Mafia Call the Ships to Port: Game Thread - END GAME - TOWN VICTORY!

[illunie]

now that ppl are providing actual arguments for a punchy sr im less paranoid about a mafia bw, im honestly not sure whether i believe punchy is being targeted or if hes maf tbh

- - - Post Merge - - -

Hey Rune I understand where you're coming from but can you please stop defending punchy because you're giving him a very large safety blanket right now, would prefer if you pressure him instead and then you can defend him if you judge him as town

ye i probably shouldve just let him explain, but i dont think he was gonna attempt to defend himself anyway so we

 

[N e s s]

can u stop with the personal insults pls ty

what im trying to say is that punchys role sounds plausible if u think about it from the perspective of a host. its doesnt seem to be just cobbled together from nothing, it actually has a purpose for town, while the bomb doesnt make sense for a scum player to have. the only way i could see the role being scum is if the bomb did smth that could only benefit scum, like kill a random blue role, and punchy withheld that information. i can see where ur coming from when u add in his actions over the past couple of days, but sussing him over his role is honestly a bad idea.

nobody has sussed him because of the role

everybody has sussed him because he said 2 of the actions of a revealed scum role

 

[EpicGamer12]

Can all of the town players who make good reads (glow/Dolby/iLoveYou/etc) make a solid reads list before end of night in case one or more of you die?

 

[illunie]

nobody has sussed him because of the role

everybody has sussed him because he said 2 of the actions of a revealed scum role

dolby was pointing out how he thinks he faked the role, im pretty sure thats sussing him for it

 

[Dolby]

dolby was pointing out how he thinks he faked the role, im pretty sure thats sussing him for it

Yeah, his role is fake as ****

- - - Post Merge - - -

REEEE I DIDN'T VOTE I THOUGHT THERE WAS ANOTHER DAY.

I'm going to sound like a hypocrite since I listed that as one of glow's suspicious behaviors. Honestly though, happy as I am that Tom flipped red, his lynch doesn't give a ton of information so we have to look at what other people did with Tom. Honestly I still feel pretty sus of glow because she avoided susing him for weird reasons, preferring to stay on Oath, and then today she hard-focused on Antonio having scumslipped. Will catch up once I am done with some irl stuff.

Can we get a reads list? Outside of just Glow?

 

[cornimer]

Just caught up lol bye punchy

 

[Ghostkid]

Yea...after all this punchy is my next up for lynch

 

[illunie]

ok now its going back to a mindless bw lol

 

[Ryumia]

Oh I forgot to say that this is actually a decent point. Idk when I first saw Punchy say this I immediately wondered if it could be a scum slip and there's a scum messenger that hasn't been using their powers. However I don't think it's very likely and I wouldn't legit sus him over it, but just a thought I had. I still think Punchy is most likely town (although he has started to become a little more quiet)

Vanessa... Can you explain this to me after what happened to Punchy? I want to know.

 

[PunchyTheCat]

Yea...after all this punchy is my next up for lynch

Just caught up lol bye punchy

Ffs
I could totally see Tom trying to tell Ghost to convince town to lynch him, and the fact that Dolby brought up something like "props for being the first one to vote Tom" sets off alarm bells everywhere.

Vanessa OH COME ON. NO REASONING, just no. Vanessa. I know you are a very skilled player and much better than this.

 

[Dolby]

The rest of the lot (ordered)
Evan
Heyden
Ryu
Gig/Amanda
Jacob
Glow
Vampnessa

Evan and Heyden's placements are fairly solid within here, as are Glow's and Vanessa's. Ryu, Gig, and Jacob are all tossups within honestly

 

[KermitTea]

hello friends

i am

sussing:

punchy, for reasons stated 1000x in the thread

iloveyou, for picking me out as an easy target after i literally joined the game for less than 10 mins and had something to do

runeraider, the defense for punchy makes me uncomfortable as it seems way over the top. if in the slight chance punchy flips town this is probably scum

slight tr:

trundle, activity doesn't seem low enough for scum trundle

 

[cornimer]

Vanessa... Can you explain this to me after what happened to Punchy? I want to know.

What do you want me to explain? I thought it was suspicious when he said that. It sounded like he was saying he knew there was a scum messenger. I have no idea if there is actually a scum messenger, but with the amount of scum roles he has slipped I wouldn't be surprised

 

[illunie]

hello friends

i am

sussing:

punchy, for reasons stated 1000x in the thread

iloveyou, for picking me out as an easy target after i literally joined the game for less than 10 mins and had something to do

runeraider, the defense for punchy makes me uncomfortable as it seems way over the top. if in the slight chance punchy flips town this is probably scum

slight tr:

trundle, activity doesn't seem low enough for scum trundle

wait why would i defend punchy if im scum and hes maf lol

- - - Post Merge - - -

i mean if hes town and im scum

 

[Dolby]

Ffs
I could totally see Tom trying to tell Ghost to convince town to lynch him, and the fact that Dolby brought up something like "props for being the first one to vote Tom" sets off alarm bells everywhere.

Ghost voted Tom both days. Tell me how he's scum then and I'll listen.

Like, I don't believe, given the wagons against me and Antonio, that resistance just didn't exist. Ghost as scum would 100% join said resistance, and his vote at one point would have switched who was in the lead. Like, you're basically arguing for a me/Ghost team here, which would also imply that Antonio would have to be scum as well

 

[cornimer]

Ffs
I could totally see Tom trying to tell Ghost to convince town to lynch him, and the fact that Dolby brought up something like "props for being the first one to vote Tom" sets off alarm bells everywhere.

Vanessa OH COME ON. NO REASONING, just no. Vanessa. I know you are a very skilled player and much better than this.

Why do I need reasoning you literally scumslipped like three times and also tried to keep the lynch off your partner

 

[Ghostkid]

Ffs
I could totally see Tom trying to tell Ghost to convince town to lynch him, and the fact that Dolby brought up something like "props for being the first one to vote Tom" sets off alarm bells everywhere.

Vanessa OH COME ON. NO REASONING, just no. Vanessa. I know you are a very skilled player and much better than this.

Convince town? Punchy if you look back at my posts u can clearly see that i do not know what im doing...and i dont think ive convinced anyone with the mediocore contributions if u can even call them that...that i post

 

[Dolby]

hello friends

i am

sussing:

punchy, for reasons stated 1000x in the thread

iloveyou, for picking me out as an easy target after i literally joined the game for less than 10 mins and had something to do

runeraider, the defense for punchy makes me uncomfortable as it seems way over the top. if in the slight chance punchy flips town this is probably scum

slight tr:

trundle, activity doesn't seem low enough for scum trundle

Kermit, assuming that Punchy is maf, I'm 97% sure that your slot is town. But I really think that 2/3 of your scumpicks are wrong here. ILY was basically tunneling Tom for most of two days here, and only switched to you bc she believed you'd be mked. Rune, I really think is just deceived town, but I'm not gonna argue as strongly against that

 

[KermitTea]

wait why would i defend punchy if im scum and hes maf lol

- - - Post Merge - - -

i mean if hes town and im scum

the evidence is too strong yet you are defending him which means either you guys are bffs or you know something that we don't that's influencing your actions aka u r mafia

- - - Post Merge - - -

Kermit, assuming that Punchy is maf, I'm 97% sure that your slot is town. But I really think that 2/3 of your scumpicks are wrong here. ILY was basically tunneling Tom for most of two days here, and only switched to you bc she believed you'd be mked. Rune, I really think is just deceived town, but I'm not gonna argue as strongly against that

what do u mean she switched to me because i'd be mk'd

if i were to be mk'd doesn't that mean they should NOT switch to me since i'm gonna die at the hands of tina anyway

 

[Dolby]

what do u mean she switched to me because i'd be mk'd

if i were to be mk'd doesn't that mean they should NOT switch to me since i'm gonna die at the hands of tina anyway

ermph
I meant that she believed that Tom would be mked