Mafia Critique Thread

[Arstotzkan]

I'm not too familiar with Tom's meta haha

Anyone have advice on how to calm your **** after a frustrating day of mafia?

 

[Cory]

I'm not too familiar with Tom's meta haha

Anyone have advice on how to calm your **** after a frustrating day of mafia?

A few wolfy pop ins will help

 

[tae]

also, someone pls critique me.
i know i don't have many games to go off of, but i'd really like some tips / pointers in order to find a better base for how i should be playing instead of making bad habits early on. i know i can't expect to be good right off the bat, but i'd really like some solid pointers in order to start myself on the right track! thank you.

still relevant pls.

 

[Minties]

I'm not too familiar with Tom's meta haha

Anyone have advice on how to calm your **** after a frustrating day of mafia?

I like the heated feeling, gives me a rush of adrenaline

Usually just play league/hots/some multi-player game where I can kill people!


@tae I'll have to read up on you to critique you properly!


People only really tell me to stop being mean in my critiques :|

 

[N e s s]

Why do i get scum read litterally the minute i post in any game I play on this site? I mean seriously this isn't an issue for me on mafia scum.

 

[Trent the Paladin]

I'm not too familiar with Tom's meta haha

Anyone have advice on how to calm your **** after a frustrating day of mafia?

Music, Netflix or gaming take your pick.

 

[N e s s]

can someone PLEASE tell me why i'm scumread no matter what the hell i say???

 

[Trent the Paladin]

can someone PLEASE tell me why i'm scumread no matter what the hell i say???

cuz you suck /s

I think it's probably because people are continuously going into games with mindsets from previous games, hence they let previous games influence the new ones a bit too much.

 

[PandaDarling]

why and how did ness's post get deleted form here and mine as well ? im confused.

 

[Damniel]

why and how did ness's post get deleted form here and mine as well ? im confused.

Post quality maybe? It was just a gif and a one worded reponse I think. So it would be deleted for having little substance

 

[PandaDarling]

Post quality maybe? It was just a gif and a one worded reponse I think. So it would be deleted for having little substance

what? is that a thing ? the picture was hilarious i was laughing so hard for a few minutes. i can just picture Ness's little face look at Tom with the same expression. oh man.

 

[Trent the Paladin]

what? is that a thing ? the picture was hilarious i was laughing so hard for a few minutes. i can just picture Ness's little face look at Tom with the same expression. oh man.

It is a thing. Tina and Justin lurk the Cellar, searching for new souls to drag screaming back into hell and to shackle to the walls. After Kayla escape, they tightened security.

I was hoping for Mentos Coke to at least roast my playstyle.

 

[Minties]

It is a thing. Tina and Justin lurk the Cellar, searching for new souls to drag screaming back into hell and to shackle to the walls. After Kayla escape, they tightened security.

I was hoping for Mentos Coke to at least roast my playstyle.

okay well I'll start the roast and finish it later-

as scum you're kind of annoyingly cocky and you tend to do "strange" things like claim roles outright when you're less inclined to claim when you're town. You also slip sometimes when trying to defend your team mates so I get really sus anytime you defend anyone. I literally always think you're scummy because you're mostly quiet until you get called out, then you post heaps.

In tarot, I had you pegged as scum as soon as Ness died because you tried to bus Tardis, but it made you look more scummy by not hammering in Ness.

I'll post a bit more later, finishing up an assignment

 

[N e s s]

But...this is the basement. Why would i get in trouble when literally people have games about posting memes.

 

[Chris]

But...this is the basement. Why would i get in trouble when literally people have games about posting memes.

The Cellar isn't as lax on rules as The Basement. Post quality rules still apply here.

It is a thing. Tina and Justin lurk the Cellar, searching for new souls to drag screaming back into hell and to shackle to the walls. After Kayla escape, they tightened security.

We will get that sneaky little role-blabber back. Someday. Just watch me.

 

[Qwerty111]

I'm horrible at scumreads. And as a result I'm very quiet. Can anyone help? Scumreading pointers? idk. I hope this is the right thread.

 

[Arstotzkan]

I'm horrible at scumreads. And as a result I'm very quiet. Can anyone help? Scumreading pointers? idk. I hope this is the right thread.

Well when someone posts, you wanna analyze their motivations for making a post. Is defending X person scummy or townie? Why are they defending them? Do their reasonings line up?

Hopefully that makes sense ^^"

 

[Chrystina]

Can it be like a ****ing rule NOT to type in peoples quotes?

I dont like seeing people type IN my quotes making me look like I said **** I didn't when Im dead, thanks.

 

[Dolby]

Can it be like a ****ing rule NOT to type in peoples quotes?

I dont like seeing people type IN my quotes making me look like I said **** I didn't when Im dead, thanks.

I do it because it's easier than making the BB codes for each quote

 

[Chrystina]

I do it because it's easier than making the BB codes for each quote

Well yeah breaking down someones one HUGE quote is annoying (I still do it) but I get that - at least put it in a diff color/italicized something

but if someones gonna take a bunch of quotes from someone might as well type underneath the quotes, not in them.