon your return to the game, demonstrates that you are being very self aware of your meta and using your meta as a defense:
I?m not sure what you?re expecting from me? Ya?ll know I don?t take D1 seriously like at all, I think they?re the most boring part of the game. I like looking at the kills and then trying to tie back to people.
I still believe that Glow/Vanessa/Tom are all very compatible with each other, and have considering the possibility of all them being scum for quite awhile
Tbh, this is all kinda focused on being right on both Tom and Antonio's alignments. If I had to say for fourth's and fifth's though, I feel that Evan, Heyden, yourself, Trundle, Ghost (purely speculative for this one), Ryu, Mog, and Gig could all easily fit there. I have no ****ing idea how I'd organize these yet, and tbh, I'm less familiar with the players in this game the further I go down the playerlist (partly because I like to start from the top and go to the bottom, but it just takes so long)
I haven't fully explored the world of Antonio being scum here if I have to be honest, but the way that people have reacted has made me believe that one or the other is scum, and that one is far more likely to be Tom
- - - Post Merge - - -
although, Ryu/Ness would be a decent possibility to explore if I'm wrong about Tom
Oh don't be silly, you really have that big of a pool for the 4th and 5th spot?
You can't expect me to believe you don't have a more narrow view? You don't get more cues for me ryu heyden or evan? we've posted a lot by now!
Why did I go from Town lean to scum possibility?
You can't expect me to believe you don't have a more narrow view? You don't get more cues for me ryu heyden or evan? we've posted a lot by now!
Why did I go from Town lean to scum possibility?
Just noting here that both Ness and glow are complete opposites on this side of the debate over whether Antonio not knowing what blue roles are even though it can clearly be read into indicates a scumslip or not. My opinion? It's a scumslip if it's a forced dumbtell, so glow if you really think it was, explain to us and compare to how conscious he has been in other moments in the game if you want to argue that he is dumbtelling. I mean, I can get to it eventually anyways, but my chorelist with things to read into is getting bigger and bigger. :| I hate 20+ player games sometimes.
I think I decided that clearing you for having a really fast response was stupid, and I even made that note in my post or something
I'm literally clearing around 8 players for the last two spots and you consider that ****ing narrow?
This.
The most that I could find on her was people generally saying that she was to quiet and not defending herself at the time
This is like the umpteenth time Ghostkid has posted in the thread to explain that he is going to bed, saying they will be back later to check up on the thread, etc. He's not as blatant to saying he is also promising to come back with reads but it harkens back to the very reason glow suspected Dedenne and she's not doing the same with GhostKid. And glow thinks her approach is never wrong so that means she wasn't wrong about reading into frequency as connotation of scuminess.
Yes, I know that I can normally narrow it down accurately to a pool about a bit under twice the size of the actual size of the scumteam by D2. But frankly, I've been simply overwhelmed this game. On top of real life, there's a whole spate of new people I don't know how to read, a pleathora of what I feel are town v town wagons (which don't really help me determine who's scum), and many people who are for some reason not participating at all
I get that, this 25 person game is screwing with my head lol, BUT I've learned over time that you can't trust no one. I need to decide on a lynch really soon because I'll be at a wedding all day tomorrow.
In the past few posts you've demonstrated:
- Irregularities in play style (Vague scum-possibility-pools)
- Appeal to emotion (The bolded statement in your quote)
- Aggressive behavior (cursing basically)
And on these accounts I am voting you today
amazonevan19
DLELELEWOOOOP
We should set a deadline for voting Tom tbh. I think we should hold him to his word and vote him off maybe 4 hours before EoD or something. There’s been plenty of time to let the inactives speak, and while I think we have a lot of good candidates, Tom is supremely scummy in my view
sure if he literally posts nothing i could vote him, but thats pretty unlikely
I have to finish this chem paper so I honestly don't have time to ISO Dolby even though I think he's super scummy so I'm just gonna vote Tom rn so he talks or something. And anyone arguing against a Tom lynch, I wasn't really gonna change my mind unless something substantial came up so.
Although I don't want you to take this as an attack,:
It kinda freaks me out that we're still doing priority lynches day 2.
