Mafia Overwatch Mafia - End Game, Town wins!

[glow]

Since this Trainwreck to hell seems to not look like it has any outlet other than staying on me, I'm Symmetry, town busdriver.
I'm aware that Tom said symmetra was likely not a town role, but that's not something I can absolve. Either I was given symmetra as my role as town, or I was given symmetra as a fake claim, so that shouldn't be read into. Regardless, given how easily proven my claim is, lynching me would be nothing short of madness.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Symmetra. Thanks autocorrect.

i just realized how disturbed i am that you felt the need to mention that you could prove your claim

if u were maf claiming driver u are obviously an ACTUAL driver (or one exists) so i mean that wouldn't make u town

regardless we still don't lynch the pr claim and anyone that keeps pushing on it is scum

 

[Jacob]

I don't think I believe endless. He's spent his last 7 posts not naming anyone scum besides a weak one on Dolby, in which he says nothing of substance besides "it irked me".

Also, reads list is almost done.

- - - Post Merge - - -

And don't you straw man me by saying you need to get ready for university. Give us some reason why you think Dolby's thoughts on my posts are suspicious.

You can't hold it against someone to have a scum tell day one realistically. Day 1 on tbt usually ends on a guess or meme lynch anyway so Abe isn't doing anything sus by not drilling someone yet.

Going with Tom today.

 

[toadsworthy]

regardless though, he is right... I don't feel comfortable lynching him when it can be so easily proven over night

or by a counter claim... I don't think I would want someone to counter claim this early though

 

[N e s s]

regardless though, he is right... I don't feel comfortable lynching him when it can be so easily proven over night

lol, you can't prove him based off his role. Unless the person bussed is told "You were bussed last night!" then I highly doubt it. He could easily say that he "switch bob with vanessa" and you wouldn't know the difference.

Unless that is a possibility. Endless, do you know if people are told if you used your "action" on them?

 

[EpicGamer12]

Since this Trainwreck to hell seems to not look like it has any outlet other than staying on me, I'm Symmetry, town busdriver.
I'm aware that Tom said symmetra was likely not a town role, but that's not something I can absolve. Either I was given symmetra as my role as town, or I was given symmetra as a fake claim, so that shouldn't be read into. Regardless, given how easily proven my claim is, lynching me would be nothing short of madness.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Symmetra. Thanks autocorrect.

Are you green or blue? Do you have an action?

 

[Endless]

I'm not strawmanning you, Ness. I clearly stated in my response to the RQS that I have much less time this game than I have historically.
I'm not told in my role pm whether or not my targets are informed.

Glow, that thought crossed my mind, but aren't drivers almost always town on this site? My memory could be erring here, if it is, *shrugs* lynching me is still a poor decision.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Are you green or blue? Do you have an action?

I'm technically a blue role. My role pm was, however, green.

 

[EpicGamer12]

I'm going to buy it unless we see a counter claim. Switching my vote to Jacob, who has at least been here to defend himself but is just bandwagoning on an AFK. Common Jacob scum play.

 

[toadsworthy]

Tom you better be posting something big!

 

[moonford]

@ Glow
I'm nothing more than a newbie, don't worry Trundle's right. =)
I don't get why you think I'm something to worry about because I'm the worst player here, easily.

I'm voting Tom, btw. He's my most comfortable choice by far as everybody else can be proven to be a different role later on, I'm certain Tom is this role.

 

[Jacob]

I'm going to buy it unless we see a counter claim. Switching my vote to Jacob, who has at least been here to defend himself but is just bandwagoning on an AFK. Common Jacob scum play.

Not sure how you mean by bandwagoning, I provided my reasoning:

Tom

Tom only has about 5 or 6 actual posts. Usually Tom is one of the hardest players to read, as his activity rates generally show nothing about his alignment.
But, two of his posts stuck out to me:


"based off numbers" as an explanation for his inconfidence in a third party shows me that he's very analytical. A third party is totally possible in a 15 person game, and I've seen games with less players and still a third party. I came to a slight conclusion that Tom is likely on the Mafia team, he knows how many mafia members there are and thinks that having a third party out there as well would throw off the balance in the game. He didn't give much explanation otherwise.

 

[toadsworthy]

@ Glow
I'm nothing more than a newbie, don't worry Trundle's right. =)
I don't get why you think I'm something to worry about because I'm the worst player here, easily.

I'm voting Tom, btw. He's my most comfortable choice by far as everybody else can be proven to be a different role later on, I'm certain Tom is this role.

you've been saying a lot of like "X defended Y" or "X sounds like they are trying to blend in" and basing things on it, but you havent played any mafia before right? how also then are you so certain?

 

[Trent the Paladin]

regardless though, he is right... I don't feel comfortable lynching him when it can be so easily proven over night

Bus Driver is a role you can easily lie about, especially if the users swapped aren't notified at all. You're literally gambling extra KP over something that cannot be proven.

Tom you better be posting something big!

lol

Heyden: "Tom sus, he was pretty quick to sort of push the attention on Ness. I say that because it was more indirect and immediately implied that a jester was unlikely, making Ness more sus."

Unless I'm concrete pointing the finger at someone, I was not proding Nester as scum. Are jokes hard?

@jacob: I don't have confidence in a third party, which why I stated as why. Meta gaming the roles based off alignments from Overwatch lore tells me there's likely three mafioso. That puts KP at two and then I'm not sure what exact role Curry would throw in for chaos. Until we see night deaths, I find it hard to believe there's a third party at the moment.

As for my absense, I've been mostly keeping up but really I don't have anything worth contributing right now. If I was online at all today it was from my tablet refreshing my browser or doing mod things. I just suggest not lynching me, but I don't have anything to convince you otherwise and I'm not going to claim.

 

[Trent the Paladin]

regardless though, he is right... I don't feel comfortable lynching him when it can be so easily proven over night

Bus Driver is a role you can easily lie about, especially if the users swapped aren't notified at all. You're literally gambling extra KP over something that cannot be proven.

Tom you better be posting something big!

lol

Heyden: "Tom sus, he was pretty quick to sort of push the attention on Ness. I say that because it was more indirect and immediately implied that a jester was unlikely, making Ness more sus."

Unless I'm concrete pointing the finger at someone, I was not proding Nester as scum. Are jokes hard?

@jacob: I don't have confidence in a third party, which why I stated as why. Meta gaming the roles based off alignments from Overwatch lore tells me there's likely three mafioso. That puts KP at two and then I'm not sure what exact role Curry would throw in for chaos. Until we see night deaths, I find it hard to believe there's a third party at the moment.

As for my absense, I've been mostly keeping up but really I don't have anything worth contributing right now. If I was online at all today it was from my tablet refreshing my browser or doing mod things. I just suggest not lynching me, but I don't have anything to convince you otherwise and I'm not going to claim.

 

[moonford]

you've been saying a lot of like "X defended Y" or "X sounds like they are trying to blend in" and basing things on it, but you havent played any mafia before right? how also then are you so certain?

I have watched many mafia games before, Tom is playing in a reserved manner, he doesn't really go into depth about his points (I don't either but that isn't the point), the lack of participation seems like a defense mechanism against exposure. All he's done is list which characters fit each role and that's about it. Not really aggressive or trying to do anything really.

 

[Dolby]

Alright then Tom

1. Why the **** do you think that Endless is scum
2. Moreover, why do you think that mafia would risk KP at this stage in the game on a claim like that
3. Why are you even less active than in the thread than even the discord game?
4. Why do you consider analyzing character alignments a higher priority than player alignments?

 

[N e s s]

I know I saw you looking at the thread Tom. Do you have any scum reads? What are your thoughts on Endless?

Also, what do you mean you were joking about me being Jester? You said that "its almost like you're trying to get lynched" so that tells me that you thought I was scummy in some way. Am I wrong on this?

 

[moonford]

I have watched many mafia games before, Tom is playing in a reserved manner, he doesn't really go into depth about his points (I don't either but that isn't the point), the lack of participation seems like a defense mechanism against exposure. All he's done is list which characters fit each role and that's about it. Not really aggressive or trying to do anything really.

Also his denial/ questioning of a third party makes me think he might be in a third party tbh.

 

[Trent the Paladin]

Alright then Tom

1. Why the **** do you think that Endless is scum
2. Moreover, why do you think that mafia would risk KP at this stage in the game on a claim like that
3. Why are you even less active than in the thread than even the discord game?
4. Why do you consider analyzing character alignments a higher priority than player alignments?

1. I don't buy his claim and that's playing meta based off role names
2. Because you guys will test it while they kill
3. I haven't felt a real need to say anything
4. If I wanted to meta game I'd ask that we all mass name claim and then Lynch from there.

I know I saw you looking at the thread Tom. Do you have any scum reads? What are your thoughts on Endless?

Also, what do you mean you were joking about me being Jester? You said that "its almost like you're trying to get lynched" so that tells me that you thought I was scummy in some way. Am I wrong on this?

I thought you being stupid, so I called you out on it. I don't trust Endless.

 

[Trent the Paladin]

*that's not playing meta based off role names

 

[N e s s]

So you think that you only think Endless is scummy based off his claim?