Mafia Monster's Ball Mafia [Game Thread - Endgame, Town Wins!]]
- Thread starter Geoni
- Start date
If you are looking for a wolf in room 2, buddy I’m not it. I can justify everything I did forwards and backwards. I can’t say if there is a wolf in room 2… I am confused why b100ming did not vote in the end to tie with tessa for a chance at being saved by the RNG… doesn’t seem like a mafia move to make.
She sussed you cafflibe
Post automatically merged:
And caffline me and b100ming were playing ssb so she had not time also sorry for losing my cool at you ness you just said a huge lie and I raged
Last edited:
Haha okay Ghost2008 is town. Just to say it louder for those that forgot, this setup is Mountainous. There are only Townies and Mafia. I lied about being cop because I figured people would be too distracted by the cells to remember.
I figured if I was to try this idea on anyone, Ghost2008 was going to react in one of two ways:
1. Get extremely angry and defense and call me out for lying (he did this)
2. immediately admit defeat that a Cop investigated him (this didn’t happen)
Given how hard it was going to be to solve Ghost’s slot later in the game I think this was a success for town here. Ghost, just to emphasize, I had no ill intentions on getting you eliminated. This was purely to try and solve your slot.
I’m still at work so I’ll look at the other reactions to this later, Ace’s in particular feels fairly townish unless he’s just trying to win an Oscar this year.
I figured if I was to try this idea on anyone, Ghost2008 was going to react in one of two ways:
1. Get extremely angry and defense and call me out for lying (he did this)
2. immediately admit defeat that a Cop investigated him (this didn’t happen)
Given how hard it was going to be to solve Ghost’s slot later in the game I think this was a success for town here. Ghost, just to emphasize, I had no ill intentions on getting you eliminated. This was purely to try and solve your slot.
I’m still at work so I’ll look at the other reactions to this later, Ace’s in particular feels fairly townish unless he’s just trying to win an Oscar this year.
hi, ive played with dan before yes, i'm not rly sure why that would need to be the case tho? hes probably the strongest player on here (except ness) and by the looks of things was pretty safe on day 1 , its weird ur ruling caffine out only based on that tbhhh........... like sure maybe less sus of them but absolutely clearing them? ? w eird
also im here but im about to sleep, all i rly have to say is i hate the whole hidden alignment thing
Post automatically merged:
im still not even sure on my own room still, much less anyone else, id have to read the whole thread again.. all i kind of thought that i didnt think betsy was all that sus and now that dans ruled out that kind of leaves ness since i kind of cleared ace in my mind already , but then that whole cop thing would be kinda strange as maf but ness is kinda bold lol , just inner thoughts idk, i shuld read back on besty
Post automatically merged:
also is droq cleared? i swear ive read the rules but im lost on the whole ghost thing? are we all ghosts? whats the message thing about? can they post anything as a ghost? if mafia is killed are they also a ghost? i feel like i missed a post or a rule or something , and if droq was mafia i feel like they would have tried to post something more leading as a last message , seems like a towny kind of note rip
Last edited:
@mogyay gun to your head who are the 3 mafia. Don’t think just tell me.
Also @Ace Marvel could you ask whoever has the neighborizer if they’d be comfortable revealing themselves, now that the cells are done I don’t think Y’all’s private chat is too useful anymore. Could be valuable information since I doubt that whoever has it is teamed with you at minimum.
Also @Ace Marvel could you ask whoever has the neighborizer if they’d be comfortable revealing themselves, now that the cells are done I don’t think Y’all’s private chat is too useful anymore. Could be valuable information since I doubt that whoever has it is teamed with you at minimum.
ok so if ghost is town and droq is town since im usually always wrong about anything then its kind of shell then yikes , which makes sense now about the dan question
u, shell and caffine
but also i actually didnt rly read day 2 so im just being mean to caffine tbh
u know who has guns ness? MAFIA . susss
i want to change my mind and pretend we actually killed someone as town tho , im being a bit pessimistic lol
ill stop post merging now, sorry
Post automatically merged:
u, shell and caffine
but also i actually didnt rly read day 2 so im just being mean to caffine tbh
Post automatically merged:
u know who has guns ness? MAFIA . susss
Post automatically merged:
i want to change my mind and pretend we actually killed someone as town tho , im being a bit pessimistic lol
Post automatically merged:
ill stop post merging now, sorry
Alright this is kind of my head space right now.
Towncore: Ghost2008, Ace Marvel, Sheep Villager
Null: Caffline
Wolf Pool: Tessa., mogyay
Frankly I just think Betsy was mafia, I haven’t got any real reason behind it since she was honestly doing just okay, but I feel that she had the least going for her than Dan or Ace. Dan’s point about her feeling ambivalent to the elimination + the fact that she has yet to use her haunt is mostly what makes me think it’s her.
B100ming was 100% a mis elimination. She spewed herself as town by failing to try and force an RNG elimination. If she was mafia, she would have taken the shot at saving herself. Her post begging Caffline to unvote her also bleeds town to me purely in the sense that it was just genuinely her pleading as town.
Droqen is a mystery and so is all of room 3. My hunch though is that he’s town, since the wagon on him was fairly weak in general. Droqen if you’re town please use your seance soon, and use it effectively.
More to say on Tessa and Mog later but I personally think the elimination for this phase needs to be either Tessa or Caffline.
Oh I forgor shell existed
Honestly I can’t tell with them lmao they feel like they’re trying to solve this game unlike when they were mafia in Resident Evil but eh.
Towncore: Ghost2008, Ace Marvel, Sheep Villager
Null: Caffline
Wolf Pool: Tessa., mogyay
Frankly I just think Betsy was mafia, I haven’t got any real reason behind it since she was honestly doing just okay, but I feel that she had the least going for her than Dan or Ace. Dan’s point about her feeling ambivalent to the elimination + the fact that she has yet to use her haunt is mostly what makes me think it’s her.
B100ming was 100% a mis elimination. She spewed herself as town by failing to try and force an RNG elimination. If she was mafia, she would have taken the shot at saving herself. Her post begging Caffline to unvote her also bleeds town to me purely in the sense that it was just genuinely her pleading as town.
Droqen is a mystery and so is all of room 3. My hunch though is that he’s town, since the wagon on him was fairly weak in general. Droqen if you’re town please use your seance soon, and use it effectively.
More to say on Tessa and Mog later but I personally think the elimination for this phase needs to be either Tessa or Caffline.
Post automatically merged:
Oh I forgor shell existed
Honestly I can’t tell with them lmao they feel like they’re trying to solve this game unlike when they were mafia in Resident Evil but eh.
Ace Marvel
Merry & Happy
I don’t really see it being Sheep? They put in the most effort out of anyone in that room and I’m vibing with most of their posts.
Tessa feels less confident in herself in this game than I’ve seen her prior to now. Iirc she was more of a town leader in previous games?
Ace Marvel
Merry & Happy
It's not Tessa, and Sheep did everything I told them to do when we were mafia buddies, even trying to use that against me.
Also I'll let you guess why it's never Tessa.
Post automatically merged:
I think we are looking for room 2 and 3 wolves
tessa grace
yeehaw
Hello hello hello all
sadly our relative's flight was delayed but I'm finally back home.
Regarding the ness fake-claim, I felt like Ghost's reaction felt very town to me. In fact, even though people were somewhat suspicious of ghost, his actions match up with the games I've played with him; short responses and instant reactions. If anything, he feels the most town.
With ness trying to get a reaction from ghost, and him and dan agreeing for most of cell 1, I doubt he's mafia and he doesn't feel like the type to take Damniel out of the game so quickly if he was mafia. That doesn't rule him out entirely but I'm leaning more town towards him as well.
As I'm writing this I'm starting to think more and more that betsy was mafia, ace seems cryptic as usual. just kidding, but still you're hard to read most of the time. most of room one hurt my brain
Idk how to feel about my room, and I have less confidence in the b100ming vote I started. I agree that her not voting to make the game equal against me felt very town, so I'm pretty open the idea of looking through cell 2 today. I should probably iso first, though (or at least reread my cell)
mog seems... well busy honestly (and i feel that on so many levels) and shell feels a little less strong than when they played as mafia recently
infact @Sheep Villager I still feel terrible about voting you I'm very very sorry
anyway I try not to think about it often so please can we never bring that game up again
sadly our relative's flight was delayed but I'm finally back home.
Regarding the ness fake-claim, I felt like Ghost's reaction felt very town to me. In fact, even though people were somewhat suspicious of ghost, his actions match up with the games I've played with him; short responses and instant reactions. If anything, he feels the most town.
With ness trying to get a reaction from ghost, and him and dan agreeing for most of cell 1, I doubt he's mafia and he doesn't feel like the type to take Damniel out of the game so quickly if he was mafia. That doesn't rule him out entirely but I'm leaning more town towards him as well.
As I'm writing this I'm starting to think more and more that betsy was mafia, ace seems cryptic as usual. just kidding, but still you're hard to read most of the time. most of room one hurt my brain
Idk how to feel about my room, and I have less confidence in the b100ming vote I started. I agree that her not voting to make the game equal against me felt very town, so I'm pretty open the idea of looking through cell 2 today. I should probably iso first, though (or at least reread my cell)
mog seems... well busy honestly (and i feel that on so many levels) and shell feels a little less strong than when they played as mafia recently
I have no idea if this means anything but I lost my confidence after being in f3 with geoni and sheep
infact @Sheep Villager I still feel terrible about voting you I'm very very sorry
anyway I try not to think about it often so please can we never bring that game up again
oh, I just know caffline irl so it was like: there's no way she'd know to kill dan from get go - especially being her first time playing mafia. But like Ace said: maf has chat which is something i forgot about so she's back on my sussy list.
I'm kinda curious about ace and the neighbourhood. why ace? and who sent the invite??
Room 2's kinda fuzzy in my mind and it's the room IDK about.
Room 3: Mog's still my prime suspect just cause I don't think it's ghost.
also i just gotta say, i'm like... very distracted/busy. havent given much time actually reading too much yet. l'll have more time during weekend sorry >.<
Post automatically merged:
ouch
Post automatically merged:
ghost I've been town reading you this whole time
Last edited:
Oh okoh, I just know caffline irl so it was like: there's no way she'd know to kill dan from get go - especially being her first time playing mafia. But like Ace said: maf has chat which is something i forgot about so she's back on my sussy list.
I'm kinda curious about ace and the neighbourhood. why ace? and who sent the invite??
Room 2's kinda fuzzy in my mind and it's the room IDK about.
Room 3: Mog's still my prime suspect just cause I don't think it's ghost.
also i just gotta say, i'm like... very distracted/busy. havent given much time actually reading too much yet. l'll have more time during weekend sorry >.<
Post automatically merged:
ouch
Post automatically merged:
ghost I've been town reading you this whole time
Why is it not tessa? Am I missing something?
Geoni
You're doing great!
No. 9 vanilla townies, 3 mafia goons, and before the game was randed an individual was given a neighborizing prize for winning the favorite custom monster contest. That's all that's in this game.
Last edited by a moderator:
oh! @Ace Marvel you keep insisting that @tessa. is innocent. is this because tessa is the one who neighbourized you?
but if i understand correctly, the person with the neighbour ability is literally chosen cause they have the best monster, it's not indicative of alignment at all. correct @Geoni ?
but if i understand correctly, the person with the neighbour ability is literally chosen cause they have the best monster, it's not indicative of alignment at all. correct @Geoni ?
Geoni
You're doing great!
