Mafia DA:I Mafia

[Geoni]

and the person who seems the most wishy washy to me is TheAhPo.... but i don't know if thats just they really don't know what they are doing or what...

I don't think you're reading tbh.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Also I'll probably provide some refreshed reads when it's not morning and I have to go to class soon.

 

[oath2order]

I also have to go to class and actually do work unlike Fallout playing Team Members. Learning and getting paid > mafia

listen here u lil ***

i already did my classwork for the day

and was home.

and i have today off

so don't judge me

you're a butt so I'm ##Vote Tom


nah but I'm going with who I thought was suspicious ##VOTE: Call me Daniel

 

[PandaDarling]

I don't think you're reading tbh.

i am reading its just that TheAhPo is reminding me too much of Slammint last game who turned out to be mafia

 

[PandaDarling]

@Daniel why are you self voting ??

 

[Arstotzkan]

Alright, finally got access to a computer.

@Daniel These are my reasons:

1) The conversation at the beginning of the day still leaves a bad taste in my mouth. Claiming to try to get town reads by being 100% off topic is eh. Not to mention you said you'd do it by making people get friendly with you, which... that sounds too much like you're trying to make allies rather than figure out what's going on.
2) The suspicion of Dad. Your reason (correct me if I'm wrong) is that Dad's been scumhunting, and because he has the capacity to lie, you think he's mafia. By that same logic, that would put Ender and me (and prob Labelle) under your scum category. Not to mention the suspicion in of itself lacks logic; how is someone having the ability to lie make them the most suspicious person out there?
3) Your reasoning for townreading Trojan rubbed me the wrong way. Because he was cool with you, you were cool with him? Again, that sounds like you're fishing for allies rather than the truth.
4) The dismissal of Ah's tactics. When he let go of his suspicion of Dad, you said his tactics were noob-like, implying that suspicion was bad in the first place. Not to mention if you so vehemently believed in Dad's guilt, you never asked for his reasoning for going around and voting/unvoting, which strikes me as odd.

I'll type more when I can, but the bell just rung so I gtg

 

[PandaDarling]

just reading back for like the fourth time and heres a few things that are a bit odd...

I'm suspicious of dad for similar reason that tom stated.

And why am I scum to you?

this bothers me Daniel cause you jump onto the Tom thing way to fast with not much substance of your own and no real explanation and then quickly changed the subject to why were you being scumread.

I thought that being friendly would make people more comfortable and possible slip up for feeling safe with me.

And I was just joking on Tom odviously, I meant that I agree with tom saying dad is a good liar and mafian though.

here i think you started to backpedal a bit and the whole being friendly thing is a little weird why would you need people to be friendly with you if your weren't mafia?

 

[N e s s]

i am reading its just that TheAhPo is reminding me too much of Slammint last game who turned out to be mafia

Your pointing fingers at me? You don't have any evidence nor reason there. Also what's wishy washy about my posts anyway?

 

[PandaDarling]

im not pointing the finger at you, all im saying is that your game play at the moment reminds me of Slammints game play last game.

- - - Post Merge - - -

but that might just be cause your new and eager to play.

 

[Trent the Paladin]

Gonna be busy today, so I don't really have time to look into Daniel or Trojan, but Pusheen's lazy vote for Daniel bugs me a lot especially since they completely ignored my post questioning it and instead when illuminatti 666 on me.

 

[PandaDarling]

Gonna be busy today, so I don't really have time to look into Daniel or Trojan, but Pusheen's lazy vote for Daniel bugs me a lot especially since they completely ignored my post questioning it and instead when illuminatti 666 on me.

ya i found that strange as well but didn't know what to do with it since its been nearly the only thing they've posted.

- - - Post Merge - - -

i think my vote is leaning towards Trojan theres just something about their response of being intimidated by dad at first that is uneasy with me and them trying to stick close to Daniel isn't a good sign i don't think we might have a Daniel / Trojan team here but i kinda feel like people are bandwagoning the Daniel vote which never seemed to work last game so im probably gonna vote Trojan as of now but we do still have anything 9 hours or so left.

 

[Arstotzkan]

Oh yeah Panda, you reminded me of something:

@Anyone who thinks Daniel/Trojan is marginally more suspicious than Trojan/Daniel to the point that a vote on Trojan/Daniel wouldn't be good: My question to Ender extends to you guys; why is it clearly better to vote for one rather than the other?

@Trojan It's been about a day. Where're the reads?

 

[illunie]

At this point it's not a joke vote anymore. Trojan is acting really scummily. Although I do believe that Daniel has a large chance of being mafia, all that's he's really done is fall for AhPow's bait. He hasn't been the only one jumping on to bandwagons either. Consider this post.

I don't like how hes going around pointing fingers at people. It makes me think taha the one pointing fingers is just doing it to make it seem that hes working for the town

And I don't know if Daniel is town but he hasn't said anything scummy so far so I just don't think he's mafia

And now he's voted for Daniel to get the vote for him off his back. Complete 180.

The problem with trying to put up a case against him though is that he's said practically nothing of value. All he's done is bantered and talked about non-relevant fluff. Daniel, on the other hand, has actually been trying to do something in the game and scumhunt. Trojan's behaviour is a classic case of newb mafia trying to look like they're active, but really only bantering every hour or two.

Boom. Case thing. And you guys thought I wasn't gonna try and d1 again.

- - - Post Merge - - -

*on

- - - Post Merge - - -

And just before LaBelle or someone comes on and asks me this, I would be fine with a Daniel lynch as I do think he is mafia, but I am much more confident about Trojan and would rather him be lynched.

 

[PandaDarling]

Oh yeah Panda, you reminded me of something:

@Anyone who thinks Daniel/Trojan is marginally more suspicious than Trojan/Daniel to the point that a vote on Trojan/Daniel wouldn't be good: My question to Ender extends to you guys; why is it clearly better to vote for one rather than the other?

@Trojan It's been about a day. Where're the reads?

im not exactly sure what you're saying here SarasaKat... i think it might be better to vote for Trojan if its a Trojan/Daniel mafia team cause Trojan isn't saying much and it might be easier to catch Daniel on something later sense his post tend to have more value to them, he seems to backpedal and get lost in what he is doing.

At this point it's not a joke vote anymore. Trojan is acting really scummily. Although I do believe that Daniel has a large chance of being mafia, all that's he's really done is fall for AhPow's bait. He hasn't been the only one jumping on to bandwagons either. Consider this post.



And now he's voted for Daniel to get the vote for him off his back. Complete 180.

The problem with trying to put up a case against him though is that he's said practically nothing of value. All he's done is bantered and talked about non-relevant fluff. Daniel, on the other hand, has actually been trying to do something in the game and scumhunt. Trojan's behaviour is a classic case of newb mafia trying to look like they're active, but really only bantering every hour or two.

Boom. Case thing. And you guys thought I wasn't gonna try and d1 again.

- - - Post Merge - - -

*on

- - - Post Merge - - -

And just before LaBelle or someone comes on and asks me this, I would be fine with a Daniel lynch as I do think he is mafia, but I am much more confident about Trojan and would rather him be lynched.

i feel very similar Rune... i was going back and readying and trying to find things to against Trojan but he just really aunt said much of anything to call him out on it...

- - - Post Merge - - -

hasn't *

 

[Arstotzkan]

@Panda I meant that if you thought person B would be a bad person to lynch because person A is significantly more scummy, why that is.

Woah Trojan voted Daniel? Holy **** lemme go check.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Yeah... ok that cements my vote in him.

 

[PandaDarling]

Trojans vote for Daniel cements your not for Trojan ?

 

[EnderWiggin]

Ugh so I fell asleep. In the middle of my ISOs.

Lemme go just fix em up.

 

[Arstotzkan]

Trojans vote for Daniel cements your not for Trojan ?

Cements that I'm voting Trojan. That, and Rune's point that Trojan has done literally nothing productive.

 

[illunie]

Daniel voted for himself.

WHYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY

 

[PandaDarling]

Daniel voted for himself.

WHYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY

i know i asked the same thing !!!

 

[EnderWiggin]

Spoiler: Call me Daniel

So let's start off the game! How's everyone doing tonight?

Intro, not worth much.

Nice, I'm staying up late just for this game. It's like 12 where I am now.

Banter

Wow lucky, what time zone are you in? It's est for me.

Also noticing that pusheen the cat has only ever had 2 posts...not sure if they'll be playing or not..

Banter

Ah I see, thanks for clarifying that for me

Banter

Yeah me too, I'm actually really excited to see how this will all turn out.

- - - Post Merge - - -



Good night?

Odd response? Still banter p much

Gonna wait for the others to start posting to see who's scummy

- - - Post Merge - - -



Ah I see, just make sure you'll be able to spend some time reading everyday, as you'll be mod killed if you don't vote.

Eh post.

I tried to convince my friends to join this game, but I guess they're not cool enough to play with us.

- - - Post Merge - - -



Well I meant as since the game just started, I want to give it time, as i have no scum reads right now.

Still banter. Also note: Daniel is a newer player, and so "I don't have scumreads" on early d1 shouldn't be particularly notable.

Nope, we 2 cool 4 them.

- - - Post Merge - - -



It all really depends on the players, just make sure you think before you post, as if you say something the wrong way might get you lynched.

Second part is eh.

It's more similar to Town of Salem, observance and team work is key.

Response.

When I put all my faith in LaBelle and payed off, good times.

Reminiscing.

Well, I do not believe It would be TheAhpo as they are new to the game and with more experienced players, a new player was probably not picked for mafia(if there is an experience bias). I would lean more towards yourself, but I have nothing to prove why I'm suspicious of any of you as of now.

Defending Ahpo.

I find your questioning pretty suspicious, you seem very keen on asking who we think is scum very early on. Ender and Sarsa did the same very early on if I recall, and ender was mafia.

- - - Post Merge - - -



I took it as them joking, as the game had literally just started.

- - - Post Merge - - -

And yourself Dad? Who is the most suspicious to you as of now?

Pretty much what I expected from him after me flipping mafia last game in the first half. Last end bit is decent.

I placed you as not suspicious, as you are new a more experienced player would most likely be chosen as mafia.

- - - Post Merge - - -


The only thing to fear is fear its self.

Returning to experience bias is irritating but not scummy.

I've been responding to everything because I wanted to start off the game with a friendly icebreaker. I also am trying to whittle out any reads I get from everyone, I want to see how they respond and I can try formulating an opinion from there.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I saw you voted for Trojan, Rune. Any reason why you voted other then to just annoy them like you said?

Eh.

Sup you all. Still reading back a bit.

- - - Post Merge - - -

#lynchdad2015 is so priceless.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I started the little chat just so that everyone started to talk, saying oh so who's suspicious is a pretty weird way to start off the game.

Interesting to note that they're commenting on Trojan's start being weird.

As stated before pusheen the cat is Trojan and runes real life friend so they will be playing. And slammint can come back on Thursday without posting too. Just because someone hasn't posted yet does not mean they will be modkilled, it's only day one and they can miss one lynching.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Last game, a few members didn't post until a couple of days later and still made it through until we decided to lynch them. You only get modkilled for breaking a rule.

Or for missing like, 3 days straight, or less depending. But semantics.

"Who do you have suspects about?"

You mean who I find scum?

Clarification.

I'm suspicious of dad for similar reason that tom stated.

And why am I scum to you?

Makes a joke out of Tom's post, but then comments they were suspicious for similar reasons?

They weren't mod killed, we lynched Bloobloop one night.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I don't know what you mean by defensive oath.

Clarification.

I thought that being friendly would make people more comfortable and possible slip up for feeling safe with me.

And I was just joking on Tom odviously, I meant that I agree with tom saying dad is a good liar and mafian though.

Clarification. Tbh this post makes me feel better about the earlier one about Tom.

I was going more for town slips.

Trojan you chill with me so I'm chill with you.

- - - Post Merge - - -

And Sarsa where is your avatar from? This is off topic but I'm curious.

Contradicts himself with a "I was more going for townslips". Or maybe not? But it's really weird phrasing if not.

When you have no clue what undertale is

Banter.

That's fine ender, I've been going through a rough patch too. But can you say why your choosing to lynch Trojan?

One of the many questions to me about why trojan.

For town?
Probably
Rune and pushee the cat, they seem to be just fooling around right now and I don't have any scum reads on them.

And probably your town too, no reads off of you yet.

And I don't understand what you mean by you were trying to trick me? I found it weird why you out of no where asked me who I thought was scum, but I answered Dad because I didn't have much to go on, the fact that your saying that you were trying to trick me, when it seems more as a coverup got your newness of anything.

Eh.

Hey guys, i'm feeling a bit down after some stuff that's been going on with my friends.

I'll be staying until the end of D1, but I probably won't be posting much, sorry.

Anyone have any questions for me?

Updating.

Sorry I didn't respond to your accusations of me. But I knew that tom was joking about lynching you, but i said that they are right in the fact that you have a certain way of posting, that seems very conniving and can convince anyone of any lies you spin.

And its fine of what you say, my rough patch shouldn't affect the game, so post whatever as i'll be fine.

Okay post.

I've read some previous games a while back, but didn't have the time to play a game until last game. Besides you could just tell by the way he analyzes and questions things, would you agree?

Makes sense.

Oh hey LaBelle, I'm assuming your reading through right now.

Poking Labelle

Your like me, I watch YouTube and go on tbt while studying for exams and assignments haha.

Banter

Just woke up and saw the voting thread, let me read back today.

Acknowledging his presence.

So wait your all lynching me for? I don't see why I'm being voted for to bed honest.

Questioning his lynch.

Conclusion:
Eh. He strikes me as REALLY eh. Tbh, this would be a fine Day 1 lynch for me. But at the same time, there's nothing that really strikes me as scummy?

Spoiler: Trojan

Does that mean it starts now?

derp

THIS POST. Okay so it's not a super scumtell or anything, but like, this post makes me think of how scum usually feel pressured to talk/participate.

Prettyyyyyy fantastic

Eh.

Really? That sucks it's 4pm for me now <3

Banter.

I live in Sydney - Australia so aedt right now. Pusheen the cat is Rune and I's IRL friend and he will be playing

Banter and information.

Sooooooooo

Who's suspicious

Okay this is like, a really EH post. I'm already willing to vote him over other people at this point.

Your friends aren't dank enough ( ͡? ͜ʖ ͡?)

Banter

That was one of the exact comparisons I made with the game when I played for the first time

Banter

You....... ( ͡? ͜ʖ ͡?)

Banter

your posts scare me ;_;

This post is notable too. Really EH about his weird "Dad scares me" thing.

The post that I made previously about asking who was suspicious was a joke as there was like no evidence. And Dad is scaring me because his posts are so analytical and he feels like a detective or something ;_;

Backtracking.

Rune is just that type of person

Banter

Ender why u no love me

Starts to respond to getting voted/poked.

I'm hereeeeeeeeee!

@SarasaKat I think Daniel is chill, he likes me so I like him

Funny that he later votes Daniel.

Sorry that I wasn't active btw, aedt time is weird so I was asleep

Information.

I don't like how hes going around pointing fingers at people. It makes me think taha the one pointing fingers is just doing it to make it seem that hes working for the town

And I don't know if Daniel is town but he hasn't said anything scummy so far so I just don't think he's mafia

Again, funny that he voted Daniel.

I love Undertale Best game of 2015 ahead of Fallout 4!

Banter

I've played both and over all even though Fallout 4 is a giant game with so much to do, I still had more fun with Undertale

Banter

Since when was I suspected of anything?

Odd post trying to deflect from suspicion on him.

U wot m8

Banter

Sorry for being inactive I'm in class right now. I still don't know why I'm being targeted right now though. As for town calls I'd say rune and pusheen the cat because they really don't care at this point. I dont know what to think about ender right now though, he seems to be targeting me and I don't know why.....

- - - Post Merge - - -

That made no sense at all it I'm typing Fast so.....

- - - Post Merge - - -

That made no sense at all it I'm typing Fast so.....

He keeps repeating the "I'm not suspected" "Ender is voting me and I don't know why thing.

Because I still don't understand why ender is hammering me like this when i haven't posted anything scummy :/

- - - Post Merge - - -

I was just trying to be friendly to everyone

"I haven't posted anything scummy."

Sorry guys for not being here for the past few hours, had a major test at school.

Apologises for being afk for a bit.

I might not post very much but I'll read everything as I'm gonna be studying while reading however I can write if there are any major things.

Information.

It's all a conspiracy :O

We're all actually just living in the matrix, controlled by a dog.....

Banter.

Conclusion:
Nothing constructive. All banter, eh posts, or just plain scumtells.

This guy is my vote.

Tl;Dr
Daniel has been really EH but hasn't actually really pinged hard.

Meanwhile Trojan has been unproductive while being active, generally useless to town, and on top of that says he has no suspicion of Daniel at the moment and then votes him.