Mafia Island Madness - Town Wins

[FinalArcadia]

lemme put on my dunce cap before I walk back into this thread with a big post in a sec

also

the scene in the picture was happy, but the victim felt nothing more than anger now, staring at the large nose of the traitor in the image.

is this the clue for this night's flavor text?

 

[Geoni]

Just here so I can post this, eat it Shawo

 

[Damniel]

WHO DID YOU SAVE DANIEL

epona and i.... are powerful...

 

[Geoni]

Nice save Dan

 

[Damniel]

lemme put on my dunce cap before I walk back into this thread with a big post in a sec

also


is this the clue for this night's flavor text?

if it is uhhh

im not sure what would be considered a "big nose"

 

[epona]

Hello everyone. U can call me officer whitney

Daniel saved me last night which means the wolves obviously know im the cop so there’s no harm in claiming here

 

[Dinosaurz]

View attachment 322598
Hello everyone. U can call me officer whitney

Daniel saved me last night which means the wolves obviously know im the cop so there’s no harm in claiming here

Who did you investigate? And results?

 

[epona]

give me a moment i kinda expected to die tn so let me make a post

 

[Geoni]

Colton is the only one who has a huge nose but idk if DinoTown would be that mean to the mafia by singling someone out with a clue

 

[Dinosaurz]

Guys pietro has a clown nose it’s fake ok

 

[Damniel]

if you guys didn't notice, epona softed to me. i had the idea when she started immediately sussing shawo and ace for possibly being cop, then i confirmed it with the whole drew harris and garda thing

i protected myself N1 and N2 i saved epona

the wifom was strong

 

[FinalArcadia]

these quotes are from shawo:

I thought Alek was mafia but they're going to get modkilled. I townread hikari for one post on d1 and they're gone. Guava, dedenne, and dino are impossible to sort, but if you made me put money on it, I'd say it's probably 2 in dedenne, guava, and dino. Making it a 4p mafia team.

I'd say there's a good chance it's dino (who did just jump on the doc kill.) and ... dedenne? or guava? neither of them seem willing to push in docs, I think it's possible that guava is mafia aligned because they're willing to jump ace, making.... dedenne town?

Actually when I think about it more. I'm pretty sure guava is mafia. They're not even trying to sort in me and Damniel even though guava is usually pretty quick to at least try and get a read on me.

I keep thinking "they're gonna try harder later" but it's already ... day 2 of day 2. It's too late.

Then can we go in dedenne guava dino!

I actually think dedenne is probably town in the three.

I thought Alek was mafia but they're going to get modkilled. I townread hikari for one post on d1 and they're gone. Guava, dedenne, and dino are impossible to sort, but if you made me put money on it, I'd say it's probably 2 in dedenne, guava, and dino. Making it a 4p mafia team.

I'd say there's a good chance it's dino (who did just jump on the doc kill.) and ... dedenne? or guava? neither of them seem willing to push in docs, I think it's possible that guava is mafia aligned because they're willing to jump ace, making.... dedenne town?

Geoni already hard sr, and I believe it's a 4p mafia team, and honestly if I had to pick town out of all of those, it'd probably be dedenne, and then maybe epona.

It's impossible to read Hikari, and I think Guava would be trying harder given the circumstance + they said they would. So that's second mafia. And I guess the only reason I sr dino is because of their reaction to the dockill and the game. They just feel really floaty. Dedenne also feels floaty but in a ~town~ way... so...

Looking back at shawo's thoughts from D2, I think it's reasonable to assume that one mafia member (at least) is in his suspicions list, because that's generally something mafia does in case they die.

The reads on Dino feel weak and like they're just thrown in there knowing that Dino could be an easy ML given his posting style. Given that I townread Dino, I think this was trying to lay the groundwork in case a Dino elim was ever possible.

geoni and shawo seemed to be in opposition way too much most of the time for me to think they were just distancing

Also, note the weird way that shawo always refers to dedenne. The "...dedenne town?" and "making... dedenne town?" and "Dedenne also feels floaty but in a ~town~ way" in three separate posts, and that's not even all of them from the examples above. He never provides any real solid reason WHY he felt this way about dedenne. dedenne/shawo could be a team; why would shawo keep throwing dedenne into his suspects lists just to always turn around and say they're likelier town than the others each time? shawo may have been prepared to bus dedenne if necessary (notably after the Cake ML), but wanted to avoid things getting to that point

anyway, tl;dr I think dedenne is one of shawo's partners, and guava still could be (not sure how to interpret shawo's "reads" on guava tbh), but dedenne I think has a more compelling case when looking at shawo's flip and that's what I'm going to posit in an effort to redeem myself for my dum dum read on shawo last phase

 

[Damniel]

Colton is the only one who has a huge nose but idk if DinoTown would be that mean to the mafia by singling someone out with a clue

can someone look up a pic of each character. can't remember the details

 

[Dinosaurz]

if you guys didn't notice, epona softed to me. i had the idea when she started immediately sussing shawo and ace for possibly being cop, then i confirmed it with the whole drew harris and garda thing

i protected myself N1 and N2 i saved epona

the wifom was strong

It’s funny how shawo called them out for soft claiming lmao

 

[DinoTown]

I'm gonna step in one time and one time only to help out with the clue. The clue is that the killer has a nose. Some of the characters you are playing as don't have visible noses on their character models. The attacker is not among them. This is the only time I'm gonna step in because you have no idea how hard it is to make the sentence 'The killer has a nose' sound natural in the story.

 

[Damniel]

btw i think final arcadia is a wolf. or at least high chance of being one. lets talk about it

 

[Dinosaurz]

Yeah lol I saw they’re trying to blame me I was like 👁👁 reading shawos posts how mean of you!!!!

Post automatically merged: Sep 26, 2020

I'm gonna step in one time and one time only to help out with the clue. The clue is that the killer has a nose. Some of the characters you are playing as don't have visible noses on their character models. The attacker is not among them. This is the only time I'm gonna step in because you have no idea how hard it is to make the sentence 'The killer has a nose' sound natural in the story.

Ohhhh ok

 

[epona]

SO

i knew shawo was trying to bait a cop claim out of me yesterday but unfortunately that entire plan hinged on him believing me to be stupider than i am and that i would just claim bc he told me to LOL

i did consider claiming yesterday but there was no point because sadly i investigated glow n1, which is why i was so annoyed and shocked when she died because it was a massive waste of an investigation

wasn't really worried about you guys believing me bc i was actually breadcrumbing my role from the very start of d1, which is why i was getting really irate with people calling me passive bc if you read my posts closely enough you would've seen it but anyway i digress

 

[Geoni]

I haven't actually made a Shawo spew read yet so I will get to that. What were your results epona?

 

[Damniel]

epona wait

Post automatically merged: Sep 26, 2020

hold off on the inspection result for a bit? lets see how the game progresses first?