Marshal or Raymond? Who do you like more?

[Rosewater]

Marshal's way cuter. Raymond looks like a 2012 incel

 

[absol]

raymond
he's an office cat with two different eye colours it doesn't get any better than that
but yeah in general I love most of the cats and don't really care about any of the squirrels

hm btw I wonder if anyone does an island that's themed around the office

 

[mayortiffany]

I prefer Raymond. I find his office worker vibe kind of hilarious, and also quite unique. I also like his eyes!

Full disclosure, I have Raymond but I've never had Marshal so I'm a lil' biased here. He also just gave me an ironwood recipe today so...

 

[Halloqueen]

Neither have any strong appeal to me. If I had to choose one of them though, I'd go with Raymond. The heterochromatic eyes and glasses make him the more appealing of the two, because I tend to like villagers who have distinguishing features that set them apart.

 

[SleepyMimeko]

It's got to be Raymond. He's a cute but smug cat with glasses FTW. Maybe it's because he lives on my island, and I have a bias for cats. He's just more unique.

 

[Clock]

Both are ok, but the cat because he stands out more than Marshal.
Although I have a villager I like more over them.

 

[thelonewanderer]

View attachment 245985
Found this picture on twitter a while back!! (@ esaevian)

Got me thinking...
Raymond and Marshal are kind of on the same level. Swoopy bangs, moody eyes... you know? I know both are highly sought after too!!

But who is your favorite? Why?

Personally I like Marshal the most!! Probably from my love for all the squirrels lol

Neither I prefer Rover.

 

[gloomville]

Marshal.

Why is Raymond so popular with eveyrone?

 

[ayeeprill]

I don't really care for either one of them (I know i know BLASPHEMY) but I think Marshal's at least cute-ish. I don't get the Raymond hype at all (i'm sorry don't hurt me)


Kyle, O'Hare, Julian, Zell, and Kidd are my fave smugs

 

[Spunki]

Marshal, because Raymond looks like a Snob. Sorry, but he gives me major Rich Kid Vibes and not the good kinds.

 

[moonshi]

I like them both and have them both! Marshal is always a cutie, like a plushie. Raymond is cute as well but have a more serious look, maybe because of business suit.

 

[Mink777]

Marshal because he hasn’t destroyed the economy.

 

[diamond is unbreakable]

I'm not huge on either, but I definitely prefer Marshal. Raymond's look is so bland to me. There are so many better smugs!

 

[raqball]

I don't really care for either of them and I don't get the hype around them but if I had to choose one or the other I'd take Raymond.

 

[Figment]

I like Raymond. Even before I knew about the hype for him, when I first saw pictures of him, I just liked the idea of a businessman cat.

Marshal is cute. I had no idea he was so popular until I joined TBT, honestly though. If I found him through NMT or in my campsite, I would take him (or Raymond) in a heartbeat and likely keep either of them. They're cute. I don't think it's a matter of hype.

(Though I believe I'd still rather have Pietro, when it comes to smug villagers.)

 

[kirby]

I think raymond has a more interesting and unique design

 

[*Maddy*]

I like them both but I'd say Raymond because he's a business cat! Is that not epic?

 

[Kurashiki]

marshal! i really like the squirrels

 

[Arithmophobia17]

i REALLY like both, and i like cats more, but in recent times i've been leaning a teeny bit on the marshal side since he's much easier to obtain. the Raymond prices are absurd. I know i got lucky getting some of my dreamies for the prices i did, but i don't think it's worth it to spend 100 nmt or more on villagers when most of them are available via amiibo (either you doing it yourself or getting it from a nice person who is cycling them for people), and the ones that aren't can be obtained through island hopping. like sure, there's glitches, and sure, island hopping can take a lot of effort beyond just getting the nmt, but if you're paying more than 400 nmt when generally you could island hop and get a villager for much less, why pay that much?

overall i really fell in love with raymond, and i'm sure i'll love him whenever i obtain him, but right now it feels like that date is so far on the horizon with the ridiculous prices and the high demand. and also marshal is super cute

 

[Clock]

Marshal.

Why is Raymond so popular with eveyrone?

Because a lot of people are obsessed seeing him in a maid outfit or something else and I don't get the point why or the fact that everyone wants to join the bandwagon and to be honest, alot of people want to pay real money for him on ebay which is plain ridiculous imo. I currently have him in my town and he was my first camper to move in by pure luck. Still, I also agree why he is so popular and high demand atm.