Mafia Make Mafia Grate Again! Game Over! Town wins!

[Cadbberry]

If it is that unlikely, and that is a consensus, we should lynch Aronthaer today.

I would give it one more day, if no one can note aron being of any assistance, not healing so not a doc maybe, nor being killed ,making his heal either on him self or non existant, then we can think about lynching him

 

[f11]

Hypothetical situation that just came to mind. Say
I'm cop and inspect a scum this night, considering there's two docs would it be okay for me to out?

I'm trying to think of all the situations last night and why some people are super quiet.

 

[Heyden]

Hypothetical situation that just came to mind. Say
I'm cop and inspect a scum this night, considering there's two docs would it be okay for me to out?

I'm trying to think of all the situations last night and why some people are super quiet.

Roleblocker could interrupt the plan though.

 

[PandaDarling]

Hypothetical situation that just came to mind. Say
I'm cop and inspect a scum this night, considering there's two docs would it be okay for me to out?

I'm trying to think of all the situations last night and why some people are super quiet.

Im confused what is the scenario ? Cop inspects Scum? and then they out ? like claim and reveal results ?

 

[Heyden]

If we ever get rid of mafia roleblocker then that could be a possible plan.
Would you guys say its okay to ask for vigilante to out if they shot Daniel? (and the fact that they're only a one shot bc it means they're basically vanilla if they used it up)

 

[PandaDarling]

If we ever get rid of mafia roleblocker then that could be a possible plan.
Would you guys say its okay to ask for vigilante to out if they shot Daniel? (and the fact that they're only a one shot bc it means they're basically vanilla if they used it up)

@Heyden you know what i don't think im comfortable with anyone outing rn, yes it may seem pointless if they were a 1-shot Vig but at the same time mafia/sk doesn't need to know that right now, the less they know and the more things stay a mystery is better for us, i mean its already the "informed minority vs uninformed majority" so we need to keep all the 'secrets' we can, i mean unless of course its gonna save one of us from being lynched/killed for no good reason, then so be it. and why are you wanting to out PR's and stuff, and then you wonder why people are moving you to their sus reads?

 

[Heyden]

Eh true, just wanted some confirmation to narrow down why those were the kills last night and who committed each kill.. meh

 

[PandaDarling]

Eh true, just wanted some confirmation to narrow down why those were the kills last night and who committed each kill.. meh

@Heyden What! you're not gonna know who committed each kill, impossible... mafia/sk isn't gonna come forward and say "and ya that kill was me... game on." sounds to me like your trying to trick PR's into outing themselves.

*If you are PR and even if your Role is pointless now, please don't claim unless absolutely necessary.

 

[Heyden]

@Heyden What! you're not gonna know who committed each kill, impossible... mafia/sk isn't gonna come forward and say "and ya that kill was me... game on." sounds to me like your trying to trick PR's into outing themselves.

*If you are PR and even if your Role is pointless now, please don't claim unless absolutely necessary.

Well if Vig comes forward and says they shot Cory, it would mean Daniel was killed by Serial Killer and the other 2 by mafia. Yeah I know I'm sounding super scummy and all but it would give a better idea of who killed who. Anyway, disregard my idea..

 

[Chrystina]

holy **** my internet went down and i panicked.

OKAY i have yet to go back and read the pages i missed. but it went down after Panda posted her reads/colors... what I find VERY odd is that you town read everyone but me...?
Care to explain? Nobody else seems sus to you? Obviously there is scum somewhere in that list but I'm seeing a lotttt of green.

Also - I would do my colors real quick but I am still for an Aron lynch.
Really, it has completely astounded me that even though he's still alive - he's being town read by so many of us. Yes yes I understand the whole mafia tactic with keeping him alive but everyone's sus of me because I'm "wishy washy" and accusing me of jumping on any lynch BW I get, and not giving definitive reads. ...Sound familiar?
Aron has done all of this and more. I think he's said "oh I agree" everytime someone brings up a scumread case on someone. He even scumread xine because they started thinking aron's claim was false. ?? xine is everyones top town read (or I would hope so) but now he's putting himself into this corner he can't get out of and doing any last possible thing he can to be saved from a lynch.

 

[PandaDarling]

Well if Vig comes forward and says they shot Cory, it would mean Daniel was killed by Serial Killer and the other 2 by mafia. Yeah I know I'm sounding super scummy and all but it would give a better idea of who killed who. Anyway, disregard my idea..

uhhh...

 

[Chrystina]

please post merge

no one was even talking to you, this is a very ominous post. perhaps you should elaborate?

- - - Post Merge - - -




you aren't worthy

- - - Post Merge - - -

toads worthy

just wanted to say this was hilarious. ty

I agree with Panda, I feel like only of Aronthaer/Sarasa is Doctor, and the other is something else..

- - - Post Merge - - -

only one of*

something else.. ?
okay so, i could believe this. but if PR's are claiming they might as well be claiming the right PR.... right?

 

[PandaDarling]

holy **** my internet went down and i panicked.

OKAY i have yet to go back and read the pages i missed. but it went down after Panda posted her reads/colors... what I find VERY odd is that you town read everyone but me...?
Care to explain? Nobody else seems sus to you? Obviously there is scum somewhere in that list but I'm seeing a lotttt of green.

Also - I would do my colors real quick but I am still for an Aron lynch.
Really, it has completely astounded me that even though he's still alive - he's being town read by so many of us. Yes yes I understand the whole mafia tactic with keeping him alive but everyone's sus of me because I'm "wishy washy" and accusing me of jumping on any lynch BW I get, and not giving definitive reads. ...Sound familiar?
Aron has done all of this and more. I think he's said "oh I agree" everytime someone brings up a scumread case on someone. He even scumread xine because they started thinking aron's claim was false. ?? xine is everyones top town read (or I would hope so) but now he's putting himself into this corner he can't get out of and doing any last possible thing he can to be saved from a lynch.

@Alexi like i stated underneath it.. i just moved people around according to the the information we received from the night kills and such and i have yet to go back and find more suspicions, i have a lot of Null people in there and im sure thats were the over mafia/sk is hiding.

- - - Post Merge - - -

please post merge


just wanted to say this was hilarious. ty


something else.. ?
okay so, i could believe this. but if PR's are claiming they might as well be claiming the right PR.... right?

@Alexi wrong. it will most likely be explained to you a bit later but its still not my place to break it down for you rn, sorry.

 

[Chrystina]

@Alexi like i stated underneath it.. i just moved people around according to the the information we received from the night kills and such and i have yet to go back and find more suspicions, i have a lot of Null people in there and im sure thats were the over mafia/sk is hiding.

- - - Post Merge - - -




@Alexi wrong. it will most likely be explained to you a bit later but its still not my place to break it down for you rn, sorry.

Okay fair enough at the first part.
@ the second part - I really don't understand the need to false claim a PR when you're already a PR but okay. I don't think anyones done this (like I don't see the point) so I guess I'll wait for it to be explained to me.

 

[Arstotzkan]

1) Heyden's acting like his meta is king when in a game with him last time when he was town, he said he tries to mix up his playstyles so he canmt be meta read
2) His tone sounds very off considering Xine not dying. Ness, knowing you cracked the code, this should also say something else to you.
3) He refuses to respond to my questions.

As for the "crack the code" bit, he sounded a bit surprised that Xine wasn't killed considering they were attacked. Sounded like to me he knew Xine was attacked and he was confused as to how he's alive rather than being surprised Xine lived the night.

- - - Post Merge - - -

^ was @Heyden for why I found him sus. And then I don't like his Vig exchange with Panda at all.

@Alexi And considering he's a total noob and you know your way around the block, why should you two be evaluated on the same level?

 

[Chrystina]

As for the "crack the code" bit, he sounded a bit surprised that Xine wasn't killed considering they were attacked. Sounded like to me he knew Xine was attacked and he was confused as to how he's alive rather than being surprised Xine lived the night.

- - - Post Merge - - -

^ was @Heyden for why I found him sus. And then I don't like his Vig exchange with Panda at all.

@Alexi And considering he's a total noob and you know your way around the block, why should you two be evaluated on the same level?

Well that was just 1 little reasoning for why I think.
The BIG issue I'm having is that we now apparently have "two doctors". While I can believe your claim since you protected xine and it was confirmed, Aron is saying he "blocked" toadsworthy (??) and as well wasn't even night killed. Something just isn't adding up, & I'm not a strong believer in 2 doctors.

 

[Arstotzkan]

Erm, you kind of dodged the question there lol. Are you resinsing your point there, then?

Of course mafia's gonna leave alive someone who's said that they would be lynched the next day if they were still alive. But his tone around his claim was way too pure. Unless you realistically think he was apologizing for ****ing up the game as scum? Cause I don't think so.

- - - Post Merge - - -

And Aron explained the "block" as "blocking the mafia from shooting him".

Does someone who didn't use an action get a notification if they were roleblocked?

 

[Chrystina]

Erm, you kind of dodged the question there lol. Are you resinsing your point there, then?

Of course mafia's gonna leave alive someone who's said that they would be lynched the next day if they were still alive. But his tone around his claim was way too pure. Unless you realistically think he was apologizing for ****ing up the game as scum? Cause I don't think so.

welp you're right, I did dodge it. to answer the question: no we shouldn't be evaluated on the same level, you're right. which is why I continued with the other reasoning.
He did apologize for ****ing up the game but (like I put in my reply towards m3ow) he also had a lot of posts that didn't seem pro town at all. & while those posts were off-putting to me, it was clear I was not going to vote for him.

but now that there's another doctor claim, what is he? There's so many different posts saying he's "town that claimed doctor" or "noob doctor", or "scum that claimed doctor". To me, it's either the 1st or the 3rd. Highly highly leaning towards 3rd.

 

[Arstotzkan]

And you really don't think we have two doctors in this game? Dolby's known to do different stuff with his set ups - I wouldn't be surprised at this point that there was two Docs put in just so it derails thread like this and meant as an obstacle we have to overcome. And even though he hasn't been the most pro town on paper, his tone is one of the purest tones in this game.

 

[Heyden]

I don't believe either Sarasa or Aronthaer are scum, I just think that one of them isn't actually a doctor and some other town PR...