Mafia Overwatch Mafia - End Game, Town wins!

[Dolby]

i shall come out and say that
my role is also green in my pm/role pm picture thing but in a regular game it would be blue

Welp.

This is a poor play, but it further solidified my townlean on you

 

[KermitTea]

so uh based on that i'm going to let endless go for now
and still in class so ill write up something better in a little bit but i think good points have been made against tom

 

[Endless]

Dolby post? What Dolby post? You slipped. Hint: the text in towns role PMs isn't "hostile third parties".

 

[N e s s]

I'd say theres definitely TownVsMafia between Endless and Tom.

Anyway, I'm voting Tom. I'll put my reads list up in about 10 minutes.

 

[KermitTea]

Welp.

This is a poor play, but it further solidified my townlean on you

it may be or it may not be but i figured it'd be best for me to do it

 

[glow]

can u guys be more conscious of what you're saying about your roles and how it implies whether or not you are VT because that's annoying me

 

[Trent the Paladin]

Dolby post? What Dolby post? You slipped. Hint: the text in towns role PMs isn't "hostile third parties".

No, no it's not which is why I wouldn't mention it. What mafia game have you ever played where town's wincon is to not kill the mafia/opfor? Probably zero. I was focusing in on White's constant vigilante crap, because frankly I don't understand how someone could read a role PM and not connect the dots.

 

[glow]

also i hate that abe is calling that a slip when it's not

 

[Trent the Paladin]

I'd like some discussion to be directed towards Dolby. I don't have time to do it myself, (30 minutes left to get ready for uni, including shower time and preparing lunch) but I destinctly remember him slightly misconstruing points w/r/t Ness. I brushed over it at the time, but the more I think about it the more it irks me.

btdubs forgetful abby

 

[glow]

it's not a slip because the word third is usually included so unless you're sitting there memorizing your role PM it's a pretty normal thing to just automatically include the word

 

[Endless]

No, no it's not which is why I wouldn't mention it. What mafia game have you ever played where town's wincon is to not kill the mafia/opfor? Probably zero. I was focusing in on White's constant vigilante crap, because frankly I don't understand how someone could read a role PM and not connect the dots.

See, in general, I don't post memes, since they detract from discussion. But this is an exception.

Tom right now:

- - - Post Merge - - -

it's not a slip because the word third is usually included so unless you're sitting there memorizing your role PM it's a pretty normal thing to just automatically include the word

In our role pm, hostile parties involve mafia and third parties. However, the only hostile party for mafia is a third party. Hence, it's reasonable to expect that Tom's role pm reads "to outnumber town and all hostile third parties"

Additionally, it could just be a lapse of thought, if he weren't using it as a reason to push on white.

 

[Trent the Paladin]

Well I hope that somebody has their sights set on you Abe. Bouncing off Ness because you supposedly read the Mafia scum games, then throwing suspicion to Dolby but then voting myself to save your fakeclaiming ass? Ok.

 

[EpicGamer12]

I'm heading out to play Pathfinder so I am done my posts for D1. I will pop on quickly at day's end though in 2 hours.

 

[glow]

Well I hope that somebody has their sights set on you Abe. Bouncing off Ness because you supposedly read the Mafia scum games, then throwing suspicion to Dolby but then voting myself to save your fakeclaiming ass? Ok.

BEST POST IN THREAD WHY AREN'T THERE MORE OW PUNS

 

[Endless]

For clarity, here's the post by Dolby.

Anybody else find this extremely ironic? It was very clear that Toadsworthy was questioning your response to Endless, and frankly, that does seem a little bit oppertunistic of him, but you just blew it up and changed your vote to him on pretty much no logic, when he didn't even say he had a suspicion on you. You pretty much announced that you were sus of him because he was questioning you

In short, I find Ness scummy

Anyway, this is probably my last post today, got homework to do

In response to:

You took something perfectly townish and twisted it to make it seem scummy. The manner in which you said that post by asking me "got you metaphors mixed up? You nervous bro?" makes it look opportunistic as hell.

It seems like he's sweeping it under the carpet by not giving any supporting text. I surely could have used a better metaphor, but the way you approached the post sticks out like a sore thumb.

The dissidence between "that was opportunistic" and "pretty much no logic" still irks me. Nothing remotely as concrete as Tom though.

 

[KermitTea]

given that we'43 running out of time and I just got out of school with things to do

I honk tom is one of the safer people to lynch atm bcuz of his inactive ish posting activity
but I am slightly hesitating bcuz of the list that he posted earlier about possible role names
i know for a fact that it's inaccurate bcuz of what I have, but how much it's inaccurate idk
so I wonder, does the inaccuracy come from him trying to cover up his mafia roles or actual ignorance of red roles bcuz he's town!

idk if this even makes sense but I'm just typing whatever comes to mind
another two suspects are Jacob who I think posted a little and also get lucky who fell off the radar

- - - Post Merge - - -

oh my god all those typing errors I cry
anyways the sole reason I'm laying off ness for now is bcuz of the details which I can confirm

- - - Post Merge - - -

Wait not ness, i meant endless

- - - Post Merge - - -

so if anyone could offer more thoughts on the people I mentioned I'll check in an hour ish hopefully to vote

 

[glow]

See, in general, I don't post memes, since they detract from discussion. But this is an exception.

Tom right now:

- - - Post Merge - - -



In our role pm, hostile parties involve mafia and third parties. However, the only hostile party for mafia is a third party. Hence, it's reasonable to expect that Tom's role pm reads "to outnumber town and all hostile third parties"

Additionally, it could just be a lapse of thought, if he weren't using it as a reason to push on white.

but i feel like i totally would have done the same thing because most role pms do include the word third. it feels like you're nitpicking. and also why would maf role pms even include the word third but town role pms not? normally the phrasing is all exactly the same apart from your role desc.

 

[Endless]

Glow, I literally just said why. Honestly at this point I'd be absolutely shell-shocked if Tom flipped anything other than mafia.

 

[glow]

i reallly really want to make a white case but i have about four weeks of math hw + an exam all due by midnight (upside-down smiley emoji)

i don't feel comfortable voting tom. i can usually read him decently enough and i don't think he slipped and i don't think really see a consistency with his scum meta here

let me b ur shephard

- - - Post Merge - - -

Glow, I literally just said why. Honestly at this point I'd be absolutely shell-shocked if Tom flipped anything other than mafia.

yeah i get that, i just don't agree lol

 

[Endless]

And I severely doubt you'd attempt to get someone lynched by mentioning that your role pm (and consequently theirs, if they're town) specifically mentioned something without double checking