Apple2013
kallie
Chick
amazonevan19
Seroja
Sej
toadsworthy
Zendel
Tom
N e s s
mogyay
ITookYourWaffles
Ex.
Null, weak town read, strong town read, weak scum read, strong scum read.
I hate having so many people as null, D1 is just very difficult to get proper reads on people.
Trundle is null due to lack of posting, I'll need to see how he contributes from now on to form an opinion (his posts since he started posting are having me town lean him though, nothing is off).
Sej is null due to lack of posts also, I know this is his first game though. I'm not going to scum read people D1 just for being inactive.
I have
kallie as strong town read, probably my strongest at the moment, it's pretty obvious, she's probably contributed the most out of everyone and seems like she's really on towns side, she's done nothing to make me think otherwise or even doubt myself at all. Good posts, thought provoking, really helping, just exuding strong town player imo.
Toad is also town for me, I've played a few games with him at this point and everything just strikes me as regular town toad, nothing to make me think otherwise yet. I agree with pretty much everything he's said and brought up so far.
I've put
Chick as scum lean, although when I think about it I'm doubting myself here, reading over what she's said and the things people are scum reading her for honestly just seem like newbie moves, I look at how I played as town when I was new and I made a lot of the same mistakes (such as pushing for a NL), I'm sure if she really was maf and had experienced players on her scum team they would have explained to her not to say that? Experienced scum know not to push for a NL, then again she isn't experienced, so I don't know. The aggressiveness, attempting to strike people's emotions, "threats", they all make me have that doubt - that doubt that she could be scum after all. I'm just not sure, people jumped on her so early, of course she's going to get defensive?
This is a difficult one, because I'm finding it hard to read
amazonevan19, but I feel the way he's been getting defensive, as well as what I mentioned before on his case on Chick, as well as slight flip-flopping, nothing really sits well with me here. I agree with
toads post below regarding Evan;
I still feel he has some sort of agenda to each of his posts (besides the ones where he exploded on me which I also found scumminess in) and feel more confident voting for him over chick rn.
Everything seems to be calculated and over-thought, and not in a helpful town kind of way.. in more of a devious way honestly. At the same time he comes across a good player, and I always find it hard to read good players when they're scum.
Everything seems good and townish with
Seroja too, there's not one thing that's made me thing "she's town!" but just everything in general gives off a town vibe, based on previous games with her too (although I have badly misread her before..)
Tom is also a slight scum lean, although I was hovering over this for a while, he's really hard to read. I mentioned it before, when someone is costing, better still, self-proclaimed coasting, it's going to be very hard to get a word out of them or form an opinion. However, this one post here;
I mean if you guys really want to Lynch me, by all means go for it. It would just be a wasted Lynch, especially since the few times I've been a survivor I'll always leaned more heavily to helping town (Xeno maf for example). I get that claiming right out the gate is kinda sus and probably something Scum!Tom would do but like there's no real point in keeping quiet about it. Worst case town or scum shoots me, best case I get to coast to the winners circle.
Is confusing to me, you're going to coast, but you still make a "defense" of sorts stating how lynching you would be a wasted lynch? I know it's nothing, I just find it
very slightly odd. It seems like something mafia would say to make sure they get an extra day, y'know? If you've always leaned more to helping town, why don't you do that instead of coast by, if you're really town? The mention of "Scum!Tom" in ways to convince people you're not scum this time doesn't sit well with me either.
I'm really torn on
ness, half null / slight town right now, but I find a lot of the way he's been acting for such an experienced player to be off, he was really quick to "write off" Evan so to speak just after he made one post that he agreed with? Then back-tracking to say he didn't write him off? I need to look into him a bit more because this is weak reasoning, he's just not completely exuding town to me, some things are
off, I see ness as someone with strong reasoning (based on previous games) but that seems to be a little missing here, not sure it's scummy though.
mog is town lean for me too, she's been contributing and adding her points, everything seems on point but nothing too clear so I don't want to be quick to fully town read her. I agree with a lot of the points she has made so far.
ITookYourWaffles. Half null because I'm unsure. Half weak scum read because of the dismissive tone when answering the RQS, very non serious overall? yet still seems to be helping town by popping in with questions every-so-often. Have you played any other mafia games here, if so which ones? I'd like to read up on your play style a little bit because I'm not sure if I'm reading into things that don't matter just because I'm not aware if this is how you usually play or not.
Zendel also half slight scum read, he was very quick to get the RQS out and answered, but he's been very quiet since then? It was a good start but the sudden decrease in activity from him strikes me as off, what
mog said here pretty much sums up why I'm scum leaning him slightly for this. In what I've seen from him, he's usually out spoken, accusing people, getting defensive, ect., this nothingness is unusual.
also im kinda used to seeing zendal call ppl out, i know he posted earlier but only to say the thread is dead, didnt really contribute much
---
Right now, I too would also feel more confident lynching Evan over Chick, from everything I've said. However, if Chick is lynched and flips town then my eyes go straight to Evan, if she flips scum then my read on him changes.
