Mafia PunchyDaHufflepuff Mafia 3: Return of the Punch - Dethy

[Geoni]

My question was asked of everyone but when I asked it I was pretty straightforward that I was pointing it in your direction. My point with it was that the choice seemed off to me given how Phil was posting on night 0 and I didn't like the tone you had when you presented your first inspection and usually I find tonereads hard to explain but I think now that there has been a shift in tone on D2 you were coming off as passive. I feel like with such an unexpected target for inspection you would have also interacted with him more than you did if your reason for inspecting was because you didn't know him well.

 

[cornimer]

My question was asked of everyone but when I asked it I was pretty straightforward that I was pointing it in your direction.

I did answer your question as soon as I saw it, I wasn't trying to avoid anything I was just offline

And again, I wasn't very active on D1/N1, which is why I didn't talk to Phil. He was killed off before I became active.

 

[Geoni]

In other words if you posted a passive semi-solvey inspection result post with a copied scratch off list but didn't put forth solving efforts elsewhere I find the answer for why you inspected Phil to be arbitrary.

 

[Dolby]

I did answer your question as soon as I saw it, I wasn't trying to avoid anything I was just offline

And again, I wasn't very active on D1/N1, which is why I didn't talk to Phil. He was killed off before I became active.

Who did you sus more before D2? Dad or Philemon?

I do have to agree with Dad that I expect you to have interacted with Philemon because you were pretty hard on me in lovers when I voted you and Phil was the only one to vote you yesterday

 

[Geoni]

And again, I wasn't very active on D1/N1, which is why I didn't talk to Phil. He was killed off before I became active.

You could have aired a thought on him when you posted the result. That's why flags were set off: if you were town and were trying to figure him out as a player then you would follow up inspection with interaction because you can't develop certainty from a result that only has a 1/4 chance of being sane.

Acting uninformed now is how you can appeal to a cleared leader who worried you couldn't have had the forethought to kill Phil when you've clearly been considering his place in this game from at least the end of night 0.

 

[cornimer]

You could have aired a thought on him when you posted the result. That's why flags were set off: if you were town and were trying to figure him out as a player then you would follow up inspection with interaction because you can't develop certainty from a result that only has a 1/4 chance of being sane.

I mean exactly, I had no idea if I was paranoid, sane or insane so my sus on him only developed through Dolby clearing himself and Dedenne and him and you being the only options left. As usual I'm sheeping, who's surprised

 

[Geoni]

Sus on who? Me or Phil? Because Dolby wasn't clear at the time in the case of Phil.

 

[cornimer]

Sus on Phil
I trusted Dolby although I knew he wasn't 100% clear

- - - Post Merge - - -

Hey Dad and Dolby which Punchy are you
I'm Lunchy

 

[Dolby]

Sus on Phil
I trusted Dolby although I knew he wasn't 100% clear

- - - Post Merge - - -

Hey Dad and Dolby which Punchy are you
I'm Lunchy

I’m the OG Punchster

 

[cornimer]

Well I have to go but my guess is that Dad is scummy old Brian which would make sense because he's scum
Unless Penchy was the real culprit all along

 

[Dolby]

Dad why were you viewing the Punchy maf 2 signup thread

- - - Post Merge - - -

Meh. Honestly I don’t think that Ness is going to actually give Brian scum intentionally if Dad is Brian and would rather not win that way if Dad does end up being scum

 

[Geoni]

... I actually am Penchy.

Anyways the only thing that was clear day 1 was that Dolby and I couldn't be Paranoid and Dedenne and yourself couldn't be Naive but given you claim to have inspected Phil N1 that couldn't play in said decision because you didn't have the info lol.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Dad why were you viewing the Punchy maf 2 signup thread

- - - Post Merge - - -

Meh. Honestly I don’t think that Ness is going to actually give Brian scum intentionally if Dad is Brian and would rather not win that way if Dad does end up being scum

Trying to figure out what y'all are talking about with Brian. I'm just gonna guess that is his name.

 

[N e s s]

END GAYME
U noob.​

Vampnessa was lynched. She was LunchyDaHufflepuff.

Nothing can prevent the evil punchy from achieving his win condition. Therefore, PenchyDaHufflepuff, aka Dad, has won.

Roles:

Philemon: PonchoDaHufflepuff - Sane Cop
Vampnessa: LunchyDaHufflepuff - Insane Cop
Dolby: PunchyDaHufflepuff - Naive Cop
Dedenne2: Brian - Paranoid Cop
Dad: PenchyDaHufflepuff - Mafia Goon

Congrats daddy :weary:

 

[Geoni]

Kek

 

[Dolby]

Of course Punchy was Naive

 

[PunchyTheCat]

Of course Punchy was Naive

NESS

- - - Post Merge - - -

Always better to NL during dethys

 

[Dolby]

Now that I think about it more it was probably better to lynch Vanessa D1

 

[PunchyTheCat]

Why did you guys not NL
You probably had an opportunity to clear another person

 

[N e s s]

Why did you guys not NL
You probably had an opportunity to clear another person

I mean they didn't exactly have many other options. The two useless cops were still alive and it came down to Vanessa and Dad, since they both were CCing eachother. Vanessa couldn't be cleared no matter what unless she tried really hard to sway the lynch.

 

[Dolby]

Why did you guys not NL
You probably had an opportunity to clear another person

We knew that Phile was Sane at this point and he died

Vanessa and Dad both claimed Insane so they couldn’t be cleared

Me and Dedenne we’re incapable of causing a clear