Mafia Monster Mash Mafia Game Thread (Town Win!)

[tae]

is the last paragraph about me? I don’t remember saying anything like that

no the post was quoted towards sheep villager.
they asked me my gut reads on people.

Post automatically merged: Oct 16, 2022

As a side note here btw, if anyone ever feels like I'm coming off too harsh on another player during game then I do apologize for that. I genuinely don't mean to be mean or bully anyone.

its not forum mafia if theres no spice. be spicy.

 

[Trent the Paladin]

I'm gonna go take a moment to prep some sort of meal for myself but after that I'll likely post my funny little reads list since making those gives my brain so much serotonin.

We have like four hours until EoD where is brain serotonin list

 

[tessa grace]

If you're #Anti-No-Elim gang, who would you place a vote on right this instance?

Hmm maybe tae or sidney, the vibes are just off. Going off of gut though as there is little to no substantial information we can go off of.

 

[Sidney]

here’s is….all that i have one people so far, maybe this can help discussion?

1. shawo shawo just confuses me; think it’s possible may have been looking for an easy kill but also possibly just town. did do the math on elims and post that, so that’s probs a good reason for town? though still not sure why me; no good reasoning and disappeared. Why did he say “town” to random’s “got it”?

2. tae not enough interaction

3. Sidney this is me

4. Totally_RandomYT - what was that one message?

5. Trent more experienced/older player, will probably be hard to get a good read for a while (less inclined to trust somehow who has potentially learned how to play/hide mafia)

6. BetsySundrop if shawo is mafia, this is my guess for mafia #2 as of now

7. tessa grace not enough interaction

8. Sheep Villager pushing a lot for day1 elim, seems eager ish to off unactives, pushing for tons of activity, possibly sus looking for easy town kill that seems town (no real new suspicions yet that i’ve seen, just questioning everyone else’s)

9. StarlitGlitch not enough interaction

 

[Trent the Paladin]

Hmm maybe tae or sidney, the vibes are just off. Going off of gut though as there is little to no substantial information we can go off of.

Do either of them rank higher than the other in this? What throws their vibes off?

 

[Sidney]

I’m gonna feel bad (for town) if you do elim me because my vibes are simply anxiety and newness

though i guess if we can’t find an actual mafia any information is better

 

[Trent the Paladin]

here’s is….all that i have one people so far, maybe this can help discussion?

1. shawo shawo just confuses me; think it’s possible may have been looking for an easy kill but also possibly just town. did do the math on elims and post that, so that’s probs a good reason for town? though still not sure why me; no good reasoning and disappeared. Why did he say “town” to random’s “got it”?

2. tae not enough interaction

3. Sidney this is me

4. Totally_RandomYT - what was that one message?

5. Trent more experienced/older player, will probably be hard to get a good read for a while (less inclined to trust somehow who has potentially learned how to play/hide mafia)

6. BetsySundrop if shawo is mafia, this is my guess for mafia #2 as of now

7. tessa grace not enough interaction

8. Sheep Villager pushing a lot for day1 elim, seems eager ish to off unactives, pushing for tons of activity, possibly sus looking for easy town kill that seems town (no real new suspicions yet that i’ve seen, just questioning everyone else’s)

9. StarlitGlitch not enough interaction

Can you elaborate some more on the Shawo/Betsy pairing?

 

[tessa grace]

Do either of them rank higher than the other in this? What throws their vibes off?

Well I mostly townread tae like I said earlier so sidney probably ranks higher. Right after I said that sidney posted their reads on people but none of them are entirely certain at all, which I get (cause I can't decide either f3 droquen anyone) but it also seems like that uncertainty makes it easier to sway to any point of view which can be good to blend in. Just kind of flaky.
As for tae, its more of a joke. They just seem angry.

 

[Sheep Villager]

We have like four hours until EoD where is brain serotonin list

Working on it boss. Got caught up by some weird people named Tae and Trent questioning me.

 

[tessa grace]

Also newbies are always maf its a curse

 

[Sidney]

Can you elaborate some more on the Shawo/Betsy pairing?

sure yeah

it’s mostly just a gut feeling/sus for now

if i read everything correctly, they were the first two to throw out suggestions for people to be eliminated

First shawo goes for me, an anxious newbie + low hanging fruit + i know my own alignment

Then shawo and betsy engage in a conversation and betsy throws out the next suggestions, two inactives, more low hanging fruit

I can’t townread this because I’m too suspicious of people and just think this would’ve been an easy way for mafia to manufacture a conversation that pushes us towards 3 different elims while not suspecting both of them + easy cover up when it turns up those people are town (if they are)

 

[Trent the Paladin]

and for some reason I am always in f3 and I always screw it up for my side.

cause I can't decide either f3 droquen anyone

Is this referring to a past game here on TBT?

 

[tae]

To me, this is a townread. Voting inactive is useless when inactive will already get kicked/replaced eventually. Being inactive imo is usually less intentional than people think, for example I just spaced the whole game and was a little too busy to play at first. I should've set a reminder so it's on me, but my or anyone else's lack of activity shouldn't be a read on their role. Their posts combined with the activity? Occasionally. But I think it's good to focus on the actual posts that they make.

Hmm maybe tae or sidney, the vibes are just off. Going off of gut though as there is little to no substantial information we can go off of.

>> also wants to d1 vote elim me.

unless i read your post wrong and you meant the townread was on sheep villager for wanting to d1 vote elim an inactive.

 

[tessa grace]

Is this referring to a past game here on TBT?

Several, including me.

 

[tae]

Well I mostly townread tae like I said earlier so sidney probably ranks higher. Right after I said that sidney posted their reads on people but none of them are entirely certain at all, which I get (cause I can't decide either f3 droquen anyone) but it also seems like that uncertainty makes it easier to sway to any point of view which can be good to blend in. Just kind of flaky.
As for tae, its more of a joke. They just seem angry.

ofc we post at the same time i miss this.

im not angry, im just spicy in mafia. ask trent or shawo. im always spicy

 

[Sidney]

Also newbies are always maf its a curse

i did one other game here and was town that time, actually

Post automatically merged: Oct 16, 2022

This meant to be read pretty neutral, but, It feels unfair if your only reasoning is that I’m new and I’m genuinely not sure what else I can say to convince. I started posting more when told i wasn’t posting enough, too, even though i feel like I’m still not adding much

 

[tessa grace]

sure yeah

it’s mostly just a gut feeling/sus for now

if i read everything correctly, they were the first two to throw out suggestions for people to be eliminated

First shawo goes for me, an anxious newbie + low hanging fruit + i know my own alignment

Then shawo and betsy engage in a conversation and betsy throws out the next suggestions, two inactives, more low hanging fruit

I can’t townread this because I’m too suspicious of people and just think this would’ve been an easy way for mafia to manufacture a conversation that pushes us towards 3 different elims while not suspecting both of them + easy cover up when it turns up those people are town (if they are)

Why do you think bringing up an elim=mafia?

ofc we post at the same time i miss this.

im not angry, im just spicy in mafia. ask trent or shawo. im always spicy

i was fr so confused by your post right before this lol. and i could believe that you're regularly spicy, if i get the energy I'll check your other games to get a read

 

[Sidney]

Well I mostly townread tae like I said earlier so sidney probably ranks higher. Right after I said that sidney posted their reads on people but none of them are entirely certain at all, which I get (cause I can't decide either f3 droquen anyone) but it also seems like that uncertainty makes it easier to sway to any point of view which can be good to blend in. Just kind of flaky.
As for tae, its more of a joke. They just seem angry.

yeah, as i said earlier, that’s where I am and why i wasn’t posting much. I don’t feel i have anything substantial to go on (not that i know what i’m looking for anyhow) but was told anything > nothing so you get…something

 

[tae]

i was fr so confused by your post right before this lol. and i could believe that you're regularly spicy, if i get the energy I'll check your other games to get a read

i was too lazy to re-do the whole post bc it got hecked up.
i actually messed up part of the post bc it originally went

*ur post town reading me*
>townreads me

*ur post naming me in ur d1 elim vote picks*
>> also wants to d1 elim me.

 

[Sidney]

Why do you think bringing up an elim=mafia?

i was fr so confused by your post right before this lol. and i could believe that you're regularly spicy, if i get the energy I'll check your other games to get a read

Because we have a role check thing as well, and eliminating today only gives us one more elim chance (with a high chance of offing a townie), i think it’s more wise to have someone that’s for sure suspicious/highly suspected to be mafia rather than just random suggestions

like…what if we accidentally killed off our role check person today? I would think that would be more harmful than losing an elim