I like my toast at 3 or 8, but unfortunately my toast usually comes out between 1 and 2.
During the initial toast it always comes out as a 9, which is way too pale for me (and somehow upping the toasting time doesn't help make it toastier). So after that I usually go for a second round of toasting, planning to leave it in there for only for like 20 more seconds, IMMEDIATELY forget about it, run off to do something else and come back to the kitchen all confused because I smell something burning. :]
As for toppings I like almost everything in the poll, but also savoury things like cheese, pickles etc etc.