Mafia Call the Ships to Port: Game Thread - END GAME - TOWN VICTORY!

[KermitTea]

ok but i still dont see a good reason for her to come picking after me so fast unless mog did something really bad

 

[illunie]

the evidence is too strong yet you are defending him which means either you guys are bffs or you know something that we don't that's influencing your actions aka u r mafia

- - - Post Merge - - -



what do u mean she switched to me because i'd be mk'd

if i were to be mk'd doesn't that mean they should NOT switch to me since i'm gonna die at the hands of tina anyway

i still dont think the case against punchy is 100 percent concrete, yes he predicted toms role but that could just be a coincidence and the only reason i can think of him doing it is to make himself look like hes contributing, which he could have done a million other ways than outright stating his teammates role. im probably not gonna be able to change the lynch but i want people to think through what punchy has done and why ppl might be pushing him.

 

[KermitTea]

ok let me rephrase

i dont see anything wrong with a little questioning yes questioning is good

but youre literally being his defense lawyer here or something and that to me is suspicious

 

[Heyden]

The rest of the lot (ordered)
Evan
Heyden
Ryu
Gig/Amanda
Jacob
Glow
Vampnessa

Evan and Heyden's placements are fairly solid within here, as are Glow's and Vanessa's. Ryu, Gig, and Jacob are all tossups within honestly

Fairly solid..? Is this your scum list or town list.

 

[illunie]

ok let me rephrase

i dont see anything wrong with a little questioning yes questioning is good

but youre literally being his defense lawyer here or something and that to me is suspicious

its more devils advocate tbh, i feel like if i was maf i wouldve dropped it a while ago

 

[Dolby]

Fairly solid..? Is this your scum list or town list.

This is the list of people who I don't feel especially solid about (though I do sus Vampnessa and Glow still). Higher up=townier, lower=scummier

 

[illunie]

This is the list of people who I don't feel especially solid about (though I do sus Vampnessa and Glow still). Higher up=townier, lower=scummier

o u couldve just said null reads lol

 

[cornimer]

I'm still pretty confident Rune is town tbh. Any scum would want to stay the heck away from Punchy rn. I see where he is coming from and why he is concerned, but the possibility of Punchy just coincidentally guessing Tom's role is just so much less likely than the possibility of him being scum. Why did he say Tom's role earlier? Either to appear helpful, or because frankly he kinda has a habit of blurting things out (like with Dolby in politics mafia)

- - - Post Merge - - -

Also I agree that Kermit/mog is probably town because punchy attempted to bandwagon her, also I townread ILY again for tunneling tom this whole time

- - - Post Merge - - -

Also also if this was answered I missed it but glow why did you vote for Fire Ninja??

 

[PunchyTheCat]

Also I agree that Kermit/mog is probably town because punchy attempted to bandwagon her

is that your only logic

 

[cornimer]

is that your only logic

Yup I think its all I need for the time being

 

[N e s s]

Hey I just realized something

If punchy's bomb explodes when he is lynched or killed then why is a Time Bomb Veteran? Time bombs explode after a period of time so theres kinda a discrepancy there

nitpick but something worth pointing out

 

[Ghostkid]

hello friends

i am

sussing:

punchy, for reasons stated 1000x in the thread

iloveyou, for picking me out as an easy target after i literally joined the game for less than 10 mins and had something to do

runeraider, the defense for punchy makes me uncomfortable as it seems way over the top. if in the slight chance punchy flips town this is probably scum

slight tr:

trundle, activity doesn't seem low enough for scum trundle

U say that ur susing ily for "making u an easy target"...but susing her for that little of a reason is also making her an easy target for u.
But thats none of my business.

 

[PunchyTheCat]

Hey I just realized something

If punchy's bomb explodes when he is lynched or killed then why is a Time Bomb Veteran? Time bombs explode after a period of time so theres kinda a discrepancy there

nitpick but something worth pointing out

idk go critique Tina about poor word choice

 

[Heyden]

Hey I just realized something

If punchy's bomb explodes when he is lynched or killed then why is a Time Bomb Veteran? Time bombs explode after a period of time so theres kinda a discrepancy there

nitpick but something worth pointing out

I'm wanna guess that the first or last person is the person that'll be affected by his power.
For this reason, Ghost should vote first and Antonio should vote last.

 

[illunie]

Hey I just realized something

If punchy's bomb explodes when he is lynched or killed then why is a Time Bomb Veteran? Time bombs explode after a period of time so theres kinda a discrepancy there

nitpick but something worth pointing out

o thats pretty true, i tried looking for smth like a time bomb but only bomb came up

 

[N e s s]

idk go critique Tina about poor word choice

does your role say that the bomb explodes immediately after being lynched or killed

 

[illunie]

I'm wanna guess that the first or last person is the person that'll be affected by his power.
For this reason, Ghost should vote first and Antonio should vote last.

thats not related to time tho right?

 

[cornimer]

Hey I just realized something

If punchy's bomb explodes when he is lynched or killed then why is a Time Bomb Veteran? Time bombs explode after a period of time so theres kinda a discrepancy there

nitpick but something worth pointing out

Because his claim is bogus

 

[Dolby]

I'm wanna guess that the first or last person is the person that'll be affected by his power.
For this reason, Ghost should vote first and Antonio should vote last.

No, Glow should vote first and Vanessa should vote last

 

[cornimer]

I'm wanna guess that the first or last person is the person that'll be affected by his power.
For this reason, Ghost should vote first and Antonio should vote last.

Huh?

- - - Post Merge - - -

No, Glow should vote first and Vanessa should vote last