Mafia Island Madness - Town Wins

[Geoni]

SO

i knew shawo was trying to bait a cop claim out of me yesterday but unfortunately that entire plan hinged on him believing me to be stupider than i am and that i would just claim bc he told me to LOL

i did consider claiming yesterday but there was no point because sadly i investigated glow n1, which is why i was so annoyed and shocked when she died because it was a massive waste of an investigation

wasn't really worried about you guys believing me bc i was actually breadcrumbing my role from the very start of d1, which is why i was getting really irate with people calling me passive bc if you read my posts closely enough you would've seen it but anyway i digress

N2?

 

[Dinosaurz]

epona wait

Post automatically merged: Sep 26, 2020

hold off on the inspection result for a bit? lets see how the game progresses first?

Why?

 

[Geoni]

If you have a red check hold off maybe

 

[epona]

N2?

epona wait

Post automatically merged: Sep 26, 2020

hold off on the inspection result for a bit? lets see how the game progresses first?

daniel and i have become one this game.

i'm withholding my n2 results until later

 

[Dinosaurz]

Ok I trust you two so I’ll take ur word for it lol

 

[Damniel]

Why?

we're not gonna end day immediately. we can see how wolves go about today and then hit em with the inspect

in either a green or red check we dont need to know now

 

[epona]

daniel can i just say i'm an IDIOT i didn't get the drew harris thing AT ALL
i knew that you were speaking in code so i was frantically google searching 'harris corporation' to see if it was something to do with police bc i didn't expect you'd use irish police names LOL

i tried to throw in chief pape and pass it off as a typo for vape to make sure u knew i knew u knew

 

[Dinosaurz]

If you guys think it’s. 3 mafia team. A 50/50 on the godfather anyway for the last 2 so chance of red is slim?

Post automatically merged: Sep 26, 2020

I feel so much better d3 then d2 haha

 

[Damniel]

OH i had to mention something and was hoping to be alive for it

i was thinking about the clues and what it meant for the team as a whole

i believe host said the clue was pertaining to a specific player

if the whole maf team had pointy ears, the clue wouldn't pertain to a single one of them. so i think at least ONE wolf is not pointy eared

so in team building w shawo (pointy eared), i dont think his partners are both pointy eared. so like, guava and dedenne are not BOTH teamed with shawo

thoughts?

 

[epona]

If you guys think it’s. 3 mafia team. A 50/50 on the godfather anyway for the last 2 so chance of red is slim?

yeah i think it's pretty reasonable to believe there's a godfather considering there's a cop

annoyingly i definitely die tonight and also it's my birthday on monday so i'm going to out for EOD

 

[Geoni]

For me when it comes to games with godfather I care more about the red check because it's so easy to just let someone take the credit for being a green check, it matters more if it was someone obvious or not when it comes to it being a confirming green check.

 

[Dinosaurz]

OH i had to mention something and was hoping to be alive for it

i was thinking about the clues and what it meant for the team as a whole

i believe host said the clue was pertaining to a specific player

if the whole maf team had pointy ears, the clue wouldn't pertain to a single one of them. so i think at least ONE wolf is not pointy eared

so in team building w shawo (pointy eared), i dont think his partners are both pointy eared. so like, guava and dedenne are not BOTH teamed with shawo

thoughts?

This is what I said yesterday. That’s why I think it’s hikari

 

[Damniel]

daniel can i just say i'm an IDIOT i didn't get the drew harris thing AT ALL
i knew that you were speaking in code so i was frantically google searching 'harris corporation' to see if it was something to do with police bc i didn't expect you'd use irish police names LOL

i tried to throw in chief pape and pass it off as a typo for vape to make sure u knew i knew u knew

yea i pieced it all together. was paranoid in that you weren't which is why i had to confirm

Post automatically merged: Sep 26, 2020

This is what I said yesterday. That’s why I think it’s hikari

hikari was randomly shawo's biggest townread in D1, im trying to piece what that means

vrisnem also brings a good point on final and shawo not really solving or interacting with each other

 

[Dinosaurz]

yea i pieced it all together. was paranoid in that you weren't which is why i had to confirm

Post automatically merged: Sep 26, 2020

hikari was randomly shawo's biggest townread in D1, im trying to piece what that means

vrisnem also brings a good point on final and shawo not really solving or interacting with each other

oh yeah final is sus too.
I’m wanna hear more from poncho

 

[epona]

regarding the clue, i've google imaged everyone and the only characters w/ noses are the following:


4. Ace Marvel (Colton)

6. Vrisnem (Stitches)

9. Dinosaurz (Pietro)

10. Continuum (Poncho)

i have obviously removed dead players and myself and daniel from this POE because we should both be 100% clear for you all now

 

[Dinosaurz]

Geoni has a nose too

 

[Damniel]

these quotes are from shawo:






Looking back at shawo's thoughts from D2, I think it's reasonable to assume that one mafia member (at least) is in his suspicions list, because that's generally something mafia does in case they die.

The reads on Dino feel weak and like they're just thrown in there knowing that Dino could be an easy ML given his posting style. Given that I townread Dino, I think this was trying to lay the groundwork in case a Dino elim was ever possible.

geoni and shawo seemed to be in opposition way too much most of the time for me to think they were just distancing

Also, note the weird way that shawo always refers to dedenne. The "...dedenne town?" and "making... dedenne town?" and "Dedenne also feels floaty but in a ~town~ way" in three separate posts, and that's not even all of them from the examples above. He never provides any real solid reason WHY he felt this way about dedenne. dedenne/shawo could be a team; why would shawo keep throwing dedenne into his suspects lists just to always turn around and say they're likelier town than the others each time? shawo may have been prepared to bus dedenne if necessary (notably after the Cake ML), but wanted to avoid things getting to that point

anyway, tl;dr I think dedenne is one of shawo's partners, and guava still could be (not sure how to interpret shawo's "reads" on guava tbh), but dedenne I think has a more compelling case when looking at shawo's flip and that's what I'm going to posit in an effort to redeem myself for my dum dum read on shawo last phase

hm. haven't looked too much into D1 shawo yet

 

[epona]

Geoni has a nose too

oops sorry dobie was meant to be there too

 

[Geoni]

OH i had to mention something and was hoping to be alive for it

i was thinking about the clues and what it meant for the team as a whole

i believe host said the clue was pertaining to a specific player

if the whole maf team had pointy ears, the clue wouldn't pertain to a single one of them. so i think at least ONE wolf is not pointy eared

so in team building w shawo (pointy eared), i dont think his partners are both pointy eared. so like, guava and dedenne are not BOTH teamed with shawo

thoughts?

If this is the case I'd say Dedenne > guava maybe. Cause I still think Ace was WIFOM'd and can work with Shawo.

I do need to re-eval Arcadia at this point and I'm hoping to hear back from Hikari's sub.

 

[Dinosaurz]

Not that I’m sussing geoni rn I’m just pointing it out for consistency