Mafia Make Mafia Grate Again! Game Over! Town wins!

Even if she is flittering between a miller or a cop, we wouldn't lynch her, but mafia would want to go for her on the chance she is a Cop.... but the mafia isn't going after her for some reason. Instead its picking off Taesaek, Sarasa, or Lucanosa for reasons?

- - - Post Merge - - -

Alexi would've flipped as town on a cops report anyhow

does the godfather do that? was that in her role?
 
Even if she is flittering between a miller or a cop, we wouldn't lynch her, but mafia would want to go for her on the chance she is a Cop.... but the mafia isn't going after her for some reason. Instead its picking off Taesaek, Sarasa, or Lucanosa for reasons?

- - - Post Merge - - -



does the godfather do that? was that in her role?

Also curious about godfather check.
 
Even if she is flittering between a miller or a cop, we wouldn't lynch her, but mafia would want to go for her on the chance she is a Cop.... but the mafia isn't going after her for some reason. Instead its picking off Taesaek, Sarasa, or Lucanosa for reasons?

- - - Post Merge - - -



does the godfather do that? was that in her role?

I'm thinking that mafia is picking people that the town don't expect to die so people don't think they are scum.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Also curious about godfather check.

They are town if a cop checks them.
 
Godfather always (usually maybe) appears as town on cop reports

either way, doesn't this whole Crys thing sound kinda fishy? now seeming to pick on Panda for reasons I think they are posting about now?
 
either way, doesn't this whole Crys thing sound kinda fishy? now seeming to pick on Panda for reasons I think they are posting about now?

Most likely, and seeing as how I was on her sus list, probably a case to go back against me.
 

DAMN CURRY. That was impressive. Definitely seeing your POV here and I think you're on the right track. m3ow_ and Panda are the people I've been reading into this evening as I'm pretty sure one of them (just via process of elimination on other strong players) had to be on the mafia team.

And yes, godfather role means they return either a town role or town-aligned to inspections. Based off Luca's role PM I'm guessing it is by alignment in this game.
 
ClamEatsCurry
Cory
Shiida
Taesaek
Lucanosa
Alexi
Inkling
Call me Daniel


-snip-

Panda1376 - Does no one else find it sus that every person who was remotely sus of Panda is either now dead or a lynch vote she had? Don't worry, I checked every most recent list and read from every player that had one, the one exception to this being Tina who posted her reads during twilight if I remember correctly. Does anyone not find that strange?

I find it extremely convenient that anyone Panda has gotten into an altercation with besides M3ow who I wouldn't say is an altercation, have either been pushed for lynch by her or is dead. Cory and tae are both dead, Qwerty was her lynch vote D2, and shiida was on Alexi's trail when she died N1. So this pattern makes sense to me. Shiida suspects Alexi, dies, Cory fights with Panda, dies, SK gets blocked as claime by D2 evidence, Vig shoots Daniel. D2 Panda pushes Qwerty lynch, but doesn't get it, but tae and Luca end up dead D3. One suspect of Panda possibly, and one suspect of Ayaya.

Another exchange that makes me super sus of Panda is this exchange happened between Inkling and Panda:

What this exchange tells me is that Inkling almost slipped up and Panda tried to help her cover it up, but once Inkling posted the second line, Panda knew she was a lost cause and from then on went on the offense against Inkling.

One of the major things she said in N1 that stuck out to me. In other words, don't say anything that might make us look suspicious or you die.

Now look at what she said to MoAL at the start of today:

I'll start with the bolded part. Is she assuming? What that line right there sounds like to me is that MoAL was really inactive, the both of them are the final two mafia members remaining and MoAL was literally of no help to Panda. So when MoAL comes to the thread to try and potentially start helping, she lashes out "assuming she can't handle the role." How would she even know that she was a PR to say that though? What this tells me is that Panda made a big slip, and that Panda is a framer, MoAL is a roleblocker and the reason neither doctor has been blocked is because MoAL hadn't been sending in actions. Also, under our radar? MoAL was at the top of lots of peoples "I want to lynch today" list. Yet then they show up, Panda claims they are under the radar and gets frustrated that a replacement may have to make up for MoAL being a terrible roleblocker. I understand frustration of an inactive, but this screams scum to me.

Like Tina said, I'd be stunned if the most experienced player from what I hear on the Mafia team was Daniel, so like Tina I think it's one of the ones she listed, namely you as said by this post.

To sum it up, I haven't played with Panda before, but from what I hear she is a very good player. For that reason, I believe she could very easily have found a way to slip and blend in with town. Especially when there are so many new players in the game and she's being helpful to them, why would they consider her mafia when she is being so helpful? Literally no one but Tina, Crys, and I suspects her, so she is doing her job perfect.

Just because I'm not saying a lot doesn't mean I'm not paying attention or trying. There are my reads people want so bad.

-First off whats going on here ? this does what any sense, you make a closed list of your reads and you don't even put me in there as scum ? and then you proceed to scum read cause everyone who sus me is dead ? i don't think anyone has sus me up until this point ? if you are referring to the dead Scum that i voted/made cases on ? why would i be scum for making cases voting for scum ? the only people i remember bring up my name was Tina and Ayaya ? (i think) and they are still here ? so you're not making any sense.

-secondly anyone i got into an altercation with is dead ? not true as well... i think my biggest argument was Ness (sorry for tunneling you Ness) and he is still alive and well.... CLAM you keep bring app people i push for lynch ? but the people lynched were scum ? son don't know what you mean.

-that exchange between Inkling and I was me trying to calm them down i think we all know how Inkling gets super defensive no matter what alignment they are and i was just trying to get them to play without feeling threatened i was giving them the benefit of the doubt (they hinted at a PR) until they went off the deep end and it was all too clear o me that it was mafia grasping at straws to stay alive.


how are you interrupting my quote:
"I have to leave for work shortly but i just wanted to say that i'm all for talking during night phases but at the same time i would be very careful what you say, as to not make anything easy for the scum team."

as:
"One of the major things she said in N1 that stuck out to me. In other words, don't say anything that might make us look suspicious or you die."

i am actually saying the exact opposite, if i wanted to get a message to any summates don't you think i would have just said it in a mafia chat ? i was trying to be helpful to the noobs in this game mostly cause theres been people trying to get people to role claimant i wanted everyone to be aware that what you say at night can and will affective game. (i was trying to keep PR's alive)

this quote of mine:
"@Mother don't come in here telling us you are asking for a replacement cause you can't handle your role (im assuming) and then try to contribute to the game, you are already under our radar and gonna be our lynch confidant (most likely) so if you can't defend yourself don't get a replacement to do it for you? you know what i mean ?"


-i was drinking so i think my reaction was a little too harsh of Mother as you can see my frustration but i think you are spinning it the wrong way, i was frustrated cause we are on to her as scum and then she comes in to say she wants a replacement ? if she was my scum mate don't you think her and i would have discussed it else where ?? AND if she was my scum mate i would gladly take a replacement because you are right she is never here and not helpful (whatever her alignment is) to town or im sure to the mafia team.

Clam i am very happy you finally made reads but its kinda weird that you finally made them and im assuming because you've been on my sus list for not and when you do this are against me ? OMGUS? (i think im using the correctly ha) and in the last paragraph you completely contradict yourself, in the first paragraph you say everyone thats been sus of me is dead, and now you just list everyone who's mentions me before and they are still alive. i don't know whats going on here.
 
Either way guys, were talking about a fake report they made up in the first place

- - - Post Merge - - -

Clam your last point on Panda doesn't make sense, because what she said doesn't make sense....

Daniel didn't know he was gonna get killed (expertly by me I might add :cool:) so her pointing something like that out seems like bad analysis, which seems townie to me
 
Looking at all of mother of all llamas posts and wow they only made 12posts this game I think she is the most inactive player we have in this game.

Sorry guys I've had a rough few days, I want to opt out for a replacement since I just don't have the mental capacity to continue on but I don't want the person to undergo any stress of 250 pages to catch up on. I still have a lot to read (5am, can't sleep). This'll probably be my last game in a while until I can get my life sorted with and all.

This post makes me sus of them because they want a replacement and according to the rules replacements would be used until day3. It sounds like they can't take care of their role and want a replacement and hoping that replacement can be more active then they wer. But I would still think that replacement would be a mafia unless Dolby make that person a townie.
 
Alexi did say her partners were of no help.... which makes me think an inactive person is one of them, Crys still makes sense too because they were actively bussing her that whole day
 
Alexi did say her partners were of no help.... which makes me think an inactive person is one of them, Crys still makes sense too because they were actively bussing her that whole day
You're gonna trust what a mafia player says? I'm pretty sure she didn't mean it literally because she also joked about the scum team list or whatever
 
Alexi did say her partners were of no help.... which makes me think an inactive person is one of them, Crys still makes sense too because they were actively bussing her that whole day

That is a great point, though I dont know how viable it is since you cant be giving to much information in your farewell. Though it may have been just been them frustrated with the vote outcomes. I would say that it makes mother look much more guilty as she has been rather inactive and that could mean they were not active in the night if they were mafia. I think it is also a safe lynch so for now I think I will be voting for Mother since we can almost all agree they are sus
 
You're gonna trust what a mafia player says? I'm pretty sure she didn't mean it literally because she also joked about the scum team list or whatever

its something to consider at least.... does no one else find that weird about Crys? so were just gonna write it off as "they always play crazy"
 
You're gonna trust what a mafia player says? I'm pretty sure she didn't mean it literally because she also joked about the scum team list or whatever

I think she was just jokeing around. Some of the people she talked about they are in the Obs.
 
Either way guys, were talking about a fake report they made up in the first place

- - - Post Merge - - -

Clam your last point on Panda doesn't make sense, because what she said doesn't make sense....

Daniel didn't know he was gonna get killed (expertly by me I might add :cool:) so her pointing something like that out seems like bad analysis, which seems townie to me
My last point? The one where I said that (no offense to Daniel of course) but if he was the most experienced/best player on the mafia team I'd find that incredibly hard to believe? I don't see how that doesn't make sense...

If you're talking about:
ClamEatsCurry said:
One of the major things she said in N1 that stuck out to me. In other words, don't say anything that might make us look suspicious or you die.
Again, I don't see how it doesn't make sense. She says to not make any mistakes of what to say to give info for the scum team. Sure, sounds townie, but you can definitely see it as a scum pov. Just because she says that in public chat, that doesn't mean when someone says something she or someone else doesn't like, they can't then head to the QT and talk about it there.
 
Back
Top