Mafia DA:I Mafia

[oath2order]

This.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Was that a troll then, or?

Yeah, it was. TBH I wasn't really taking the game entirely seriously up until this day started

 

[PandaDarling]

i still think he was trollin' there... idk i tried to go back and find it earlier but i couldnt what page is that on ?

 

[Damniel]

Yeah, it was. TBH I wasn't really taking the game entirely seriously up until this day started

So you've been suspicious of LaBelle this whole time yet you say you were taking nothing seriously until today? Uh okay.

- - - Post Merge - - -

This past day has been excellent in terms of debate and it's given me some insight into who exactly is playing for what team. For the most part at least. These are all based off of this past day.

Scum
LaBelleFleur - Mafia, of this I am 100% sure.
Call Me Daniel - Mafia. 85% sure, and an inspection will hopefully prove that. His rabid defense of LBF, his belief of her roleclaim without any evidence to back it up, and his sudden belief that I'm mafia despite going many days without really saying anything about me are all fairly damning in my eyes

Likely Town
SarasaKat - Giving us very reasonable questions, grilling both of the two people accused of scum during this day fairly equally.
Panda1376 - Mostly
TheAhPoCawdOh - I'm iffy on you. I can't tell if your fighting with Panda is a very clever ruse to distract town or not.

Too Little Evidence to Tell
Pusheen the Cat - :/
Ashtot - He's ****-posted.
Capella - I can't really say anything.
Slammint - I have no clue.



My reasoning was that I didn't really have any major readings one way or another at that point, so I just went with whoever the most experienced thought was suspicious, I guess. I suppose, in retrospect, I should have checked anybody in my Too Little Evidence to Tell section, they were who I was considering just based off inactivity before I read some more posts.

So the only 2 people who have doubted you are on your scum list?

 

[PandaDarling]

Sarasakat what do you think of Oath and Labelle's reads ?

 

[Arstotzkan]

i still think he was trollin' there... idk i tried to go back and find it earlier but i couldnt what page is that on ?

You can click the arrows next to the post, and it brings you to where the post is.

I'm on 40 posts per page, but iirc it was around page 18 for me. It was about half way through N1.

 

[oath2order]

So you've been suspicious of LaBelle this whole time yet you say you were taking nothing seriously until today? Uh okay.

Please actually read. I have described my thoughts on LaBelle and my general suspicions numerous times but I guess I can reiterate it.

I have had no strong readings one way or another for the first two days. I basically just followed whatever was going on with town at that point. I inspected LaBelle because I saw Dad mentioned he was suspicious of her, so I figured that Dad was experienced, he probably had something good, so I figured I'd inspect her to help out. I was not actually suspicious of her when I inspected, however, I became 100% suspicious after I got the results back.

 

[PandaDarling]

I can't do that I'm a jester!

No thats trojan!!!

- - - Post Merge - - -

Legit question how much time left

this is the exchange between Dad and Oath, to me is seems like a joke... he even says "legit question...." meaning his not joking anymore...


and thanks Sarasakat about the arrow thing you just made me like 100X easier... haha

- - - Post Merge - - -

sarasakat how do you not see that as joking ?

 

[Arstotzkan]

@Daniel I think you're thinking of Ashtot.

@Panda They both seemed pretty solid. I liked that Oath gave his reads for everyone, and I liked how LaBelle went into depth regarding why she thought Pusheen. Though I think scum!Daniel definitely makes more sense than scum!Pusheen (especially if LaBelle flips mafia). That being said:

@LaBelle Who would you read as town atm?

- - - Post Merge - - -

this is the exchange between Dad and Oath, to me is seems like a joke... he even says "legit question...." meaning his not joking anymore...


and thanks Sarasakat about the arrow thing you just made me like 100X easier... haha

- - - Post Merge - - -

sarasakat how do you not see that as joking ?

Now that he clarified his stance, I see it as joking. Thanks for reminding me to ask Oath of something though.

@Oath What from before can we take seriously? Was your Tom suspicion or your Ender vote legit?

 

[PandaDarling]

Labelle so your telling me that if Oath gets lynched today then the next person you wanna lynch is Pusheen ?

 

[oath2order]

@Daniel I think you're thinking of Ashtot.

@Panda They both seemed pretty solid. I liked that Oath gave his reads for everyone, and I liked how LaBelle went into depth regarding why she thought Pusheen. Though I think scum!Daniel definitely makes more sense than scum!Pusheen (especially if LaBelle flips mafia). That being said:

@LaBelle Who would you read as town atm?

- - - Post Merge - - -

Now that he clarified his stance, I see it as joking. Thanks for reminding me to ask Oath of something though.

@Oath What from before can we take seriously? Was your Tom suspicion or your Ender vote legit?

Ender was a bandwagon. Trojan was a bandwagon.

Tom suspicion was a joke.

For the most part, before this day, it was a joke/****-post. My third-party bit on Trojan was nothing more than stupid paranoia.

 

[LaBelleFleur]

@LaBelle Who would you read as town atm?

Some quick reads:

SarasaKat: Solid town. Questioning everything and has been from the get-go.

Call Me Daniel: Town. Been fairly certain of it since he posted his reads late D1, but the fact that he's not immediately jumping on the bandwagon to lynch me, and is bringing up some decent points solidifies it.

Pusheen the Cat: Potential mafia. See above.

Slammint: Wasn't sure about her before, but reading back in the thread, I'm pretty sure she's town. She's just kind of bumbling about, doing whatever - pretty sure that if she had a mafia team backing her, they would've told her to cut it out a while back.

Panda1376: Null for now, not because there's not enough to go off of, but because I haven't had a chance to fully analyze your interactions with TheAhPoCawdOh yet.

Capella: Null because they've done absolutely nothing. Could be potential mafia, since I see they've bandwagoned on my lynch.

Ashtot: Despite you going after me the entire game with no evidence, I believe you're town because I believe Oath faked his save claim, so by extension I think your claim is true.

TheAhPoCawdOh: Null for the same reason as Panda.

oath2order: Scum scum scum.

Labelle so your telling me that if Oath gets lynched today then the next person you wanna lynch is Pusheen ?

I need to do some serious reading back before I commit to anything. You asked who I thought was scum, and if I had to pick this instant, I'd pick Pusheen.

 

[N e s s]

Ender was a bandwagon. Trojan was a bandwagon.

Tom suspicion was a joke.

For the most part, before this day, it was a joke/****-post. My third-party bit on Trojan was nothing more than stupid paranoia.

So you're telling me that this was all a joke to you since D1?

You're saying this now?

How exactly can somebody of town alignment be thinking that, considering this is the only form of communication?

 

[oath2order]

So you're telling me that this was all a joke to you since D1?

You're saying this now?

How exactly can somebody of town alignment be thinking that, considering this is the only form of communication?

Did you see Tom posting?

He basically took it as a joke and he's town alignment.

 

[N e s s]

Did you see Tom posting?

He basically took it as a joke and he's town alignment.

What does tom have to do with my question? You've basically just said you don't care about Towns most effective scum hunting tool serious.

And who would have the outlook of this? Scum.

- - - Post Merge - - -

*insert taking in that sentence.*

 

[oath2order]

What does tom have to do with my question? You've basically just said you don't care about Towns most effective scum hunting tool serious.

And who would have the outlook of this? Scum.

- - - Post Merge - - -

*insert taking in that sentence.*

Okay, I have to spell it out for you.

Tom was joking around during day one.

Tom was town.

Just because you joke around doesn't mean you're scum.

 

[PandaDarling]

im sorry Labelle... those reads don't really supply any information they are way to general for me. and the only person you are scum reading at the minute is Pusheen ? someone who's only posted like 5 times and aren't here to say anything. that doesn't sit right with me.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Okay, I have to spell it out for you.

Tom was joking around during day one.

Tom was town.

Just because you joke around doesn't mean you're scum.

try not to get frustrated Oath, thats what its like dealing with him he asked the same question about 5 times in different ways... and your all wondering why i find him annoying.

 

[Arstotzkan]

Some quick reads:

SarasaKat: Solid town. Questioning everything and has been from the get-go.

Call Me Daniel: Town. Been fairly certain of it since he posted his reads late D1, but the fact that he's not immediately jumping on the bandwagon to lynch me, and is bringing up some decent points solidifies it.

Pusheen the Cat: Potential mafia. See above.

Slammint: Wasn't sure about her before, but reading back in the thread, I'm pretty sure she's town. She's just kind of bumbling about, doing whatever - pretty sure that if she had a mafia team backing her, they would've told her to cut it out a while back.

Panda1376: Null for now, not because there's not enough to go off of, but because I haven't had a chance to fully analyze your interactions with TheAhPoCawdOh yet.

Capella: Null because they've done absolutely nothing. Could be potential mafia, since I see they've bandwagoned on my lynch.

Ashtot: Despite you going after me the entire game with no evidence, I believe you're town because I believe Oath faked his save claim, so by extension I think your claim is true.

TheAhPoCawdOh: Null for the same reason as Panda.

oath2order: Scum scum scum.I need to do some serious reading back before I commit to anything. You asked who I thought was scum, and if I had to pick this instant, I'd pick Pusheen.

What do you think about Daniel radically changing his opinion of Oath from not suspicious to scum when he said he was cop, then? And what were your thoughts about Oath prior to D3?

Also, kinda getting critical here so:
@ANYONE WHO SUPPORTS THE OATH LYNCH:
Why did Oath claim Sheriff?

 

[LaBelleFleur]

im sorry Labelle... those reads don't really supply any information they are way to general for me. and the only person you are scum reading at the minute is Pusheen ? someone who's only posted like 5 times and aren't here to say anything. that doesn't sit right with me.

I don't have a ton to say at the moment because I really need to go back, read everything over again, analyze, and put my thoughts together, which will take me a while. I just wanted to post something quick in response to Kat's question to show where my head's at. I've made my thoughts on Oath quite clear, and he's my only strong scum-read at the moment. My suspicions on Pusheen are more along the line of "if Oath is scum, then who's likely to be his mafia buddy?", which I don't want to take a ton of stock in until I know 100% whether Oath is mafia or not (or I'm dead. In which case, Oath is 99.99% mafia).

 

[PandaDarling]

What do you think about Daniel radically changing his opinion of Oath from not suspicious to scum when he said he was cop, then? And what were your thoughts about Oath prior to D3?

Also, kinda getting critical here so:
@ANYONE WHO SUPPORTS THE OATH LYNCH:
Why did Oath claim Sheriff?

i second that question..... the only thing oath is doing by claim he's detective is painting himself into a corner with no where to move after this if Labelle flips town.

 

[Arstotzkan]

I don't have a ton to say at the moment because I really need to go back, read everything over again, analyze, and put my thoughts together, which will take me a while. I just wanted to post something quick in response to Kat's question to show where my head's at. I've made my thoughts on Oath quite clear, and he's my only strong scum-read at the moment. My suspicions on Pusheen are more along the line of "if Oath is scum, then who's likely to be his mafia buddy?", which I don't want to take a ton of stock in until I know 100% whether Oath is mafia or not (or I'm dead. In which case, Oath is 99.99% mafia).

So uh. You're not confidant Oath is mafia?