Most underrated villagers in ACNH?

[Matt0106]

I will preach this until the day Animal Crossing is erased from existence, but...

Elmer is the sweetest little horse. The most adorable, in my opinion. I don't know why but he's my favourite villager and I'm a little surprised that he's usually thrown under the rug compared to the other horses. Give him some love people (jk, this is just topical humour and not meant to be taken seriously).

 

[-Lumi-]

My sweet boy Egbert is the light of my island and I can’t believe he’s not more popular he’s so cute especially when he’s wearing the cute shirt from Father’s Day! It’s got a little cape on it and it makes him look 10 times cuter when he’s running around!

Spoiler: Egbert 🥰

He’s one of the few villagers who actually lets me sit beside him long enough to get a picture

He loves to sing, too! Not quite as much as Lolly but

He’s also super sweet and supportive of Lolly’s singing!

I love him so much

 

[mayor.lauren]

i really love tutu! she’s so so cute and i feel like her peppy personality suits her so well! i always love having her on my island!

 

[Mu~]

Blaire, I never read any1 talk about her, despiste being really cute.

 

[tiffanistarr]

Omg I have like a laundry list of villagers that are so overrated

Bones
Ozzie
Portia
Shari
Nana
Hornsby
Melba
Bunnie
Dobie
Ellie
Vivian
Gonzo
Rudy
Tipper
Norma
Stu
Coach
Walker
Willow

I mean the list could seriously go on and on and the list wouldn't be complete without mentioning the King and Queen themselves Jambette and Beardo

 

[DaisyFan]

My fave villager, Carmen. She is sweet, beautiful, and cheerful! I love her so much!

Other underrated villagers I really like are: Frita, Chadder, Spork, Tex, Anabelle, Cally, Walker, and list goes on and on. :')

 

[oranje]

I'd argue that every villager that isn't popular are all underrated! Most of my personal favorites aren't popular in general.

I will preach this until the day Animal Crossing is erased from existence, but...
Elmer is the sweetest little horse. The most adorable, in my opinion. I don't know why but he's my favourite villager and I'm a little surprised that he's usually thrown under the rug compared to the other horses. Give him some love people (jk, this is just topical humour and not meant to be taken seriously).

I agree about Elmer. He's cute, has a nice natural color, and he looks like Bojack Horseman, which is a plus for me.

 

[Matt0106]

I'd argue that every villager that isn't popular are all underrated! Most of my personal favorites aren't popular in general.



I agree about Elmer. He's cute, has a nice natural color, and he looks like Bojack Horseman, which is a plus for me.

View attachment 356587View attachment 356588

Yesssssss! and that signature tho!!!

 

[Nunnafinga]

Wart Jr.........the bumpiest frog in the game.

 

[Hedgehugs]

Tfw you went through the whole thread liking posts only to realize most were from June and July of last year...

I think Penelope is really underrated! Her design is really adorable, her mod haircut, one little tooth, and her giant bow ears! And a pink tail! She has the perfect look for a peppy imo c:

glad you liked my post from centeries ago because i kinda forgot this thread existed and i like people acknowledging and talking about less popular villlagers.
oh and penelope is really underrated i def agree... like how can people not love the clever but cute use of the bow omg i love it.

anyway for my opinion; to this day i'm honestly surprised how unpopular (and sometimes disliked) eugene is. like... if i didn't know anything about animal crossing i would assume he was one of the popular villagers. he's that cool.

also; him without glasses (picture not mine)

like he's such a dork without his main glasses i love it.

also graham's the same way too, but cuter...

like... LOOK AT HIM. LOOK AT HIM. HE'S PRECIOUS.

i know i'm hogging up alot of this page but danggg dude do i love alot of characters that i wish were more popular; i'll do a quick round about a bunch of the squirrels that i like which i probably did back in an earlier page but i'll do it again anyway just in case;

sally: she's soooo cute like if personality types weren't gender locked she would definitely be a lazy and i would love her even more.
cally: i love her and her biggg rosy cheeks and off-centered eyes. her catchphrase "WHEE!" always makes me imagine she's running up a tree it's as funny as it is cute. i like to imagine sally and cally as sisters but that's just my headcanon.
agent s: just a bias pick because she's blue and my favorite number is 2. but i always found females with the fitness hobby interesting because they're rare. so in short terms; she's a jock in heart, and i like jocks. probably the most jock-ish female in the game.
pecan: also bias pick because i had her in ACGC as a little kiddo. she oozes that snooty personality for me. i practically love everything about her, to the point i'm kinda surprised she isn't my favorite villager (i just love hazel too much sorry pecan). her eyes, her brownish red fur, the milkmaid dress they gave her and her Interior, which is one of my favorites and where I first heard K.K. Love Song, which is in my top 10 probably 5 songs in the game(picture not mine)

ok, sorry for the long post. i'm done now.

 

[Moritz]

glad you liked my post from centeries ago because i kinda forgot this thread existed and i like people acknowledging and talking about less popular villlagers.
oh and penelope is really underrated i def agree... like how can people not love the clever but cute use of the bow omg i love it.

anyway for my opinion; to this day i'm honestly surprised how unpopular (and sometimes disliked) eugene is. like... if i didn't know anything about animal crossing i would assume he was one of the popular villagers. he's that cool.

also; him without glasses (picture not mine)

View attachment 356604

like he's such a dork without his main glasses i love it.

also graham's the same way too, but cuter...

View attachment 356606

like... LOOK AT HIM. LOOK AT HIM. HE'S PRECIOUS.

i know i'm hogging up alot of this page but danggg dude do i love alot of characters that i wish were more popular; i'll do a quick round about a bunch of the squirrels that i like which i probably did back in an earlier page but i'll do it again anyway just in case;

sally: she's soooo cute like if personality types weren't gender locked she would definitely be a lazy and i would love her even more.
cally: i love her and her biggg rosy cheeks and off-centered eyes. her catchphrase "WHEE!" always makes me imagine she's running up a tree it's as funny as it is cute. i like to imagine sally and cally as sisters but that's just my headcanon.
agent s: just a bias pick because she's blue and my favorite number is 2. but i always found females with the fitness hobby interesting because they're rare. so in short terms; she's a jock in heart, and i like jocks. probably the most jock-ish female in the game.
pecan: also bias pick because i had her in ACGC as a little kiddo. she oozes that snooty personality for me. i practically love everything about her, to the point i'm kinda surprised she isn't my favorite villager (i just love hazel too much sorry pecan). her eyes, her brownish red fur, the milkmaid dress they gave her and her Interior, which is one of my favorites and where I first heard K.K. Love Song, which is in my top 10 probably 5 songs in the game(picture not mine)

View attachment 356610

ok, sorry for the long post. i'm done now.

Its funny you should mention Eugene and Graham as I spent a long time trying to decide what smug villager to have on my island. It was between those 2 and Hans. Hans won out.

Now it's between those 2 again for my second island. I'm thinking Eugene this time.

Maybe I should buy a third switch...

 

[moonlights]

I think a lot of the dogs are underrated - Daisy and Biskit for example.

Also I don't see much attention surrounding Dizzy and Louie, both great villagers.

 

[Hedgehugs]

Its funny you should mention Eugene and Graham as I spent a long time trying to decide what smug villager to have on my island. It was between those 2 and Hans. Hans won out.

Now it's between those 2 again for my second island. I'm thinking Eugene this time.

Maybe I should buy a third switch...

Hans is really good so I don't blame you for picking him first. Ngl kinda wish he was my first campsite villager sometimes.

I also agree with Eugune for your 2nd island. I love Graham myself and have him on my island right now but I've always wanted Eugene as a villager, even if he wouldn't be permanent because I don't have space for him, unfortunately.

Again, I love them both, so you can't go wrong either way in my opinion. If I were you though I would get both (if you have the space), or at least temporarily get both just so I could get a feel for them on my island and see which one I would want to keep.

...I probably should get a third switch too. I really want alot of villagers, I can't help it.

 

[piske]

glad you liked my post from centeries ago because i kinda forgot this thread existed and i like people acknowledging and talking about less popular villlagers.
oh and penelope is really underrated i def agree... like how can people not love the clever but cute use of the bow omg i love it.

anyway for my opinion; to this day i'm honestly surprised how unpopular (and sometimes disliked) eugene is. like... if i didn't know anything about animal crossing i would assume he was one of the popular villagers. he's that cool.

also; him without glasses (picture not mine)

View attachment 356604

like he's such a dork without his main glasses i love it.

also graham's the same way too, but cuter...

View attachment 356606

like... LOOK AT HIM. LOOK AT HIM. HE'S PRECIOUS.

i know i'm hogging up alot of this page but danggg dude do i love alot of characters that i wish were more popular; i'll do a quick round about a bunch of the squirrels that i like which i probably did back in an earlier page but i'll do it again anyway just in case;

sally: she's soooo cute like if personality types weren't gender locked she would definitely be a lazy and i would love her even more.
cally: i love her and her biggg rosy cheeks and off-centered eyes. her catchphrase "WHEE!" always makes me imagine she's running up a tree it's as funny as it is cute. i like to imagine sally and cally as sisters but that's just my headcanon.
agent s: just a bias pick because she's blue and my favorite number is 2. but i always found females with the fitness hobby interesting because they're rare. so in short terms; she's a jock in heart, and i like jocks. probably the most jock-ish female in the game.
pecan: also bias pick because i had her in ACGC as a little kiddo. she oozes that snooty personality for me. i practically love everything about her, to the point i'm kinda surprised she isn't my favorite villager (i just love hazel too much sorry pecan). her eyes, her brownish red fur, the milkmaid dress they gave her and her Interior, which is one of my favorites and where I first heard K.K. Love Song, which is in my top 10 probably 5 songs in the game(picture not mine)

View attachment 356610

ok, sorry for the long post. i'm done now.

lol centuriesssss rip

I thought of another one, Axel! I love his perpetual toothy smile, his bangs and the teal tips he has on his ears and tail c: I feel like all the other elephants get overshadowed by Dizzy!

 

[Seelie]

Agreeing with Pecan, whom I have only had for a short while and would already die for. I especially love her and Poppy hanging out together; it blows my mind that Poppy's so popular but Pecan gets overlooked!

Also I love so many of the dogs -- Butch and Shep share an orchard on Muir Wood and are just so cute together; Bea, Daisy, Maddie, Marcel, and Bones are also great!

I've never had Olive, but I think she's really sweet.

Anddd shout-out to all the jocks. I've seen so many people complaining about them but I think they're so funny with all their talk about muscles and absurd exercises (Dom isn't underrated, but he is my absolute favorite out of all the villagers). Some other jocks that deserve more attention than they get: Rudy, Genji, Bill, Drift, Poncho -- I think they're all very cute.

 

[Junebugsy94]

I love Lily she is so cute and sweet! Definitely my favourite, I'm surprised there aren't more people talking about her.

 

[nightglow]

Beardo. Give him a chance and you will miss his charm when He is gone.
I really like him. He made my past island interesting.

 

[Cristaaaaal]

I feel like I don't see her a lot, so I'm going to say Cleo. Her coloring is so pretty and horses are cool.