Mafia DA:I Mafia

[PandaDarling]

Sarasakat... tbh everyone was posting those stupid "send your scum kills" post the other night. there was at least 3 of them.

 

[LaBelleFleur]

Sarasakat... tbh everyone was posting those stupid "send your scum kills" post the other night. there was at least 3 of them.

Joking around is an easy way to conceal your real suspicions.

 

[oath2order]

@Oath No one else suspicious, huh.
Why didn't you check Dad? Did your opinion of him change since this post here?

Y'know, I honestly can't answer that. I don't really know.

 

[Damniel]

While i would say Ahpo and Panda are acting weird, they've been doing this the whole game now and it's more just playing around then anything.

Oath has been getting really defensive now that people have been questioning him. Shows a sign of nervousness and being caught in my opinion. I'm keeping my vote for Oath because like i stated before he's trying to sway you all into his own bidding.

Also sarsa who do you think is scum now?

Anything else i need to add? No? okay back to me dragonsss~

 

[oath2order]

While i would say Ahpo and Panda are acting weird, they've been doing this the whole game now and it's more just playing around then anything.

Oath has been getting really defensive now that people have been questioning him. Shows a sign of nervousness and being caught in my opinion. I'm keeping my vote for Oath because like i stated before he's trying to sway you all into his own bidding.

Also sarsa who do you think is scum now?

Anything else i need to add? No? okay back to me dragonsss~

I don't think I'm defensive, I think I'm answering the questions in a level-headed manner.

 

[Arstotzkan]

Sarasakat... tbh everyone was posting those stupid "send your scum kills" post the other night. there was at least 3 of them.

No, but he was being serious about it. That's how he showed his suspicion of Tom.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Yikes... I guess we know who to lynch if LaBelle flips town, at least.

 

[Damniel]

It's also funny how this is what happened with Ender. Person claims to be a blue role(Oath and Trojan) and everyone votes on the actual blue role (Ender and LaBelle).

 

[LaBelleFleur]

dude ive thought that labelle is scum all game

- - - Post Merge - - -

freaking marmalade dino

You keep saying stuff like this, but you never back up your statements with any evidence, so...

My guess on your thought process when night started was "oh crap, oath survived and now he's asking my role, i need to quickly come up with a plausible story. everybody claims townie so i'll come up with a PR that can't exactly be proven but is enough to shake off whatever he says"

Again, sounds great in theory, but if I were mafia, why would I want to throw suspicion on myself by claiming a PR? In that situation, it would be more beneficial for me to explain how someone who claimed townie was scum, rather than put suspicion on myself then have to defend against attacks. There?s no way I?d claim a PR, especially not town role-blocker.

i was looking at that too... someone asked her about Trojan and she didnt say anything until way later when he had pretty much already sealed his on fate, then she had to scum read him cause he outed himself.

To be completely honest? It was sheer laziness. I was feeling quite sick & tired and didn't feel like analyzing, so I quickly read through the arguments against both Daniel & Trojan, and decided that at that point in time, I found Daniel scummier than Trojan. So I put my thoughts out on Daniel so that I wouldn't get accused of not posting my reads, being indecisive, etc. By the time I was feeling better & ready to put out reads on everyone, Ender was the new target, so nothing I said really mattered. :/

 

[PandaDarling]

No, but he was being serious about it. That's how he showed his suspicion of Tom.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Yikes... I guess we know who to lynch if LaBelle flips town, at least.

but we can't keep playing like that or we'll lose the mafia is one step ahead of us if we keep mislynching...

- - - Post Merge - - -

D@mn IT !!! i wish there was more evidence.... Oath is there anyway you can prove your the detective ?

 

[N e s s]

but we can't keep playing like that or we'll lose the mafia is one step ahead of us if we keep mislynching...

- - - Post Merge - - -

D@mn IT !!! i wish there was more evidence.... Oath is there anyway you can prove your the detective ?

No, there's no evidence for him to use.

also love ya panda

 

[Arstotzkan]

but we can't keep playing like that or we'll lose the mafia is one step ahead of us if we keep mislynching...

- - - Post Merge - - -

D@mn IT !!! i wish there was more evidence.... Oath is there anyway you can prove your the detective ?

I know.. which is why I'm trying to analyze this and see what's going on. I don't want to get played, but I don't want to overthink this either. It's a tricky balance we're dealing with here.

 

[oath2order]

It's also funny how this is what happened with Ender. Person claims to be a blue role(Oath and Trojan) and everyone votes on the actual blue role (Ender and LaBelle).

What I want to know is how you are far more convinced that LaBelle is blue.

Again, sounds great in theory, but if I were mafia, why would I want to throw suspicion on myself by claiming a PR? In that situation, it would be more beneficial for me to explain how someone who claimed townie was scum, rather than put suspicion on myself then have to defend against attacks. There?s no way I?d claim a PR, especially not town role-blocker.

It wouldn't exactly be throwing suspicion on yourself when it's a PR that can't exactly prove anything. A mafia member can easily claim to be Detective, however, will end up being a very ineffective fake-Detective because all they'll be able to do is confirm people as town. If the fake DT claims someone as mafia, and they flip town, they instantly get lynched.

If you try and fake yourself a town roleblocker, it's fairly easy as you don't have to explain your actions, and nobody knows if you're telling the truth or not. Townies typically don't get told if they are blocked, as townies do not have actions to block, and most PRs won't say they were blocked as that would out them. There is no way to verify with other players what a fake-claimed roleblocker has done each night.

Slammint, Pusheen, we're getting to the end of day, any thoughts?

 

[PandaDarling]

LaBelle who do you think the other mafia are ?

- - - Post Merge - - -

same question to Oath as well please and why ?

 

[Arstotzkan]

While i would say Ahpo and Panda are acting weird, they've been doing this the whole game now and it's more just playing around then anything.

Oath has been getting really defensive now that people have been questioning him. Shows a sign of nervousness and being caught in my opinion. I'm keeping my vote for Oath because like i stated before he's trying to sway you all into his own bidding.

Also sarsa who do you think is scum now?

Anything else i need to add? No? okay back to me dragonsss~

I think LaBelle? Tbh I'm not really sure. Reasons are everything in this game, and if Oath can't provide one for why he checked LaBelle in the first place, then that makes me a LOT less confident in him. But there's still the fact that a sheriff result is a sheriff result, and I've yet to see why he would BS his result.

 

[PandaDarling]

I think LaBelle? Tbh I'm not really sure. Reasons are everything in this game, and if Oath can't provide one for why he checked LaBelle in the first place, then that makes me a LOT less confident in him. But there's still the fact that a sheriff result is a sheriff result, and I've yet to see why he would BS his result.

im right there with you Sarasakat... he's reasoning for investigating Labelle was that Dad was suspicious of her before he got MURDERED !!! and im ok with that... i think its understandable.... i mean out of everyone else left who else would he have investigated really ? ? ? there wasn't much of a led on anyone else.

 

[oath2order]

LaBelle who do you think the other mafia are ?

- - - Post Merge - - -

same question to Oath as well please and why ?

This past day has been excellent in terms of debate and it's given me some insight into who exactly is playing for what team. For the most part at least. These are all based off of this past day.

Scum
LaBelleFleur - Mafia, of this I am 100% sure.
Call Me Daniel - Mafia. 85% sure, and an inspection will hopefully prove that. His rabid defense of LBF, his belief of her roleclaim without any evidence to back it up, and his sudden belief that I'm mafia despite going many days without really saying anything about me are all fairly damning in my eyes

Likely Town
SarasaKat - Giving us very reasonable questions, grilling both of the two people accused of scum during this day fairly equally.
Panda1376 - Mostly
TheAhPoCawdOh - I'm iffy on you. I can't tell if your fighting with Panda is a very clever ruse to distract town or not.

Too Little Evidence to Tell
Pusheen the Cat - :/
Ashtot - He's ****-posted.
Capella - I can't really say anything.
Slammint - I have no clue.

I think LaBelle? Tbh I'm not really sure. Reasons are everything in this game, and if Oath can't provide one for why he checked LaBelle in the first place, then that makes me a LOT less confident in him. But there's still the fact that a sheriff result is a sheriff result, and I've yet to see why he would BS his result.

My reasoning was that I didn't really have any major readings one way or another at that point, so I just went with whoever the most experienced thought was suspicious, I guess. I suppose, in retrospect, I should have checked anybody in my Too Little Evidence to Tell section, they were who I was considering just based off inactivity before I read some more posts.

 

[LaBelleFleur]

Regardless, claiming a PR over a townie is asking to be scrutinized, something a mafia member would never want.

LaBelle who do you think the other mafia are ?

I'm really not sure. I need to read back and analyze everyone's interactions and whatnot, but if I had to pick someone here and now, I'd say Pusheen. (This is going by my theory that there are two mafians left, so Oath & one more mafian.) They've been so quiet all game, and when they have piped up, it's been to voice their uncertainty or repeat something that's already been said. It could be that it's their first game and they're not sure how to contribute, but it could also be a mafian not sure how to post in a way that makes them appear town.

 

[Arstotzkan]

im right there with you Sarasakat... he's reasoning for investigating Labelle was that Dad was suspicious of her before he got MURDERED !!! and im ok with that... i think its understandable.... i mean out of everyone else left who else would he have investigated really ? ? ? there wasn't much of a led on anyone else.

He didn't know that at the time though. And he was apparently suspicious of Dad at a time, and that suspicion vanished, so I'm not liking that a lot.

@Oath It's more that your suspicion for Dad disappeared without much reason. Otherwise, I'd probably do something similar to what you did tbh

 

[oath2order]

He didn't know that at the time though. And he was apparently suspicious of Dad at a time, and that suspicion vanished, so I'm not liking that a lot.

@Oath It's more that your suspicion for Dad disappeared without much reason. Otherwise, I'd probably do something similar to what you did tbh

When was I suspicious of Dad?

 

[Arstotzkan]

Alright dad send your scum kill

This.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Was that a troll then, or?