you can talk about things, don't feel pressured bc people shut you down. it's a valid point -- assuming probability makes 0 sense when maf is rng every game
It's not really a case in that I felt pressured to not say anything (because I did), it's that she just kinda ignored what I had to say for some reason. I made a rebuttal here:
So, I do agree with glow in that this is the scummiest thing that Epona has said so far. I think it's common sense not to try and speculate on the Kingmaker's identity, whether she meant to or not, and I can see her making this comment after it being on her mind for a while. I do find it a little more jarring considering that Epona had no reason to point this out in the first place, as in the previous page she was just arguing with you.
my qualm with what she said is that it rules her out as km, especially with me already making the stupid play to out my role as townie. it narrows down the pool for mafia, which imo is an anti-town play
it makes no logical sense for km to theorize km's motives publicly, and i think epona's choice would've been more methodical than on volt for the sole reason of probability (bc it's not applicable here). obviously nothing against volt as king, but i can't see any scenario where it makes sense
WIFOM. The KM doesn't want to be found and killed, so publicly theorizing throws you off. Publicly saying "it's not Epona" is a problem because it narrows down the pool of who to go for to get the KM for the mafia - as you rightly said. So trying to clear Epona of the role now on D1 when there's no mechanical proof of such a thing isn't beneficial.
you're right, but imo it's scummy as hell still. obviously i'm theorizing and we don't know
You're right, but that's gonna be a tactic saved for endgame time because doing it while there's town left to be made King the following day, it's gonna be a bit heckin obvious who to lynch
Care to elaborate?
I agree, it doesn’t really seem to do us any good because it’ll just make them a target
True, but a motion tracker doesn't normally get told the role. If KM "visited" someone who also got visited by mafia, they'd die. If the tracker followed the KM, it would appear to the tracker as if the KM killed 'em. Also roleblockers says "all actions but kingmaker selection may be blocked" implying it could be. So I don't think it's a terrible question. Unless this is Shawo's attempt at softclaiming the tracker. Then it's a bad question.
