Mafia Monster Mash Mafia Game Thread (Town Win!)

tae said:
so is poe for tessa based solely on shawo’s stance on her?
Click to expand...
No. Actually I think he's messing with it all but can't figure it out.

Mostly it's because of shawo's behavior/plays toward you and sidney d1 making you less likely partners. Then only process of elimination. However- I really think there is more pointing toward random at this time.

Don't make fun of me, but yes I'm including that stupid got it post....
 
Looked up coaching, got these-
Both p14, posts 277, 280
(I replied to one saying if got it was an actual maf slip ima high five myself. That still stands, because my crackpot random/shawo, got it/town theory has put me on sus lists this whole stupid game)...

I'll check for instructions, etc and other variations of coached maybe find more.

shawo said:
Oh and, while Got it being a mafia slip would be really funny. (Imagine. Mafia partner telling Random to post, and Random posts got it in the forum lol.) It really doesn't seem maffy because realistically if someone was coaching Random to post... they'd probably give more guidance. Realistically Random just posted for... X reason.
Click to expand...

shawo said:
Am I... using jargon? Are you a mafia layman?

Let me iso real quick though because I'm not super confident on pushing a tone sr.
Post automatically merged:


TL;DR given the time in the game that was posted, and the context, I'd expect mafia!random to have posted a better post. Even due to coaching. The post itself is inherently null value from a gameplay perspective, but given the fact that everyone else in the game seems competent enough, it stands to reason that anyone would've/could've/should've coached random to do... literally anything else. Granted there's a big assumption here in that mafia!random would respond to coaching at all, given how the games going, and I do think random's next post was really bad, but that's the circumstance behind why I said it when I did.
Click to expand...
 
Sheep Villager said:
Don't think I have a choice unfortunately. Left to the cruel fate of being torn to shreds by whoever is in obs chat. 😔
Click to expand...

ultimately you made a good play. you backed mafia into a corner and that’s your job homie. cop sucks and i know i hate playing cop- so like give yourself some credit. you gut instinct’d it and snipped mafia on your first inspection. that’s pretty dope.
Post automatically merged:

YOU’RE NOT LEAVING US EMPTY HANDED SHEEP.
 
Also wanted to post one more reason I believe it would be random over tessa. Tessa didn't join the game until fairly late. I'd think maf would want to be there and not just be completely absent most of d1.
 
BetsySundrop said:
Looked up coaching, got these-
Both p14, posts 277, 280
(I replied to one saying if got it was an actual maf slip ima high five myself. That still stands, because my crackpot random/shawo, got it/town theory has put me on sus lists this whole stupid game)...

I'll check for instructions, etc and other variations of coached maybe find more.
Click to expand...


i think there’s maf between random or sidney. it’s just figuring out who it really is. i feel like more people are inclined towards axing random for their play style and i can’t wait to go over and re-read some posts and iso the two. if you did pick up a mafslip i’ll legit cackle tho bc that’s just unfortunate for the mafia.
 
BetsySundrop said:
Looked up coaching, got these-
Both p14, posts 277, 280
(I replied to one saying if got it was an actual maf slip ima high five myself. That still stands, because my crackpot random/shawo, got it/town theory has put me on sus lists this whole stupid game)...

I'll check for instructions, etc and other variations of coached maybe find more.
Click to expand...

That puts the whole word choices thing in to the unfortunate spot of it could've been just a general parrot then. I find it a bit more NAI than if it had come up with no-one else bringing it up before. It is still in the ???? category tho.
 
BetsySundrop said:
Also wanted to post one more reason I believe it would be random over tessa. Tessa didn't join the game until fairly late. I'd think maf would want to be there and not just be completely absent most of d1.
Click to expand...

i mean, on the backside of that… laying low and not bringing attention to yourself is pretty smooth sailing sometimes.
Post automatically merged:

also random was completely AWOL most of d1 as well…
 
tae said:
i think there’s maf between random or sidney. it’s just figuring out who it really is. i feel like more people are inclined towards axing random for their play style and i can’t wait to go over and re-read some posts and iso the two. if you did pick up a mafslip i’ll legit cackle tho bc that’s just unfortunate for the mafia.
Click to expand...

The sad, tragic, most awful thing is-

If it was a legit maf slip, I'll be even more inclined to post my crackpot theories in future games, which really isn't helpful...
 
Also in then name of town I do want to make the note now that whilst Tae is being very nice right now please do not forget to check them going forward too. I do find the willingness to talk towny but you should always scrutinize things in this game.
 
Sheep Villager said:
Also in then name of town I do want to make the note now that whilst Tae is being very nice right now please do not forget to check them going forward too. I do find the willingness to talk towny but you should always scrutinize things in this game.
Click to expand...
TT_TT I also got an infraction for being too spicy so take that into consideration thx
 
tae said:
TT_TT I also got an infraction for being too spicy so take that into consideration thx
Click to expand...

Too spicy?! Lol, guess I should watch it, I've seen some really spicy spice - usually instigated by myself, on accident, of course...
Post automatically merged:

Sheep Villager said:
Also in then name of town I do want to make the note now that whilst Tae is being very nice right now please do not forget to check them going forward too. I do find the willingness to talk towny but you should always scrutinize things in this game.
Click to expand...
If you do have time to quick read through d1 just for tae/shawo interactions and tell me if I'm missing anything, but it seemed to me unlikely partners...
 
Sheep Villager said:
Also in then name of town I do want to make the note now that whilst Tae is being very nice right now please do not forget to check them going forward too. I do find the willingness to talk towny but you should always scrutinize things in this game.
Click to expand...
Sorry if you already said this, but what are your reads like now?
Post automatically merged:

i won’t weigh in on the random vs me situation aside from saying that random is a decent possibility for tomorrow’s vote from me (and the obvious; i’ll answer whatever)

We’ve looked at random’s posts so much i’m not sure there’s anything else for me to gather until they post again
 
Last edited:
shawo said:
Oh and, while Got it being a mafia slip would be really funny. (Imagine. Mafia partner telling Random to post, and Random posts got it in the forum lol.) It really doesn't seem maffy because realistically if someone was coaching Random to post... they'd probably give more guidance. Realistically Random just posted for... X reason.
Click to expand...
I may be bad, but if that was thee case, I wouldn't be that bad.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Damniel
Mafia Among Us Mafia Game Thread (Town Win!)
139 140 141
Replies
3K
Views
101K
unravel
unravel
N e s s
Mafia TBT Mafia - Darkest Dungeon (Cancelled)
Replies
15
Views
920
N e s s
N e s s
E
Mafia The Quest for King - Mafia | Game Thread | GAME OVER
89 90 91
Replies
2K
Views
51K
Jacob4
Jacob4
TN4U
Mafia Redd's Revenge - Game Thread [GAME OVER]
56 57 58
Replies
1K
Views
31K
BetsySundrop
BetsySundrop
Damniel
Mafia Among Us Mafia - Sign Ups
2
Replies
24
Views
2K
Damniel
Damniel
Back
Top