I realize this original thread is so old that the OP no longer cares, but I could not resist weighing in on one of my favorite personality types and design groups.
I think the sisterly villagers have some very interesting and unique designs, and the personality is so fun!
Except for Mira and Rocket, I pretty much think they are all excellent in their own ways.
My favorites are: Agnes, Reneigh, Deirdre, Ursala, Muffy, Charlise, Shari, Fuchsia, Pashmina, Renee
others I think are great who I either haven’t seen enough to decide on, don’t fit my personal aesthetic, or didn’t click for me - Phoebe, Flo, Tammy, Frita, Paula, Hazel,
growing on me - diva, katt, Canberra, plucky, cherry
doesn’t work for me cause I can’t deal with the kangaroos - Sylvia, who I think otherwise is all right.
No, never - rocket and Mira
I hope they add more sisterly villagers and don’t tone the style down at all! I would love for there to be a sisterly hamster, because I just love the hamsters. I think a duck would also be great as a sisterly villager. A tiger might be nice to have too. And though I don’t like them much as a species, I feel like people would love a wolf villager.
There definitely are too few, which I think contributes to the sense of the designs being worse. People’s taste are so varied that with a group of 71 different designs, more people are sure to be able to find at least one or two they like, as opposed to a group only about 1/3 the size.