• Guest, you're invited to help build our new TBT time capsule! It contains three parts, with some of its elements planned to open in 2029 and others not until the distant future of 2034. Get started in 2024 Community Time Capsule: Blueprints.

Mafia Island Madness - Town Wins

Hmmmm interesting, now were do we stand, I like the idea of Geoni, I like it a lot.
Post automatically merged:

Although if Shawo actually flips red, it means you will go after me, which is victory for mafia, so let me think.
Post automatically merged:

Why look into me if Shawo ended the day voting Geoni?
Post automatically merged:

Can Alek's slot be considered that it fulfilled the post quota and vote of the day so it can survive another day?
 
Last edited:
i would say maf shawo/geo would spew the other as town given their interactions
Post automatically merged:

epona said:
this just got S P I C Y though
Click to expand...
538d539506f76.image.jpg
 
is mafshawo normally this stuborn to die haha

FinalArcadia said:
My guess while catching up on what I missed over the night was that Ace was actually cop (hence why he mentioned a cop at all) and it was why he was pushing so hard on Geoni, but guess not then?

Willing to believe shawo's new claim as it is, makes a LOT more sense than 2x docs or 1 doc + 1 Lucky
Click to expand...
felt like that too, but the impression died when he claimed green. tbh, a thought I had but I forgot to say I think if ace was mafia, and specially one teamed with shawo, he would have just went with the soft or even hard claimed

shawo said:
I just assumed that doc could target anyone consecutively, which was my mistake I guess.
I went into the cc hoping that everyone would ignore doc and go outside because that was mechanically optimal.
Click to expand...
honestly i can believe this is just a cultural shock and maybe this plan would work with another players. granted this is town motivated btw. but oh well.

still think we should go shawo. idk how much remorse I have for potentially chopping a cop in a game where there could be a godfather
 
shawo said:
eh whatever. I'll just say it.

I'm vanilla cop repo ace sided with town.

Goal was to have Daniel doc me w/o outting my role.

I was hoping I wouldn't die today and maf wouldn't kill me cuz it wouldn't amke sense for cop to claim doc but me I guess.

I was hoping to bait epona into ccing earlier cuz I saw her softing it, but I don't think she was really softing cop.

Kinda annoyed because the only reason I claimed not lucky was because imo that's the only role mafia would want to cc there. So if I said "i'm not lucky" the natural thought process would be "shawo as mafia wouldn't retract into VT or whatever."
Click to expand...

LOL everyone vote shawo
Post automatically merged:

Damniel said:
i thought ace slipped cop too which was what i was trying to communicate to epona via twilight trivia lol

last game i could see the benefit in shawo claiming miller -> mason. here this is harmful to us. like i dont see how this couldve ended well for either of us since either he'd be killed for a doc claim, i die and then he gets direct heat, or neither of us died and town chops between us
Post automatically merged:

as someone all for risky claims, im just like blown by this
Click to expand...

daniel do you actually think i'm stupid. like how do you think i graduated with a law degree i KNEW what you were trying to tell me LMAO
 
ok so my ace slip theory is out the window so here's what's happening

shawo is mafia here. he tried to bait out a cop claim earlier and when it didn't happen he felt comfortable enough to fakeclaim. he assumes we won't chop an un-CC'd cop so ace will probably be the chop of the day. ace will flip town, essentially clearing shawo

OR on the off chance we chop shawo today and he flips red, ace will be a perfectly set-up ML so it's an eye for an eye for mafia

tldr shawo is wolf ace is villager. sorry for misreading u ace
Post automatically merged:

the problem with shawo's plan is he thinks we are all stupider than him
 
hear me out this might me another confusing theory with volt
but like shawo why did u inspect ace
shawo was sure of geoni yesterday and ace was tunneling geoni near EoD. I already explain why both of them cant possibly be on the same team with geoni
shawo was budding up with ace bc both wanted geoni dead, so that was a safe inspect to lie about. shawo basically is saying that he was softing the whole time when he actually cleared ace bc ace wants geoni dead
 
epona said:
ok so my ace slip theory is out the window so here's what's happening

shawo is mafia here. he tried to bait out a cop claim earlier and when it didn't happen he felt comfortable enough to fakeclaim. he assumes we won't chop an un-CC'd cop so ace will probably be the chop of the day. ace will flip town, essentially clearing shawo

OR on the off chance we chop shawo today and he flips red, ace will be a perfectly set-up ML so it's an eye for an eye for mafia

tldr shawo is wolf ace is villager. sorry for misreading u ace
Post automatically merged:

the problem with shawo's plan is he thinks we are all stupider than him
Click to expand...

AtE is a double sided blade, but it needs to be used sometimes, in my case every time.

I still gave up though, but is nice to see the game progressing.
 
voltairenism said:
hear me out this might me another confusing theory with volt
but like shawo why did u inspect ace
shawo was sure of geoni yesterday and ace was tunneling geoni near EoD. I already explain why both of them cant possibly be on the same team with geoni
shawo was budding up with ace bc both wanted geoni dead, so that was a safe inspect to lie about. shawo basically is saying that he was softing the whole time when he actually cleared ace bc ace wants geoni dead
Click to expand...

there is no need to even go down this line of inquiry bc shawo is not the cop
 
shawo showed no indication of interest in Ace. intersecting geo or epona wouldve made more sense

not that CCing cop as doc makes sense anyway. i couldve bought it if he were lucky or even vanilla
Post automatically merged:

inspecting
 
ya shawo really messed up here
i could maybe believe he was town fakeclaiming again here if he hadn't lied about an inspection result
 
This plans actually is pretty well though if mafia, because I will flip town today if voted off, so that clears Shawo for the rest of the game, winning because.

Daniel protects Shawo.
Daniel dies tonight.
Shawo mafia read a town, people follow.
Mafia wins.
 
a green inspect with a green flip would never make me think they're legit. especially with this gamestate. had it been a RED flip i might've protected him. but the general idea was that i take my protect off myself i guess
 
Which means the mafia team

Can be Shawo/Geoni and Dedenne/FA
Post automatically merged:

could*
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

EvilTheCat6600
Goodbye And Good Riddance To My Second Island
Replies
0
Views
220
EvilTheCat6600
EvilTheCat6600
Alolan_Apples
Island Improvements Questionnaire:
Replies
9
Views
306
Asarena
Asarena
Plum Pudding
Question regarding Harvey's Island
Replies
5
Views
158
J087
J087
mayor.lauren
Buying Cataloguing?
Replies
0
Views
86
mayor.lauren
mayor.lauren
Jeremy
  • Locked
  • Poll
Besting Blunders - Community Voting
Replies
4
Views
884
ShawnFuzz
ShawnFuzz
Back
Top