PandaDarling
Purple People Eater
Mafia Make Mafia Grate Again! Game Over! Town wins!
- Thread starter Dolby
- Start date
PandaDarling
Purple People Eater
That usually doesn't mean anything really. Lucanosa was similar in past games where he was active outside of mafia but super quiet in the game. He was town on those occasions. I also suspected Hayden in past games for being active elsewhere but he ended up being protown too. Though I'm all for making them more active.
So far, based on what I've read, my conclusion so far:
- SarasaKat and Xine are heavily leaning on town, Xine for leading a lynch on scum, and SarasaKat for being confirmed Doc.
- I'm also leaning on town/not mafia for Crys, Aron, and m3ow because both inkling and Daniel pushed these players as scum (1, 2, 3, 4)
- From my personal observation, I'm leaning on town for Alexi, Panda, and Ness. Panda's play seems to fit with her town meta and nothing from her stands out to me as odd. As of this writing, Alexi is the majority, yet she doesn't seem panicked nor trying to make herself look protown so people unvoted her. Scum numbers would be low atm and they would want to keep as many of their members alive, so the lack of defensiveness from Alexi makes me think she's town. As for Ness, I haven't seen anything odd from him, I know his meta and I think he's town based on that.
- Heyden is the one most suspicious to me atm, because Daniel mentioned that he fit his town meta, and so did inkling. What's odd here is that inkling is a new player, how could she confidently say that Heyden is town based on meta when she hasn't played much games with him? Not to mention how both of the flipped scums say that he's town based on meta. Tho I don't find this suspicious enough to vote for him yet, as I haven't gone through his posts/replies. I think people posted their reads on him but idk where to find them?
- These are players I'm familiar w/ but null because they haven't posted much: Tina, Lucanosa, mother of all llamas
- I'm not sure on these players bc I've never played with them and they either post too much or too little: Tardis2016, toadsworthy, ClamEatsCurry, Caddberry, Taesaek, Qwerty111
- Out of the unfamiliar names (for me) that I mentioned above, I compared them with how they're mentioned in Daniel and inkling's reads. EDIT: LMFAO this part got deleted while I was changing pages so they'll be a shorter version of what I intended
Taesaek was mentioned first in inkling's reads for being unusually quiet, while null on Daniel's because he doesn't seem protown. Considering that inkling put his name first, I think he's slighty leaning on town
Tardis2016 was added as a sidenote on inklings as being confused as usual, while Daniel thinks he's genuinely trying to help town. They seem like a new player but the scums's opinion on them makes him worth looking later.
Toadsworthy was not mentioned on inkling's read, while Daniel's remarked that he seem protown. Their posts tend to be TL;DR so I'll need more time to analyze them.
ClamEatsCurry was also not mentioned on inkling's read, while Daniel thinks he's a typical noobie and put them as null. I do agree that they don't seem like scum if they're asking questions on the thread instead of the QT.
Caddberry are written as giving weak town vibes from both inkling and Daniel, since they both mentioned they try to be town but not enough for them to write them as town. Will need to read them further.
Qwerty111 wasn't mentioned on inkling's read but she did mention his inactivity here, while Daniel puts him at null. I'm not sure what to think of them so null as well.
In conclusion, my top scumreads at this moment are Heyden, Tardis, and Toadsworthy. The latter two I'm not familiar with so I'd need further reading with them. Please let me know if I missed anything!
For someone who's been trying to get PR claims and even saying what SarasaKat is in the thread, this seems pretty off.
- - - Post Merge - - -
@Ayaya: I'm liking the organization haha. You didn't include Aronthaer though, I noticed. What's your read on him? Or maybe I missed it in an earlier post.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Oh wait, nvm. Missed it
@Ayaya yeah I've had a couple of people make reads/cases on me. Not sure why those 2 even townread me...
@Alexi, look I'm more than happy to claim, so if anyone wants to make the call I'm up for it.
- - - Post Merge - - -
I start school tomorrow so I won't be there for the last 6 hours of day so if you want me to claim, the next few hours is a good time because you wouldn't want me dying
@Alexi, look I'm more than happy to claim, so if anyone wants to make the call I'm up for it.
- - - Post Merge - - -
I start school tomorrow so I won't be there for the last 6 hours of day so if you want me to claim, the next few hours is a good time because you wouldn't want me dying
@Ayaya yeah I've had a couple of people make reads/cases on me. Not sure why those 2 even townread me...
@Alexi, look I'm more than happy to claim, so if anyone wants to make the call I'm up for it.
- - - Post Merge - - -
I start school tomorrow so I won't be there for the last 6 hours of day so if you want me to claim, the next few hours is a good time because you wouldn't want me dying
What good is there to claiming now? How about contributing with your reads?
@Ayaya yeah I've had a couple of people make reads/cases on me. Not sure why those 2 even townread me...
@Alexi, look I'm more than happy to claim, so if anyone wants to make the call I'm up for it.
- - - Post Merge - - -
I start school tomorrow so I won't be there for the last 6 hours of day so if you want me to claim, the next few hours is a good time because you wouldn't want me dying
DON'T ****ING CLAIM UNLESS YOU'RE GETTING VOTED UP DAMMIT.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Why not? Whats the point or lynching an inactive today if we can still hit scum today by lynching the most suspicious player? Even then, we can still see who agreed/disagreed with the lynch.
What makes you think that Alexi is so town when you made the case against Alexi in the first place?
With all the claims it is getting irritating, I don't know if people are real claiming or fake claiming but it should stop. No one is threatening you, or if they are it is because you are making lazy claims and now you are pushing on giving your role up for no reason. You are giving away possible PR right to the mafia, I don't know if you are townie or if you are mafia but right now you are my top contender for a vote with the recent moves you have been making. No one else claim unless you NEED to, we have given already 2 possible docs and 3 possible town to the mafia, lets not give the scum any more town.@Ayaya yeah I've had a couple of people make reads/cases on me. Not sure why those 2 even townread me...
@Alexi, look I'm more than happy to claim, so if anyone wants to make the call I'm up for it.
- - - Post Merge - - -
I start school tomorrow so I won't be there for the last 6 hours of day so if you want me to claim, the next few hours is a good time because you wouldn't want me dying
Arstotzkan
A scum mom
Are you sus of Heyden for doing that move? And I don't think I've heard any reasons from you being sus of Heyden. Might have missed it, but mind explaining what you find suspicious about him?
The attitutude he has to the game just throws me off, is he just trying to sound pretty scummy which according to his meta call, he is just acting scummy which also sounds like he does't know how to play mafia so call your attitude in game scummy and no one will care about what he says.i always try to change my meta, like acting scummy in this game
I think this is a OMGUS vote which is just a weak pointless vote since there isn't much to vote at them for at this point.
Also Ayaya made a great point, not that I am bandwagoning on a vote for heyden but with both mafia members giving him a town meta even if they dont really know his metas from other games so why would they call out a town meta unless they were covering for him.
Also this rush of a lynch and saying what I bolded just puts bad taste in my mouth since we already lost 1 town, 1 watcher (is blue neutral this game?), we dont want to loose a lot of town at the start since that always leads town to being sus of each other and then mafia wins, at least that is how my ToS training with it goes. (I apologize if ToS is nothing like this but it is all I know about mafia.
Right now I would say a lot of why I want to lynch him, is that he is either acting scummy just for meta and that his posts just have a scum read in my head. I thought he was a weak town because he didn't post a lot D1 but now I have him at the top of my sus list due to the some of the odd and weak covers he has going through the game.
- - - Post Merge - - -
I gotta jet to school, I am already gonna be late XD but i will try to watch on mobile the best I can, if not, I will catch up when I get home.
@Cadbbery: A blue role is what everyone is referring to as PR's (power roles) they are our best roles to have. (Which is why I find Heyden scummy for trying to hunt them all down). Of course, a townie is just as important because numbers but blue roles hold greater value since they have actions (can shoot at night, save people, etc).
Also I'm glad you used that last quote in your post. I realllly thought I was the only one who found that scummy and wanted to scream.
Also I'm glad you used that last quote in your post. I realllly thought I was the only one who found that scummy and wanted to scream.
Ok, I will make my case/read on alexi, but I'm at school rn so expect at 5pm pst unless something else happens. I know I'm asking a lot, but I want a lot of the people playing so I hope I see you there. This timeslot also gives 2 hours to vote or unvote make sure your there.
blue means power role. doctor, investigator, cop, watcher. etc. green is just vanilla townies. red mafia. yellow is third party.
toadsworthy
Tangsworthy
lol, I'm still sticking with Tardis unless we get some good evidence for Heyden/Alexi
have you not read Heyden's posts? just wondering...
toadsworthy
Tangsworthy
no I have, its just I feel better with a Tardis lynch rn... have you read their posts? they kinda seem like they are getting fed information a little bit, no consistent stream of consciousness ( was saying Ness was scum, then came back the next day and jumped on your bandwagon without any explanation), Daniel wrote them as town lean, and Inkling never touched him in their rants.
- - - Post Merge - - -
and now they claimed Sean Hannity which I think is a meh claim. and then have not come back
- - - Post Merge - - -
With Heyden I think yeah he is saying some scummy stuff right now, but I think its just brutally honest and annoying... the JoAT thing was the stupidest thing, but I mean we saw that coming, its just we shouldn't have put it out there.
and with you, I really like your claim. Seems like a legit person to be a townie, don't know how you would've made that up. so I prefer to lynch tardis right now
