Mafia Make Mafia Grate Again! Game Over! Town wins!

[Chris]

Okay so we have this fight between Aron and cory. Both are being pretty emotional(Cory pressing a bit too hard and Aron taking it too hard) and it's honestly just a distraction. I'm not a fan of Cory's constant,"I'm one of the few people who are scumhunting" ego when you've haven't stated any reason for any of your reads besides "I think they are because of meta and gut feelings". Pointing out suspicious posts and behavior is scumhunting, not by tunneling someone and start a emotional fight. Both of you need to tone it down with the posting because I wasted my time reading your bickering.

Given that we know Daniel was scum, this reads to me as "hey Cory back off my nub". I think Daniel was just understating the whole thing as a 'distraction' to try move the conversation away from Aron's daft claim. Alexi barely posted during Aron & Cory's exchange, and note that after Daniel posted this Aron finally shut up with their constant talk of being the doctor. I'm wondering if Daniel came online, saw what was happening in the thread, and decided to give him a scolding in scum QT.

Yeah, after reading through the past couple pages (40 posts per page so it's not a lot), it really *SEEMS* like he's townie who THOUGHT claiming doctor would be a good idea.
Then when we all freaked out about him claiming, he realized it was the worst thing he could've done. So, I'm reading him as like 60% town 20% actual doctor 20% scum, for now.

Cover-up for if Aron is lynched so she could back and say she didn't totally believe him? I like those noncommittal words she emphasised in their too - "*SEEMS*", "THOUGHT". Her posts also didn't seem very sincere around this time. e.g. she sort of just laughed off Aron's claim and only thought to question it further when she basically just piggybacked off Curry's reaction:

^Exactly what Curry said. Like... Why say that. You get most of the sus of off you, then bring it right back. Wth?

Before this point she was pushing Aron. It seemed like it hit a point where people were deciding to sway on Aron so she changed her tune as a form of damage control.

 

[Chris]

Idk what Tardis is even on about. Seems like he skims a lot or doesn't take the time needed to catch up on what he missed. I mean anyone can read what actually happened with the whole Aron thing & what he posted was way off. He's just rolling with whatever is favorable for town - pretty scummy to me.

Alexi also jumped to push Tardis when Panda suspected him, which is making me even more confident in my belief Tardis is town.

 

[f11]

I think panda is the most likely mafia considering she's still alive at this point.

 

[Curry]

im still curious as to why xine was sus of ness being sk ?

They claim it was purely reaction testing. While I find it INCREDIBLY hard to believe, could there be the possibility of more millers that aren't self aware to throw the cop off? With so many people claiming PR, and there theoretically only being 1-2 mafia left, with a SK most likely, there's 13 townies, with 7 claimed or soft claimed, that seems pretty broken. Is forum mafia normally that stacked?

 

[f11]

I think everyone should go back to look at what the dead mafia said about the alive players, specially panda. Ok I'm going to school now.

 

[Chris]

They claim it was purely reaction testing. While I find it INCREDIBLY hard to believe, could there be the possibility of more millers that aren't self aware to throw the cop off? With so many people claiming PR, and there theoretically only being 1-2 mafia left, with a SK most likely, there's 13 townies, with 7 claimed or soft claimed, that seems pretty broken. Is forum mafia normally that stacked?

Not unless the mafia is strong enough to balance it out. And it doesn't seem it.

Multiple goons and godfather so that's 40-50% with no actions (whether 5 or 6 mafia) feels underpowered. And I'm pretty sure Alexi/Daniel couldn't have been the scum teams strongest players. Not to be rude but if Panda, m3ow_, Sarasa, and Xine are all town-aligned that is waaaay OP in addition to all the supposed PRs we have.

 

[Curry]

Not unless the mafia is strong enough to balance it out. And it doesn't seem it.

Multiple goons and godfather so that's 40-50% with no actions (whether 5 or 6 mafia) feels underpowered. And I'm pretty sure Alexi/Daniel couldn't have been the scum teams strongest players. Not to be rude but if Panda, m3ow_, Sarasa, and Xine are all town-aligned that is waaaay OP in addition to all the supposed PRs we have.

This post makes me want to run out of class and go finish my case I have on my desktop. I'll have something important during today, I'll say that.

 

[toadsworthy]

I think I'm gonna focus on Tina, Ayaya, meow, and panda tonight... I feel like there's some shade in one of them

- - - Post Merge - - -

My previous sus of Tardis does seem less scummy now that people point out stuff.... Will start with that tonight

 

[xine]

Not unless the mafia is strong enough to balance it out. And it doesn't seem it.

Multiple goons and godfather so that's 40-50% with no actions (whether 5 or 6 mafia) feels underpowered. And I'm pretty sure Alexi/Daniel couldn't have been the scum teams strongest players. Not to be rude but if Panda, m3ow_, Sarasa, and Xine are all town-aligned that is waaaay OP in addition to all the supposed PRs we have.

Do hosts usually modify the scumteams or is it random?

 

[Chris]

Do hosts usually modify the scumteams or is it random?

It's one of those things that is frowned upon but most hosts still manually move players around to balance the games. I personally just hit random repeatedly until it looks okay.

 

[ZetaFunction]

Rip.

Time is like a winding river, it repeats itself, and the future can be seen by mapping the past.

LOL I can't believe I was killed tho, I think I know now who's scum

Good luck fellow townies~

 

[xine]

Rip.

Time is like a winding river, it repeats itself, and the future can be seen by mapping the past.

LOL I can't believe I was killed tho, I think I know now who's scum

Good luck fellow townies~

Someone decode that bolder line for me.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Given that we know Daniel was scum, this reads to me as "hey Cory back off my nub". I think Daniel was just understating the whole thing as a 'distraction' to try move the conversation away from Aron's daft claim. Alexi barely posted during Aron & Cory's exchange, and note that after Daniel posted this Aron finally shut up with their constant talk of being the doctor. I'm wondering if Daniel came online, saw what was happening in the thread, and decided to give him a scolding in scum QT.



Cover-up for if Aron is lynched so she could back and say she didn't totally believe him? I like those noncommittal words she emphasised in their too - "*SEEMS*", "THOUGHT". Her posts also didn't seem very sincere around this time. e.g. she sort of just laughed off Aron's claim and only thought to question it further when she basically just piggybacked off Curry's reaction:



Before this point she was pushing Aron. It seemed like it hit a point where people were deciding to sway on Aron so she changed her tune as a form of damage control.

The thing is that every single maf so far has pushed Aronthaer being scum, correct me if I'm wrong. He is a confirmed Doctor, so he would have to be a mafia Doctor if anything.

M30w has a point about the roleblocker role being in play. I am back to square one.

 

[Kirbystarship]

Sorry I haven't been posting. Just don't feel good but now I feel better.

 

[xine]

They claim it was purely reaction testing. While I find it INCREDIBLY hard to believe, could there be the possibility of more millers that aren't self aware to throw the cop off? With so many people claiming PR, and there theoretically only being 1-2 mafia left, with a SK most likely, there's 13 townies, with 7 claimed or soft claimed, that seems pretty broken. Is forum mafia normally that stacked?

Why is that hard to believe?

I mean it's not impossible, but I don't see the reason in talking about it yet considering cop is still hiding.

Theres only 5 blues out in the open (one being dead). Where did you get seven? It is reasonable to assume there are 6, the 6th being the cop, because of the presence of millers and godfather. There is also confirmed SK. Or I should say a confirmed hostile third party.

 

[Aronthaer]

Someone decode that bolder line for me.

Who's the only member here who's name refers to time travel? *coughtardiscough*

- - - Post Merge - - -

I got 15 out of 25 eggs this year, I'm pretty good at riddles haha

- - - Post Merge - - -

Yo, Lucanosa liked my post. I can't prove it to you in any way at all but that's practically confirmation from them that I'm on the right track.

 

[xine]

It's one of those things that is frowned upon but most hosts still manually move players around to balance the games. I personally just hit random repeatedly until it looks okay.

Well, Sarasakat is confirmed Doctor. So the only possibility she would have to be mafia is Mafia Doctor, which I highly doubt. I doubt m3ow bussed Godfather Day 1. That would be too bold. I will reevaluate Panda, but they have been quite consistent from what I remember.

 

[Aronthaer]

Well, Sarasakat is confirmed Doctor. So the only possibility she would have to be mafia is Mafia Doctor, which I highly doubt. I doubt m3ow bussed Godfather Day 1. That would be too bold. I will reevaluate Panda, but they have been quite consistent from what I remember.

And if Sarasa's a confirmed doc, than I am as well. I protected her last night.

 

[Chris]

The thing is that every single maf so far has pushed Aronthaer being scum, correct me if I'm wrong. He is a confirmed Doctor, so he would have to be a mafia Doctor if anything.

Ah! I forgot it was claimed that he prevented a hit.

 

[Aronthaer]

Ah! I forgot it was claimed that he prevented a hit.

by the doctor who also had someone claim had a prevented hit. so either there's a Mafia doc, we're all telling the truth or Xine, Sarasa AND I are all mafia.

 

[Chris]

by the doctor who also had someone claim had a prevented hit. so either there's a Mafia doc, we're all telling the truth or Xine, Sarasa AND I are all mafia.

This feels very unnecessary. I said I forgot one thing.