Mafia Make Mafia Grate Again! Game Over! Town wins!

And you really don't think we have two doctors in this game? Dolby's known to do different stuff with his set ups - I wouldn't be surprised at this point that there was two Docs put in just so it derails thread like this and meant as an obstacle we have to overcome. And even though he hasn't been the most pro town on paper, his tone is one of the purest tones in this game.

no I don't think we do at all. Maybe a role similar to doctor, but not two "doctor's."

buuuuut like I've said a hundred billion times about posting reads - I'm gonna do that now. They incredibly changed after night and there are other people I'm sus of besides him, so I figure it would help to have more than 1 lynch candidate.
Colors, for now. Detailed post later after I ISO everyones posts:

Alexi
Sarasakat
Xine

Tardis2016
Panda1376
Toadsworthy
Taesaek
Ness
Cadbberry

ClamEatsCurry
Heyden
Crys
Qwerty111
Mother of all Llamas
Aronthaer
M3ow_
Kevinnn Ayaya
Shondell Tina
Honey.dew Lucanosa
 
@Alexi Why not?

And Im curious to hear a more detailed opinion of Heyden, in particular. Last time you talked to him that I remember, you said something about wanting to point him out for something but then white text.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Heyden, reply to my suspicions of you, will ya?
 
Well I thought knowing who the used up vig (assuming they're one shot) was, it would give us a better idea of last night and such. I don't know why it would matter anyway since they're basically just a vanilla townie if they did shoot.
Sarasa, I feel like I know your actual role but I'm trying to do you a favor by keeping my mouth shut, unless I'm legitimately just overthinking it..

- - - Post Merge - - -

Then again, why does one doctor have a dead role name and the other one has a largely known politician role name?
 
Lol, why would you bring up that bit about my role? That sounds like blackmail. And there was more stuff to my suspicion of you than just he Vig bit.

- - - Post Merge - - -

the Vig bit*
 
man Heyden originally I townread you day 1 but you're digging yourself deeper and deeper...

@sarasakat: yeah, thats part of it. but ahh you'll see. there's more, especially with the KP thing. sorry i suck and take way longer than i should compiling a post rip.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Okay so I'll just start with heyden.. but I got more, might change throughout day 2.


Heyden
Let's start with this:
I don't see how I seem scum? I've been acting how I usually act as town..
Except you haven't after day 1. at all. Starting from after the inkling lynch:
Hahahaha... KP is 2 now this is good, gonna read on Inklings posts and see what I can get out of it.
I thought this was pretty scummy, but I asked for explanation since I still was town lean on heyden. his answer:
I'm basing my thoughts off previous games. In Minties GoT game they had 1 extra player, and 5 scum, so I assumed this game would have a maximum of 5 scum and a minimum of 4 scum. 1 less scum would be 2 KP either way.

So then, he makes sure to be less confident with it in his next post.
The KP is most likely 2 at the moment. Most likely 3 members, 4 would seem a little bit scumsided.
As for PR's, I'm pretty sure Dolby likes to incorporate a few more PR's than there usually are, so possibly up to 8 maybe. I don't believe in 2 doctors, I think I know what's actually happening but I'm keeping my mouth shut for the sake of keeping them safe.
And 3rd parties, I'm thinking 1 hostile (e.g Mad Hatter, SK) and a non-hostile (Lover, Lyncher)

Xine, Cory and Shiida are possible victims of Serial Killer/Mafia/Vigilante
Daniel was the victim of Vigilante or Serial Killer

If a vigilante did shoot Daniel, wouldn't it be good for them to out since they're basically just a vanilla townie now anyways?

Also, @ the very last part- really? how is this pro-town at all. yeah, lets out the vig they're just a VT anyways so thats ok. except not. this continues further down with obvious PR hunting.
Why did Xine live lol
How do you know if xine was even targeted?

I have 1 more read going to post it before the night cycle ends. Just need to find all there posts.
Looking forward to see some reads from you.
Night is almost over..?
You're just being an ass here, really. Why are you so keen on tardis posting reads?


The following posts, obvious PR hunting:
Have you ever thought that Mafia could have a doctor on their side? Like a mafia doctor.

That is possible, but it would mean there's still a town doctor but we can't really get them to out...

Now that I think of it, there probably is a Veteran... Was anyone hit?

If we ever get rid of mafia roleblocker then that could be a possible plan.
Would you guys say its okay to ask for vigilante to out if they shot Daniel? (and the fact that they're only a one shot bc it means they're basically vanilla if they used it up)

Eh true, just wanted some confirmation to narrow down why those were the kills last night and who committed each kill.. meh

Well if Vig comes forward and says they shot Cory, it would mean Daniel was killed by Serial Killer and the other 2 by mafia. Yeah I know I'm sounding super scummy and all but it would give a better idea of who killed who. Anyway, disregard my idea..

my god @ the bold. "this is scummy to say but im gonna say it anyways" ??


filler posts, but also complains about people needing to condense their posts:
10/10 response, tardis 4 town leader
something nothing
pineapple head massacre
why does everyone think they're gonna die, dw the pro-doc Aron is probably on you lol
like dis post if ur town
i take pics

really there is no point to those posts at all. i almost don't even want to include them all cause it makes my post look gigantic, but you're a lot more serious when town and none of this is helpful.
 
God ****ing dammit can I survive past one game where I'm not a ****ing townie. If the vig shot me they should quit Mafia.
 
no I don't think we do at all. Maybe a role similar to doctor, but not two "doctor's."

buuuuut like I've said a hundred billion times about posting reads - I'm gonna do that now. They incredibly changed after night and there are other people I'm sus of besides him, so I figure it would help to have more than 1 lynch candidate.
Colors, for now. Detailed post later after I ISO everyones posts:

Alexi
Sarasakat
Xine

Tardis2016
Panda1376
Toadsworthy
Taesaek
Ness
Cadbberry

ClamEatsCurry
Heyden
Crys
Qwerty111
Mother of all Llamas
Aronthaer
M3ow_
Kevinnn Ayaya
Shondell Tina
Honey.dew Lucanosa

Why am I on your townreads when you had thought that I was so clearly scum when I said "For the town"? I thought you asked me if I were to "flip scum yet".
 
no I don't think we do at all. Maybe a role similar to doctor, but not two "doctor's."

buuuuut like I've said a hundred billion times about posting reads - I'm gonna do that now. They incredibly changed after night and there are other people I'm sus of besides him, so I figure it would help to have more than 1 lynch candidate.
Colors, for now. Detailed post later after I ISO everyones posts:

Alexi
Sarasakat
Xine

Tardis2016
Panda1376
Toadsworthy
Taesaek
Ness
Cadbberry

ClamEatsCurry
Heyden
Crys
Qwerty111
Mother of all Llamas
Aronthaer
M3ow_
Kevinnn Ayaya
Shondell Tina
Honey.dew Lucanosa

Why am I on your townreads when you had thought that I was so clearly scum when I said "For the town"? I thought you asked me if I were to "flip scum yet".
 
Why am I on your townreads when you had thought that I was so clearly scum when I said "For the town"? I thought you asked me if I were to "flip scum yet".

you misinterpret a lot of what ive said to you. most of it is just reaction testing.
 
you misinterpret a lot of what ive said to you. most of it is just reaction testing.

Oh, cute.

Anyways I don't know if I want an aron lynch. I still think he just looks like panicking town, since there would have been no reason at all for him to claim. I'm leaving this on a short note for school, but in other words, i somewhat want an Alexi/Heyden lynch today, but i'll revisit that later.
 
@Alexi In your color-coded reads, you had Heyden as slightly suspicious or neutral. Yet just now, it sounded like you were seriously pushing for his lynch. What gives?
 
I think we can make sure if two doctors are really doctors by having them say who they protected after the deadline (for actions to be sent in) and before day post is posted. There's a one hour gap which should be enough for them to get on and confirm, right?

Saying this now so the doctors remember and don't use the "I forgot to send in an action omg!!" excuse :lemon: and as someone who pretended to be a doctor before, I can imagine what they'll say if they're not a doctor and can't prove it. Will remind again once night is up.
 
I think vig should out if they're one shot. But I have a feeling I already know who it is.
 
I think vig should out if they're one shot. But I have a feeling I already know who it is.
That's what I've been saying and people are calling me out as scum for it so... :/ But yeah, I think they should still...
 
Roleblocker could interrupt the plan though.
but scum could be lynched and might have a chance of being thentoleblocker.

I am all for an alexi lynch. She's been jumping around the bandwagon all day and seems she's decided for Hayden's.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Why, though?
it could figure out the kills and what happened at night and at least one confirmed person.
 
Why, though?
Essentially if they're one **** they're basically VT now that they shot, plus it would be good to narrow down who was killed by vig/sk/maf.

- - - Post Merge - - -

one shot*

- - - Post Merge - - -

I'm good for an Alexi lynch too unless something comes up.
 
oddly enough i agree with the whole vig thing.
if you're essentially a VT now, you might as well help town make heads of tails of the events. it'll give us a more solid approach as to where to go from there. i mean, unless vig really did shoot cory and then well, gg why'd u do that. but if vig isn't a 1 shot, don't out yourself, obviously. use your remaining fire power to do some good. if you're honestly a vt now, i really don't see why everyone is so absolutely against them outing the results. i get you want some secrets kept but why do you want them kept from town as well?

also, the 2 doctor thing sounds like bull****.
especially if your role name is ted cruz. like seriously. potential sk or wild card third party.
unless you're lying and that's not really your unofficial role name.

as much as i think aron is bull**** and i don't trust him, i don't want to waste a lynch on him if he really is dumb townie doctor and then mafia wins by letting him stay alive N1 in hopes that we lynch his dumb ass today. give it some time, there's other crafty things going on that we need to focus on.

also, @ayayayayayyaaaaa, that's an excellent idea. if you're a doctor i can't wait to hear your plans for the night. gg.
 
Back
Top