EpicGamer12
Senior Member
wow dat bandwagon logic though
Mafia Papers Please Mafia: Game Over, Town Wins!
- Thread starter Dolby
- Start date
wow dat bandwagon logic though
EnderWiggin
Senior Member
Okay I'm going to put this out there.
I don't want to lynch SarasaKat.
I stated in my first post that I had them leaning town, and so far they haven't given me a real reason to change that read. (Also what's with the weak ass pushes on them. Trundle's post was weaksauce and Minties case comes down to "She was trying to rile me up". If I'm wrong on the Minties case please correct me, but that's all I see.)
I haven't looked at Panda really. I've let them fly under my radar a lot so I'm going to do that quickly and see if I want to join the wagon there.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Oh wait Ayaya made a Kat case? I didn't see it on my quick read through. OTL Waking up is hard help.
- - - Post Merge - - -
ALSO THIS POST SCREAMS OFF TO ME.
I don't want to lynch SarasaKat.
I stated in my first post that I had them leaning town, and so far they haven't given me a real reason to change that read. (Also what's with the weak ass pushes on them. Trundle's post was weaksauce and Minties case comes down to "She was trying to rile me up". If I'm wrong on the Minties case please correct me, but that's all I see.)
I haven't looked at Panda really. I've let them fly under my radar a lot so I'm going to do that quickly and see if I want to join the wagon there.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Oh wait Ayaya made a Kat case? I didn't see it on my quick read through. OTL Waking up is hard help.
- - - Post Merge - - -
ALSO THIS POST SCREAMS OFF TO ME.
ty ty great maf player 10/10 logic i know
but I personally was hoping for a reaction out of that
Arstotzkan
A scum mom
Mind explaining why I "could be scum" more than other candidates?
@Ayaya
Oh you did? Were you asking about anyone in particular, or about everyone? Because I plan on typing up a reads post real quick as one of my last posts if I'm indeed getting lynched today.
Minties I think should be pretty obvious. They seem way too opposed to pressure and half of their points weren't even valid, as I've replied to in my reply to Minties last wall.
I feel like Jacob's mainly floating around and not ever committing to anything or any viewpoint, which makes me feel like he could just be floating by trying to not get anyone on his bad side.
EnderWiggin
Senior Member
I just realised I don't think I've ever seen Panda roll scum yet. Random side note while I ISO
Gut feelings. I've been choosing between you, panda, and minties for a while and you seem the most likely in my opinion.
I probably look really ****ty when i'm typing this, but i have nothing else thats pinging me right now.
PandaDarling
Purple People Eater
@Ender I've never been scum, kinda scared to think when that day comes how ill deal with the pressure.
Arstotzkan
A scum mom
This is so frustrating - I'm trying to be accomedating but all of these cases are like "lol 'chaos'." Idk what kind of chat you're in Ness but you're either being led around by your neck to do that person's bidding or you're scum yourself - that was a really ****ing shady post and I know you can do better than that.
EnderWiggin
Senior Member
No thought on Dough?
I've kinda been ignoring the Dough thing too. Aaaah I've been lazy oops;;
- - - Post Merge - - -
Or you could be scum right now?
Theres something on dough?
I'm maybe slightly kinda thinking unvoting Kat since i literally don't have any clue towards a scum besides the 3 that I mentioned, i'm sorry if this upsets you Kat.
PandaDarling
Purple People Eater
@Ness who are you in another chat with ?
- - - Post Merge - - -
haha if i was, which im not, id be pretty proud of myself... im really trying to be helpful this time guys.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Or you could be scum right now?
haha if i was, which im not, id be pretty proud of myself... im really trying to be helpful this time guys.
EnderWiggin
Senior Member
Okay, so, I think Panda might actually be scum? They're playing similar to a few games in memory, all of which they were town, but I've yet to see them scum yet so idk how that plays up.
The reason I think they might be scum? Actually comes from the fact that they started PMing me in a manner very similar to the first PM game we played together. It feels a lot like "Oh hey look, remember how I was town in this?"
To be honest I think I'd prefer a Ness lynch because of that shady af post just now, but if it's between Panda and Sarasa I would prefer Panda. (I'll reread over Dough now and see what I think of them and where they rank in "Who I want to lynch rn")
The reason I think they might be scum? Actually comes from the fact that they started PMing me in a manner very similar to the first PM game we played together. It feels a lot like "Oh hey look, remember how I was town in this?"
To be honest I think I'd prefer a Ness lynch because of that shady af post just now, but if it's between Panda and Sarasa I would prefer Panda. (I'll reread over Dough now and see what I think of them and where they rank in "Who I want to lynch rn")
Okay, I'll correct you then. They've spent pretty much the entire game trying to say that my posts are out of context or picking and choosing text to cite my suspicions on. They're trying to create a scene by screeching that I'm not making any cases and always essentially saying "OH YEAH? PROVE IT!" Considering this is Day One, that's a pretty god damn stupid thing to say since there has hardly been any posts with much substance. To be honest, it's bloody exhausting to have to repeat myself over and over. If they're scum and have a veteran player on their team, then they would know how I would respond and they would know it would quickly derail the thread. Literally 10 ish pages of this crap has bogged down the thread. I don't see them as a good player, more like an annoying little pest that thinks they're MAFIAMLG and keeps spouting off the same sentences over and over trying to prove something. That's completely unproductive and exactly what scum would want so they could hide among it imo.
I would like to hold my Jacob suspicion off for now due to him actually speaking. I need more time to go into his posts before I make a decision. The other player I was considering voting for today was Panda because I feel like they've been very wishy washy with posting, mostly just piggy backing off of what I said. Panda is usually pretty aggressive as town, posting often trying to scum hunt. They just feel very quiet this game and like they're going along with the tide without rustling any feathers.
Arstotzkan
A scum mom
Alright, what're the pros/cons of the 3 you mentioned then?
Panda, what're your thoughts regarding my lynch? You've been keeping a pretty Switzerland stance.
EnderWiggin
Senior Member
Thanks for the post clarifying.
Sorry, I'm still not entirely awake. Terrible sleep schedule is my bane.
Hmm. You're starting to make me rethink my townread on Sarasa, because you are right about the whole derailed arguing. ><
No thought on Dough? Or Ness?
- - - Post Merge - - -
His whole role-fish thing with the newbie?
Arstotzkan
A scum mom
@Minties No? There were new points brought up each time, and we went back and forth until now you're outright refusing to reply to my last post. Tbh I just don't think you're used to being questioned since you seem to like being on a high horse in these games.
EnderWiggin
Senior Member
Eeeh. I don't have a solid read on Dough even after rereading. Their panic seems really weird for a scum to do in thread, but their rolefishing is hella bad.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Tbh I just really want Ness. :/
- - - Post Merge - - -
Tbh I just really want Ness. :/
PandaDarling
Purple People Eater
@Ender how can you say she is acting as she normally does and she's town all the time so she's probably scum? that doesn't make sense also yes i sent you a PM all it said was "hey whats going on" i had reasons to do so and i will disclose at a later time and you were mafia that game remember.
@Sarasakat im not really happy with a lynch on you for D1, thats why i didnt vote for you.
EnderWiggin
Senior Member
Their last two posts have been hella off, especially when it's like "I was talking with someone and now I'm set in my way" and then when people poke at him suddenly "I'm thinking of unvoting.
Arstotzkan
A scum mom
Throwing down a vote on Minties because aforementioned reasons, might switch to Panda if it seems more viable.
Gonna start putting down a reads post, but for now here, take my watch. I demand you give it back to me once my reads are done
- - - Post Merge - - -
Eugh damn I like that last post though. Nvm
Gonna start putting down a reads post, but for now here, take my watch. I demand you give it back to me once my reads are done
- - - Post Merge - - -
Eugh damn I like that last post though. Nvm
