k well everyone is defending the inactives but I?m not in favor of having people in this game that don?t contribute to anything, and I?d rather keep Alexi/Hayden although I?m not the MOST confident about Alexi at least we can read her because she posts frequently.
hi guys, sorry I haven't been on. the joy of compulsory education got in the way.
Anyway, nobody really seems that sus to me? Tardis seems legitimately confused after this whole drama. (if you are going to ask someone politely to stop pming you i'd probably pm them or just not respond and wait for them to check the qt instead of just saying it in the thread :I) But I guess that's all the leads we have. Honey seems like they really wanted tardis dead. Don't exe's do that? Just a thought I guess. I'm gonna go look at the pages again.
not sure if ur just new or ur in a scum QT so u don?t realize out of thread communication about the game isn?t allowed :/
Alright I'm gonna actually attempt at some reading so here goes (warning the last time I played properly (eg without dying first day) was like 2014/15 so have mercy)
Alexi
Acted virtually the same in newbie so I think town
Tardis2016
either generally confused, or "has a qt".
Panda1376
active but they seem to just rub me off the wrong way. idk tho.
Sarasakat
active + scumhunting so I think town
Crys
Kinda waiting on their post, but they seem pretty chill.
Toadsworthy
A tiny (tiny) bit more reserved than last time. but may just not have anything to go on or is busy. i think town though.
Ness
Doesn't seem sus to me? Yeah he disappeered rather suspiciously after being called out
M3ow_
Making some valid points, but idk they rub me off the wrong way I might just hate confident people gdi
Inkling
Still quiet as heck, even after newbie, where they were not maf (blue role I think?) so I think town for now.
Cory
not putting much effort into this, but i suppose they're not suspicious.
Taesaek
Seems consistent with newbie mafia, so i think town.
Aronthaer
I really don't think they're sus, but roleclaiming was a pretty stupid move. So I'm assuming mafia will just take care of them. They do seem town though.
Qwerty111
it me
Mother of all llamas
was quite quiet in newbie, bit like inkling, and was town, so for now I think they are pretty consistent.
help pls cannot scumhunt for anything, I'm kinda just using past games and obvious stuff. i suck.
mk so this is what really throws me off the most.
first and foremost note that Daniel is left out of this list, and Daniel was posting more than Llamas was at the time so inb4 ?inactivity so I had no reads?. Also Qwerty read inkling who was also less active than Daniel I?m pretty sure.
the reads that really are off-putting are these:
Alexi- This is Qwerty?s first mention of Alexi and she townreads her. and now Alexi is the most suspicious to her because she?s flip flopping? lol but what are you doing? I?m almost positive that Qwerty just noticed that Crys and others find Alexi suspicious because of my read on her D1, and are sheeping that considering that
Panda- I mean it?s fine to have a gut feeling about someone, but if you can just give 1 or 2 quotes that gave you that gut feeling then that makes a WORLD of difference when it comes to your reads. Panda hasn?t said or done anything that makes me sus of them and I think the majority of us have townread her all along so you really need to be more specific with your reasoning otherwise it just looks like you?re saying this about everyone.
I mean Sarasa and Panda were both active and scum hunting, so whats the difference? why did you townread Sarasa but not Panda?
Ness- ok you say he?s not sus but then you said he disappeared rather suspiciously so this doesn?t make sense. yet you call Alexi flip floppy, I mean Alexi was showing her reasoning for why she thinks this then why she changed her mind, but you just changed your mind in the middle of a sentence and it?s called fence sitting. which is inherently not scummy but it?s hypocritical that you called Alexi the scummiest one here when you?re doing the same thing????
Inkling- that?s not a fair assessment considering that was a Nub game, there was only 38 pages and 9 people in the game. This game is over twice that size and we went through over 100 pages in D1 ALONE. if you?re gonna mention meta at least use a game that works in comparison. In Tarot mafia Inkling was one of the top 5 posters with 140+ posts and Tina replaced her like d2 lol.
Cory- yeah that?s straight up just contradicting.
> Cory ?not putting in effort? = town
>Alexi putting in effort and changing her mind = scum
k ur rly inconsistent
about that last part, I think the more you play the easier it gets because obviously you?ll be more familiar with people but it?s not impossible to scumhunt without using any meta at all. but if you do wanna use meta, you can check out the TBT wiki b/c it?s really helpful if you?re unfamiliar.
basically just notice inconsistencies, notice people making statements w/ logic/evidence and people arguing with statements without it. notice people defending or attacking certain people and see if they apply the same criticism evenly or if there?s a subtle bias. that?s all I can think of off the top of my head, but if I think of more then I?ll make a reply to you in the critique thread.
How about you post something useful for once tho.
push on Aron- but I thought you townread him and said that he?s not suspicious??
and then NOTHING for two days, until today. 0 reaction about inkling, 0 reaction about anything that happened during night. but reads the thread and has been following along this whole time yet you can't find anything to say for two days??
but Qwerty was posting elsewhere so ye not like they?re not able to get to a computer u kno. I mean it'd be a different story if they weren't posting elsewhere at all.
oh my god
Okay, firstly. Why am I not posting? Because it's so f***ing hard to scumread. You're all going off meta. This is literally my first main game. I know basically, what, 3 of you? It's really hard to keep track too. What else would you like me to post? memes? Now I know why I stuck to newbie games. I am reading. I am looking. I am not avoiding the thread. Earlier, at 3am my time. I was asleep. Then I was at school. Now I'm home, and getting stuff thrown at me bc I post some stuff on other parts of the forum. I have a life outside mafia.
Point two. I want to vote for either Alexi or Aron bc they've both been flipflopping around, and going by my last game that's pretty sus. Aron pleading to be spared until day 4 sounds really weird to me too. But I'm going to vote for Alexi for now, and may change if Aron does something or something else happens.
Kinda curious about Xine's views on me. Since everyone seems so convinced that she's townie after hitting scum. Did everyone forget about third party?
like I said and others have pointed out, not EVERYONE is going off of meta so soz u can't really excuse urself there
that sentence about memes is just straight up over defensive- in fact this entire paragraph is. why are you getting so riled up? I mean it?s not like you?re the only one that?s new here. IIRC it?s Cadberry?s first game- and they also mentioned that it was difficult to scumhunt? but they still post frequently. just because you?re new doesn?t mean it?s better just to say nothing. even a general thoughts post is better than nothing. we all have lives outside mafia, you don?t need to list off everything i mean we believe you, but that?s not really the point here.
I asked what exactly you meant by flip-flopping because I want to know if you?re just sheeping my D1 case on Alexi or if you have your own reasoning for this. like that last paragraph is SO wishy-washy i just can't.
if you think changing your opinions is sus then you?re being hypocritical because you?re doing the same things- you townread Alexi and Aron but now you?re changing your mind. isn?t that flip-flopping? At least Alexi actually shows her train of thought and answers when she is asked WHY she believes these things. it just seems like you saw a few others vote for her, knew you had to vote or you?ll be modkilled, and sent in your vote.
I'm not voting for you because you said something about me. I don't vote for defense. I've voted for you because I think you're scum??? Isn't this a no brainer?
but WHY pls explain? pls???
like the last paragraph in your previous quote basically said that you don't have your own read on Alexi and that you'd change if something else happened. but if you genuinely think Alexi is scum then why would you unvote?? it's really obvious to me that you don't really have a solid opinion on who's being lynched here, you just needed to come back in time before being modkilled.
so yeeeah this is why I'm voting Qwerty and I don't think I'm changing my mind.
- - - Post Merge - - -
*dies inside because i just posted my qwerty case and now it's not showing up*
- - - Post Merge - - -
o LAWD what happened where did it go why is nothing posting whywhywhwywhywwhyrwy
