Most underrated villagers in ACNH?

[crazycatlady713]

I don't understand why Julia isn't more popular! She's got adorable anime eyes and her house is color coordinated with her body. Also, I like to consider her trans as she is clearly a peacock but is also female so, ya know, represent.

 

[paleogamer11]

I don't understand why Julia isn't more popular! She's got adorable anime eyes and her house is color coordinated with her body. Also, I like to consider her trans as she is clearly a peacock but is also female so, ya know, represent.

I can see her that way, and I don’t like it. Another thing, could you reply to my leather thread?

 

[crazycatlady713]

I can see her that way, and I don’t like it. Another thing, could you reply to my leather thread?

Leather thread?

 

[paleogamer11]

Leather thread?

The thread is about overshadowed villagers. It’s in the general AC Discussion.

 

[Serabee]

I don't understand why Julia isn't more popular! She's got adorable anime eyes and her house is color coordinated with her body. Also, I like to consider her trans as she is clearly a peacock but is also female so, ya know, represent.

YES! Julia is one of my dreamies because of all that

 

[Dunquixote]

Tex is underrated and harry

I agree! I had Harry in NL with Gaston and while I didn’t care for Harry’s design, he still grew on me nonetheless. My memories with Harry were good .

Initially I didn’t like Tex, but I got him from @JeffreyAC’s void and he eventually grew on me. He looks really cute in the vampire costume and the black tailcoat . Sadly, I just recently let him go. I wouldn’t say he’s a favorite now but I think he deserves some more love and am glad I gave him a chance. .

 

[Bk1234]

C A R O L I N E

 

[John Wick]

C A R O L I N E
View attachment 292972

Love her.

Had her in a WW town many years ago.

Her eyes are awesome!

 

[cici..crossing]

vivian and cally. i love them so much.

 

[Bk1234]

Love her.

Had her in a WW town many years ago.

Her eyes are awesome!

I just got her and to be honest, I think I’m happier that I got her before Marshal (now I want Kyle as my 2nd Smug because he flirted with me on an island ). Her big blue eyes are SO cute!!!

 

[JunoHorizon]

Pecan! She's super cute but I don't see much love for her online.

 

[BluebearL]

Just had to come back to this thread to say... HANS! He is a super sweet, smug Yetti and I think he deserves some recognition. His house is cool and I really like his design. He is now one of my favourite new residents and is here to stay

 

[Moritz]

Tybalt!
And Flip, and Colton, and Hans.

But remember, the less popular your favourites are, the more original your island looks and the easier they are for you to get given.

 

[JemAC]

Seen Bea mentioned a few times in this thread and completely agree that she's very underrated, I'm not sure if people think she's a bit plain or maybe its due to the normal personality that some find boring (though the same could be said for Goldie who seems to be a popular villager) but I think she's really cute and a really good villager so it's nice seeing her getting some love in this thread. Also I agree with the support for Caroline, she has a really pretty design, maybe a tad too bright, but she fits really nicely into a tropical island theme.

A few others that seem too underrated:
Portia - I never really see her getting much love and she always seem to be low on any villager popularity lists but she's a really nice villager, plus she has my favourite personality so that makes her even better
Olive - seen her mentioned on this thread and agree that she's just as good as the other cubs that get a lot of love
Murphy - he was a random move in on my island and is a really sweet villager but never seems very popular
Many Rabbits - some do get a lot of love but most rabbits seem unpopular yet they're such a cute species with some really good designs
Blaire - probably another one that doesn't get lots of love due to the relatively plain design compared to some other squirrels but I think she's really cute
Vivian - another one that's been mentioned in this thread, I like all the wolves but Vivian and Freya are my favourite female ones but they always seem to be the least popular ones
Hopper - never seems to get a lot of love for a penguin but he's one of the top cranks for me
Chickens, Kangaroos and Elephants - very few of these seem to get much love and most rank very low on popularity polls (chickens mostly) but I think there are some very good villagers in these species and they deserve a lot more love then they get

 

[Tindre]

Pierce, I feel like almost no one knows about how cute he is?? Like he looks so dependable and friendly. I love him.. Also Rocco the tough but sweet hippo.. and Sylvana the cutest villager of them all!

 

[Candy83]

I will name one underrated villager applicable each personality category. That will be followed by one additional male and one additional female. It can read like the cast of one’s island.

• Cranky dog Butch
• Snooty cat Kitty
• Lazy monkey Simon
• Normal kangaroo Carrie
• Jock alligator Sly
• Peppy horse Winnie
• Smug goat Kidd
• Uchi chicken Plucky

• Additional Male: Jock duck Bill
• Additional female: Peppy bird Twiggy

 

[piske]

Tfw you went through the whole thread liking posts only to realize most were from June and July of last year...

I think Penelope is really underrated! Her design is really adorable, her mod haircut, one little tooth, and her giant bow ears! And a pink tail! She has the perfect look for a peppy imo c:

 

[Jam86]

well i love so many villagers but idk which are underrated tbh so i'll name the ones i don't see others mention often lol

pashmina, canberra, frita, flip, peck, biff, pierce, frobert, bill, boone, hamlet, samson, sly, tad, bangle, gabi, bella, anabelle, dotty, maddie, carmen, pango, patty, puddles, pippy, peanut, tutu, wendy, beardo, chadder, o'hare, shep, kidd, jacques, baabara, cashmere, cleo, tipper, greta, snooty, julia, boris, curt, bruce, grizzly, cyrano, groucho, buzz, del, gruff, rooney, murphy, hamphrey, cesar, harry, chow, ike, rasher, ricky, hopper, wart jr, cally, deena, annalisa, caroline, dora, carrie, bea, bertha, rhonda, mitzi, nana, sydney, norma, alfonso, claude, chester, papi, crackle(spork), cole, tucker, prince, rodeo, dizzy, hornsby, hugh, ozzie

there might be more i missed or some of these may be popular because like i say, idk who's underrated haha
but i love loads of villagers and don't really notice if someone hates a villager i like

 

[Plainbluetees]

crackle(spork)

Spork was one of my starting lazies and I regret letting him go. He was so adorable!

I also like Anicotti. I haven’t had her, but she looks so chill. And her catchphrase is cannoli!! What more could you want?
(Not my photo below.)

 

[JKDOS]

I don't know if some of these are underrated or not but I'll give it a try.

Fuchsia - The Uchi Deer. I love her house in New Horizons, and I don't mind her yellow bangs as much as I thought I would.

I think Jocks as a whole are underrated. Some good ones are

• Rudy the cat. My favorite of all the jocks.
• Genji the Rabbit. He kept his name from the Japanese version
• Tybalt the Tiger
• Ribbot and Sprocket - Okay hear me out. These guys are humorous in an ironic kind of way. They are both robots, yet they think they can train their abs and hamstrings, etc. The only realistic thing they say is something like "I just finished my 7000th pull up rep"

Carmen - The Peppy Rabbit. Carmen was introduced in City Folk, and I didn't even really know she existed until this year, so maybe she is too underrated.

Moe - The lazy cat. When it comes to the lazy villagers, especially the cat ones, Punchy and Bob seem to take the spotlight. I tend to forget Moe exists because he doesn't ever seem to be talked about.