Mafia Call the Ships to Port: Game Thread - END GAME - TOWN VICTORY!

[Heyden]

punchy’s claim feels fake but why is he confirmed scum I’m missing something

 

[Dolby]

Actually could see a world in which Punchy said that in discord as town in reference to Tim’s claim, but he was hard out going for the Antonio lynch, so he’s already a scumlock given the circumstances and his claim

 

[N e s s]

punchy’s claim feels fake but why is he confirmed scum I’m missing something

read my earlier posts

 

[EpicGamer12]

punchy’s claim feels fake but why is he confirmed scum I’m missing something

agreed, what am I missing here?

 

[illunie]

honestly punchy is reacting the exact same way to messing up than the last two games, i feel like this 'slip up' is kinda town indicative, he could justve said mafia joat bc he thought tom was scum

 

[Ghostkid]

https://media.giphy.com/media/26FPML6KpNajDH0SQ/giphy.gif

Punchy plz for the love of god...what is this?

 

[PunchyTheCat]

honestly punchy is reacting the exact same way to messing up than the last two games, i feel like this 'slip up' is kinda town indicative, he could justve said mafia joat bc he thought tom was scum

THIS

 

[Heyden]

read my earlier posts

OHMYGOD literally can't breath lmfao
ya bye punchy !!!!!!!!!!

 

[illunie]

Actually could see a world in which Punchy said that in discord as town in reference to Tim’s claim, but he was hard out going for the Antonio lynch, so he’s already a scumlock given the circumstances and his claim

so antonio scumlocking fireninja is just dumb town while punchy sussing antonio means hes scum?

 

[N e s s]

2. Messenger could have forgot to send in actions, if the messenger is scum, a theory I have is kind of like a JoaT, with the messenger being able to RB or frame or smth

going to requote this for those who missed it

1. Funny how there turned out to be a scum joat
2. Funny how Punchy just so happened to mention 2 of the Scum Joat's abilties

 

[EpicGamer12]

going to requote this for those who missed it

1. Funny how there turned out to be a scum joat
2. Funny how Punchy just so happened to mention 2 of the Scum Joat's abilties

O lol

 

[Dolby]

so antonio scumlocking fireninja is just dumb town while punchy sussing antonio means hes scum?

Fire ninja was never a viable alternative to Tom, so Antonio would’ve voted for me instead if he had wanted the vote off Tom

Antonio was a viable alternative and Punchy fought to keep it off Tom, including switching from Mog to Antonio

Honestly beginning to sus you for this

 

[illunie]

going to requote this for those who missed it

1. Funny how there turned out to be a scum joat
2. Funny how Punchy just so happened to mention 2 of the Scum Joat's abilties

ok thats really sus then lol. im hesistant to scumlock him tho, theres still a possibility that its a coincidence

 

[Jacob]

-_-
Tina just MK me now

scum crack

 

[PunchyTheCat]

going to requote this for those who missed it

1. Funny how there turned out to be a scum joat
2. Funny how Punchy just so happened to mention 2 of the Scum Joat's abilties

I'm a 10/10 genius

- - - Post Merge - - -

scum crack

was referring to OOTC

 

[Antonio]

I wasn't worried about tom, he was actually my backup choice.

 

[illunie]

going to requote this for those who missed it

1. Funny how there turned out to be a scum joat
2. Funny how Punchy just so happened to mention 2 of the Scum Joat's abilties

wait a min what would scum punchy have to gain from saying this? im trying to think of something he could gain from literally revealing his teammates role aside from looking like hes being useful but i cant

 

[amazonevan19]

Punchy and Runeraider's stocks are certainly crashing after that flip to be sure

I just read up on everything and am gasping for air laughing

 

[PunchyTheCat]

wait a min what would scum punchy have to gain from saying this? im trying to think of something he could gain from literally revealing his teammates role aside from looking like hes being useful but i cant

double this

 

[illunie]

double this

hey maybe u should defend urself and stop making me do it for u. why would u say ur suspicions about the joat role? u still havent answered that