Mafia PokéMafia : a small game of mafia - Town Wins

[Biancasbotique]

Have we heard from jtheburger yet? and dragonboy just came here to say he is in england again.

and I think Zelda is stepping up , in terms of saying something about the game than be quiet. She doesn't want to be lynched and as newbie, I know when I was one, my biggest fear was being lynched.

Zelda, don't trust one's talkativeness to being town. it could either be town contributing or mafia trying to blend in..

 

[StrayBluet]

So, if you had to vote right now, who would it be for considering it seems that you want to go for the less active players? Why have you been silent for the past I don't know how many hours despite Dad's and myself's votes on you?

Well Dragon has posted twice so far but they've only been about him living in England and J hasn't posted at all. I feel less suspicious of Dragon but I don't know why, I guess it just seems like he doesn't really have anything to add yet but he still wants to post something to avoid being killed. I think I'll go with J.

Also, I haven't posted anything regarding being voted against by you or Dad because I don't really have evidence that I'm not mafia yet, I just know I'm not. There's also slim chances of having a good enough defense to get out of being lynched if you were voted for.

(I've been playing a Town of Salem online game to learn about it, if people vote on you for being lynched, can you give a defense and then everyone else votes if you're guilty or innocent or is it just, people vote for you then you're dead?

 

[Dolby]

(I've been playing a Town of Salem online game to learn about it, if people vote on you for being lynched, can you give a defense and then everyone else votes if you're guilty or innocent or is it just, people vote for you then you're dead?

That's not the case here lol. If you get the most votes you're just straight up lynched

 

[Hyrule_Crossing]

if people vote on you for being lynched, can you give a defense and then everyone else votes if you're guilty or innocent or is it just, people vote for you then you're dead?

Asking a question is for green test, blue is only for the host

 

[StrayBluet]

Oh, that's great.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Asking a question is for green test, blue is only for the host

oh whoops, should I just leave it or could I edit it just to change the color?

 

[Dolby]

I don't really have the effort to go into, but right now the only people I feel are particularly compatible with Zelda are Hyrule and Bianca, whom I both townread. I don't find the responses particularly telling, but jt isn't compatible, and I want to say that I don't think that dragon votes zelda here as m/m without explanation

Gonna unvote this

- - - Post Merge - - -

The fact that no specific counter has been brought up makes me think that if Zelda does happen to be scum Antonio's the slot that's most likely teammed

- - - Post Merge - - -

Well, I?m not 100% sure, but.

1: ZeldaJune (mostly cause I haven?t seen any posts in a few pages)
2: jtheburger
3: dragonboy
4: im_the_rhino
5: Bianca
6: Dad
7: Dolby

I might change later, this is partly based on amount of posts, and what is being talked about In said posts.

Dad and Dolby are at the elast suspicion cause their posts seem to be really researched. (Again I?m a newbie so I don?t know what I?m talking about for half of this XD)

All the last four hadn't posted in a few pages, what made zelda different at the time of this

 

[StrayBluet]

I just finally found something to post about, at first I didn't trust or suspect anyone but I read everyone's posts and thought about it and I know I can't just not post anything throughout too long of a period of time.

 

[toadsworthy]

Well Dragon has posted twice so far but they've only been about him living in England and J hasn't posted at all. I feel less suspicious of Dragon but I don't know why, I guess it just seems like he doesn't really have anything to add yet but he still wants to post something to avoid being killed. I think I'll go with J.

Also, I haven't posted anything regarding being voted against by you or Dad because I don't really have evidence that I'm not mafia yet, I just know I'm not. There's also slim chances of having a good enough defense to get out of being lynched if you were voted for.

(I've been playing a Town of Salem online game to learn about it, if people vote on you for being lynched, can you give a defense and then everyone else votes if you're guilty or innocent or is it just, people vote for you then you're dead?

What dolby said, i am aware they do that in irl mafia but not here

- - - Post Merge - - -

Heyden will be replacing for Antonio, effective immediately

- - - Post Merge - - -

Voted roles have now been applied to the respective player.

Just so you know I RNGed who got what. 2 numbers 1-7 for town ones, and 1 number 1-2 for mafia using the roster on page 1 of this.

 

[PunchyTheCat]

@Toads can I be reps please thanks.

 

[Dolby]

Finally ****ing free

Alright so rn I'm really having a hard time distinguishing between rhino, dragon, and jt. All have barely posted, most have bwed. I'll actually say that I don't think that JT is actually avoiding contributing rn since he's hasn't been online since early yesterday.

Still feel good about Bianca and Hyrule (though I'm gonna have to re-ev if Zelda is lynched and flips red today). Less good on Dad but less then the other two

I did end up with Zelda as my number 2 pick for scum earlier, and having to drop JT because of lack of avoidence of the thread thus far, but I'm seriously considering her as town now due to not having good teams. Dad's hard going after her and I don't think that he goes in with the intent to solo this game. Bianca has casually defended her and Hyrule has been pretty non-committal in a strange way towards her (saying that she feels worst about Zelda but not voting), but I TR the two of them. I don't think that Rhino is a good teammate as his vote was effectively a cement vote given that Zelda has one effective vote on her at the time. Heyden hasn't posted yet, but Antonio's absence would be a potential explanation as to why there's no real resistance to this besides me. Dragon's voting her, and she's proposing JT as the alternative. At the end of the day she has so many solid anti-aligns that it makes me doubt that this is scum (well, except Antonio/Heyden)

Jt has just been absent. Rhino has at the very least been here at times. Dragon's only posts are that "hey I live in England guys" and is kinda a red flag since he's just establishing a thread presence but hasn't done anything. JT hasn't tried to do that (at least yet)

 

[Heyden]

hi

 

[Heyden]

First of all, why tf did you guys pick COP opposed to something actually important like a roleblocker or doctor. Watcher is objectively better imo so that’s good at least. But putting godfather in the game just made this a lot more difficult imo.

As for voting I leave in 20 mins and haven’t really read the thread but anyone who’s not participating I’m down to vote for, aka dragon or j, cos I don’t see the benefit in keeping them around if they’re gonna do nothing all game

 

[Dolby]

This is playing right into my tinfoil on why there was no resistance to Zelda (Zelda/Antonio). Especially the fact Dragon was voted over JT, as my vote is on Dragon. Pretty sure that if Zelda changes to Dragon who’s being lynched want change so I’m ok leaving my vote where it is now for now

- - - Post Merge - - -

Doctor and rber are both objectively worse than cop here

- - - Post Merge - - -

Doctor and rber are both objectively worse than cop here

- - - Post Merge - - -

Yeah, actually that pings in such a way that that I’ll change. You didn’t look into the lead wagon

- - - Post Merge - - -

??

 

[StrayBluet]

Man, I'm gonna be lynched on day one, aren't I

 

[Geoni]

I'm caught up after skimming the last few posts and feeling like Zelda is a shot in the dark which I hate.

Dolby you didn't respond to a lot of my points which I can read as Dodge at EoD as much as we both know walls aren't helping rest of town. Also you did say Zelda was disinterested townie.

Heyden at least skim.

Zelda why were you lurking?

 

[Dolby]

I'm caught up after skimming the last few posts and feeling like Zelda is a shot in the dark which I hate.

Dolby you didn't respond to a lot of my points which I can read as Dodge at EoD as much as we both know walls aren't helping rest of town. Also you did say Zelda was disinterested townie.

Heyden at least skim.

Zelda why were you lurking?

That’s not EoD dodge, I just don’t feel a need to respond to much of it

I said “uncaring townie vs frozen fear” scum

In calc rn

 

[StrayBluet]

you mean rn Dad? I'm not really meaning to, I'm watching YouTube videos and every so often, I'll check and forget to go back to the Cellar

 

[Geoni]

I mean on and off this entire game after you made your first post in the thread justifying your cop/watcher vote.

 

[Dolby]

I mean on and off this entire game after you made your first post in the thread justifying your cop/watcher vote.

Why did you just vote NL

 

[Geoni]

I hate doing this but the shot in the dark feels likely to miss. Lets NO LYNCH and only lose one townie by day 2 and not 1.

I'd like to lynch Dolby with the information I have but nobody is even reading or responding to the reads I have made about him and just take his volume at face value so I don't think I can Chinese Fire Drill him in 15 minutes.