i love marshal! but i love raymond too. Currently have raymond on my island but i think i prefer marshal more because his cheeks are beautiful! but i also prefer raymond because he is cool and i love his house exterior. i love both!! (maybe 51% in marshal and 50% on raymond since he still dont teach me how to make a stone lion dog and keep giving me the steel flooring smh) (but my favorite villager always have been beau/muffy also marshal! a bit)
Marshal or Raymond? Who do you like more?
- Thread starter lyradelphie04
- Start date
moon_child
Senior Member
Still a full fledged Marshal fan. I thought I’d like Raymond too but uuuuhhhhmmm he kinda reminds me of those office yuppies who try very very hard to be cool aka the hippie types who like to hang out at those cafes you see on IG and act all cool and all. I dunno. Lolllll. Anyway, I think his appeal is that he’s a new villager with no amiibo yet that’s why he’s “hard to find”. Anyway, sorry Raymond.
I had both villagers at one point. Although I only had Marshal for a few days because of campsite cycling, while Raymond stayed for a month and a half, I think. I actively hunted for Raymond (got him after 243 tickets) just to see the appeal, but I found Marshal more endearing despite the short time I had with him. Also because he's tiny and has music for a hobby.
Design-wise, I like them both. Marshal is cute, while Raymond is cool. But overall, I just prefer Marshal more.
Design-wise, I like them both. Marshal is cute, while Raymond is cool. But overall, I just prefer Marshal more.
CrankyCupcake
overthinks everything
I love them both. Won't choose between them. That's why they're both on my island. 
mintmaple
Andrea
- Joined
- Oct 19, 2013
- Posts
- 133
- Bells
- 232
- Love Tokens
- 0
- Cupid Coins
- 0
- Switch
- 6326-8063-7035
- Island
- Rose Mint
I have both of them living on my island right now.
I'm happy that I got Raymond from less that 10 NMTs and I do like his design, but i've liked Marshal since New Leaf and he's just the cutest grumpy-looking squirrel. I do like Raymond's eye colors and his cute office home.
Marshal wins for me haha
But I love seeing Raymond interact with my other cat villager, Punchy and the whole smug-lazy collison lol
I'm happy that I got Raymond from less that 10 NMTs and I do like his design, but i've liked Marshal since New Leaf and he's just the cutest grumpy-looking squirrel. I do like Raymond's eye colors and his cute office home.
Marshal wins for me haha
But I love seeing Raymond interact with my other cat villager, Punchy and the whole smug-lazy collison lol
Stella-Io
Chasing Luna MothWings
I like Raymond more for his design. I don't think we have any other villager with heterochomania, plus, he has physical glasses, not glasses printed on his face like villagers in past games had. I know the other villagers now have actual physical glasses, like Eugene. Also slightly more bonus points cause he's a cat and I like cats.
Lulucrossing
Lulu🌸
That’s a tricky question. I wasn’t interested in Raymond because I didn’t like the fanbase around him but he was my first campsite villager. At the beginning I thought I would have given him away pretty soon but turned out I really liked him and he has been in my island since March of last year, making him my “older villager”. On the contrary, I always thought that Marshall was better but when I finally had him in my island I wasn’t able to bond with him and let him go pretty quickly. So, I’d say definitely Raymond 
I really like both of them and had the pair of them on my island for a long time, they're probably my top 2 favourite smug villagers, but I slightly prefer Raymond. In real life I'm a big cat person so I usually have a soft spot for the cat villagers and Raymond's colour scheme and personality remind me of one of my Maine coons which has led to him becoming a firm favourite for me and a permanent villager on my island. Eventually I allowed Marshal to leave so that I could try out other villagers but I have since moved him into my NL town so that I could still have both of them between the two games.
BoonyBoo
Spooky Bunny
I'm gonna go with Raymond because my opinion, he's the more smug of the two.
Think about it.. First of all, this little dude is a cat. Cats are famous for being jerks. Secondly, he's a rich businessman with his nerdy little glasses. I wouldn't be surprised if he graduated from the Animal Crossing version of Harvard. Third, look at him prancing around with his rare little eye condition. He swears he's all that in a bag of chips for his eyes being two different colors each. Dude even went as far as to dying the hair on his head to blonde. Lastly, this guy caused the destruction of Nookazon because of his looks and rarity. People are selling him for millions of in-game bells and dozens of in-game miles tickets. I bet he's laughing at all of us while he snuggles up on his fancy little desktop and sips on a Starbucks Frappuccino.
Think about it.. First of all, this little dude is a cat. Cats are famous for being jerks. Secondly, he's a rich businessman with his nerdy little glasses. I wouldn't be surprised if he graduated from the Animal Crossing version of Harvard. Third, look at him prancing around with his rare little eye condition. He swears he's all that in a bag of chips for his eyes being two different colors each. Dude even went as far as to dying the hair on his head to blonde. Lastly, this guy caused the destruction of Nookazon because of his looks and rarity. People are selling him for millions of in-game bells and dozens of in-game miles tickets. I bet he's laughing at all of us while he snuggles up on his fancy little desktop and sips on a Starbucks Frappuccino.
Attachments
Aquilla
slow replies, reach me on discord if you need me
A very difficult choice to make. I like them both very much but for completely different reasons. Marshal is simply adorable, like all the squirrels. I love this bouncy tail and the little blushies on his cheeks. He also looks fantastic in blue sweaters. If I had to pick I would go with Raymond though for the simple and cheesy reason that I have an old grey Maine Coon cat with green eyes. Apart from being grey they don't have any other common features, but it still biases me. I love cats and my cat in particular. I also hate to see the Raymond hate online and how people are being treated simply for liking him so part of me just wants to protect him and give him a safe space. 
Dunquixote
Semi-Hiatus
A very difficult choice to make. I like them both very much but for completely different reasons. Marshal is simply adorable, like all the squirrels. I love this bouncy tail and the little blushies on his cheeks. He also looks fantastic in blue sweaters. If I had to pick I would go with Raymond though for the simple and cheesy reason that I have an old grey Maine Coon cat with green eyes. Apart from being grey they don't have any other common features, but it still biases me. I love cats and my cat in particular. I also hate to see the Raymond hate online and how people are being treated simply for liking him so part of me just wants to protect him and give him a safe space.
Your cat is so gorgeous!
. Thank you for sharing such a cute photo of your cat 
.I agree with you! I honestly don’t get the whole: this villager is overrated argument when everyone has different tastes and reasons for liking a villager. I do understand how some would like to see villagers that are less popular on islands since there are some villagers that are great that I rarely hear mentioned or see on islands like Gaston. I don’t mean any disrespect by any this; I never understood why popularity is made into such a big deal.
Moonlight.
𝘧𝘳𝘰𝘮 𝘵𝘩𝘦 𝘴𝘵𝘢𝘳𝘴
raymond wins by default by being a cat lol. no hate towards marshal though, he's cute.
A very difficult choice to make. I like them both very much but for completely different reasons. Marshal is simply adorable, like all the squirrels. I love this bouncy tail and the little blushies on his cheeks. He also looks fantastic in blue sweaters. If I had to pick I would go with Raymond though for the simple and cheesy reason that I have an old grey Maine Coon cat with green eyes. Apart from being grey they don't have any other common features, but it still biases me. I love cats and my cat in particular. I also hate to see the Raymond hate online and how people are being treated simply for liking him so part of me just wants to protect him and give him a safe space.
Aww your cat is adorable, Maine Coons are such lovely cats and real gentle giants
Similar threads
