Mafia Overwatch Mafia - End Game, Town wins!

[glow]

sheep me

 

[Trent the Paladin]

So you think that you only think Endless is scummy based off his claim?

His claim really just nailed my suspicion.

 

[N e s s]

His claim really just nailed my suspicion.

Yet you still haven't told me any other reasoning as to why you think he's scum.

 

[Endless]

His claim really just nailed my suspicion.

Huh?

What?

Excuse me?

This needs to be addressed and explained in depth.

 

[N e s s]

Huh?

What?

Excuse me?

This needs to be addressed and explained in depth.

This smug uplift in tone feels off. Still want more from Tom, but I don't like this post.

 

[Endless]

This smug uplift in tone feels off. Still want more from Tom, but I don't like this post.

There's no smug uplift here. I'm just floored and liable to vote Tom if his next post explaining his reasoning even vaguely resembles what I expect it to.

 

[KermitTea]

hi so a lot has happened
can someone explain the busdriver role that endless claimed given that his role is green not blue
ie. what does a green busdriver do?

and meanwhile i am still reading but i do have some thoughts regarding his claim in relation to tom's post on likely and unlikely names

 

[Trent the Paladin]

I have watched many mafia games before, Tom is playing in a reserved manner, he doesn't really go into depth about his points (I don't either but that isn't the point), the lack of participation seems like a defense mechanism against exposure.

If you've watched me play before then I question why you're so suspicious of me on Day 1. If I'm mafia I usually implode from smugness and superiority and I get lynched rightfully so. But really if you've watched many mafia games before plus actually read your role PM then why:

So third party is the correct term? I got mixed up then.
On the wikia it said vigilantes are pro-town but I've seen and heard people say otherwise so that's why I got confused.

Did you keep saying vigilantes? Surely if you read your PM fully, it would have specifically mentioned hostile third parties and then from previous games you would have seen the same specific terminology?

@ Glow
I'm nothing more than a newbie, don't worry Trundle's right. =)
I don't get why you think I'm something to worry about because I'm the worst player here, easily.

I'm voting Tom, btw. He's my most comfortable choice by far as everybody else can be proven to be a different role later on, I'm certain Tom is this role.

What role is that mind you? Also I find your word choice here kinda weird, how can everyone else be proven later on? Especially if they're townies and it's rather easy to fake a claim?

Also his denial/ questioning of a third party makes me think he might be in a third party tbh.

Whoo day one speculation, stating that I don't feel like there's a hostile third party! I don't believe there's one at the moment because why? The game would be deliberately setup to end relatively fast then.

 

[amanda1983]

sheep me

Why White over Tom at this stage? I think both are better targets than Endless currently, but there's more question marks over Tom than White for me right now.

 

[N e s s]

There's no smug uplift here. I'm just floored and liable to vote Tom if his next post explaining his reasoning even vaguely resembles what I expect it to.

What happened to you thinking Dolby was scum? You said wanted more discussion about him, and you still haven't given me what I asked for: why you think he's suspicious due to him questioning my posts.

- - - Post Merge - - -

There's no smug uplift here. I'm just floored and liable to vote Tom if his next post explaining his reasoning even vaguely resembles what I expect it to.

What happened to you thinking Dolby was scum? You said wanted more discussion about him, and you still haven't given me what I asked for: why you think he's suspicious due to him questioning my posts.

 

[KermitTea]

fyi i have also heard of vigilantes == pro-town shooters (i forgot what people call that role on here lol) so i don't really hold that against flamingo, nor does it really cement him as townleaning or scumleaning for me

 

[Endless]

But really if you've watched many mafia games before plus actually read your role PM then why:

Did you keep saying vigilantes? Surely if you read your PM fully, it would have specifically mentioned hostile third parties and then from previous games you would have seen the same specific terminology?

Nhie seen a mafia player slip harder. Take a gander at your role pm then vote.

 

[EpicGamer12]

Do you guys think that the Endless's detail about the green appearance of the claim is legitimate? Sometimes extreme details such as those are evident of a well formed lie, showing a lot of thought was put into it. Although I'm sure other blues in the game could be quick to call it out if their roles were listed as green as well.

 

[KermitTea]

OH CRAP

 

[Dolby]

Do you guys think that the Endless's detail about the green appearance of the claim is legitimate? Sometimes extreme details such as those are evident of a well formed lie, showing a lot of thought was put into it. Although I'm sure other blues in the game could be quick to call it out if their roles were listed as green as well.

Honestly, I think a real blue would have called him out on that if he was lying. He still could be lying sure, but as maf, why would he think that?

 

[EpicGamer12]

Nhie seen a mafia player slip harder. Take a gander at your role pm then vote.

o boy u r right this could be big slip (or forgetful mistake, but \o/ )

 

[Endless]

Apparently I was late on the calling-out-tom train, everyone else is already on him. Oh well.

 

[Dolby]

Honestly, I'm probably not going to bring in my meta on Tom, since that'd take work which would be better used analyzing others

 

[KermitTea]

i shall come out and say that
my role is also green in my pm/role pm picture thing but in a regular game it would be blue

 

[Trent the Paladin]

Nhie seen a mafia player slip harder. Take a gander at your role pm then vote.

lol ok. Where's the Dolby post since Uni clearly isn't something you're needing to focus on right now?