I got that one too and I love it! I personally think the darker shades of the airport are a lot nicer than the brighter ones so I’m fine with this one! Plus the seaplane looks great.
The red/orange was my top pick, so obviously I strongly disagree. I wish mine looked like that, but I settled for green because everything else was perfect!
I like it because it's the only color that contrasts with all surroundings (ocean=blue, beach=yellow, grass/trees=green)
I wanted blue or green but got red. I wanted pears and got those, but now I am thinking they are not colourful enough. I love the spot my house is in, but I guess if we can move the house and terraform we can make the same spot in any town. I would drop everything I have made on a friend's island and reset except I got Frita and Buck and have become attached to both of them already. I think I can live with the red airport and the idea that it looks like a barn is cute.
The pears might have been a mistake. I reset twice to get a different fruit from my best friend so we can trade. I accepted pears. I had pears as my town fruit in my first NL game until the cartridge popped out and I lost the town somewhere outside. So they had some nostalgia, too. Also I loved the golden colour of perfect pears. But if there are no perfect pears in this game maybe the pale green pears are a mistake in for me in NH.
I don't have a red one myself, but have seen pictures of it. I don't think it looks like a barn. If it bothers you, sure. Reset. But don't reset just because your friends are saying stuff. Ignore them!