Mafia Squeaky Clean Mafia - Day 3 - Ends Monday May 25 at 7pm EST

[Antonio]

engaging with antonio right now (given their emotional state) probably won't be productive and just lead to a heated fight. this is reminding of me of last game where their got into a fight over the flawed reasoning for claiming mason so early. we can talk about this D2. an emotional argument won't help anyone and will deter others from the game. take your time to cool off

I'll be off for the next few hours while I gather some time to rest. I apologize for my actions.

 

[g u a v a]

(oh my god can we shut up about roles though!!!!!!!!!!)

This is my justification for voting Mayorleaf and you ...It is interchangeable..something about you (volt/Daniel) and Mayorleaf doesn't quite sit right with me.

it's hardly a justification but ok.

sweetie everyone confuses you at this point lol. you can do better

i lol'd.

I can see this. And I believe it's unfair for other players to heap that sus on you without giving you a chance first.

ok but is it really that unfair? he's treating it like volt and him are a different character which he's not! from his posts im not getting the sense that he was trying to rationalize volt's actions and align them with this new play style, it feels more like we're talking about two separate characters and we've yet to make a connection between besides the fact that volt could've been overwhelmed. not enough to wipe away my suspicions tbh.

 

[toadsworthy]

I'm too pissed to play this game atm, apologies. I'll be back later today when I have calm down. People have died in my life and it's frustrating atm.

good idea! This is all just a game.... everyone keep points toward people about gameplay, or in that context. If someone is clearly aggravated AT THE GAME, make sure you put that into Context OF THE GAME. Not reprimanding anyone because lord knows I know about being on both sides and see both sides. More so just a reminder to all sides for all sides

you all are great, we are all great, I am great, this is great... we’ll make it through this mafia game without any feelings hurt

*kiss kiss, mwah*

 

[Damniel]

@Damniel I will state my susses at the end of night phase if that's okay with you

yea im posting my full reads at the end too lol

BTW, just because Damniel came in doesn't mean the person he replaced isn't less scum. @Damniel What is your justification regarding your replacement previous actions?

i tried to rationalize volt's behavior in my post commenting on the progress of the second half of the day. Im not volt so i can't justify what they did, but i can rationalize as to why they may have done it. I also don't think a new player subbing out is alignment telling as both town and scum have done it. what exactly of volt's behavior am i to justify? id rather talk about what ive said. if you think volt was scum that just means everything ive said are also lies

Post automatically merged: May 20, 2020

ok but is it really that unfair? he's treating it like volt and him are a different character which he's not! from his posts im not getting the sense that he was trying to rationalize volt's actions and align them with this new play style, it feels more like we're talking about two separate characters and we've yet to make a connection between besides the fact that volt could've been overwhelmed. not enough to wipe away my suspicions tbh.

there's only so much i can do to justify a player that's not me. I wasn't able to talk to talk before i came in so in the end i have no idea why they acted the way they did, but i can try to rationalize why they might've said something given our role. we can speculate all we want but id much rather talk about what I have done. you can suspect volt but if you don't have problems with how im playing the game its not a fair argument. otherwise replacements just wouldn't be allowed

 

[Seroja]

ok but is it really that unfair? he's treating it like volt and him are a different character which he's not! from his posts im not getting the sense that he was trying to rationalize volt's actions and align them with this new play style, it feels more like we're talking about two separate characters and we've yet to make a connection between besides the fact that volt could've been overwhelmed. not enough to wipe away my suspicions tbh.

Because they are two different players. so while you can keep volt's posts and scumminesss in perspective, it would be great if you focus more on judging his slot according to Daniel's posts going forward. Otherwise you will be too biased to be objective. I have replaced a town player who was widely scumread before, but the players in the game were kind enough to consider my posts and I was able to changed their opinions on my slot.

Remember just because you're town doesn't mean you can't look scummy. Mislynches happen for this reason. If Damniel exhibits scummy behaviour then by all means, rip on that all you want.

Post automatically merged: May 20, 2020

ebwop: *change

 

[bell account]

Finally, I wouldn't be this ****ing obvious as mafia. I would let others **** themselves up, not **** myself up.

This is what is going to happen. I am against being lynched day 2 but if I must, I will vote myself off to prove a point. I would even post my role image after I die to prove a point that mafia was targeting me. So, Let's GOOOOOO.

if youre willing to vote yourself im willing to vote you too on policy

 

[Biancasbotique]

sweetie everyone confuses you at this point lol. you can do better


Also don't you dare vote yourself if you're town. Proving a point or not, that is incredibly selfish and to the detriment of town.

I know right! but I totally agree with this point. Don't vote yourself which is what I did in my early games. It is not helpful to town.

and if you look at previous posts, you should know that our thinking on Kat is alike - there is a question on why she didn't care about the lynch?

@Damniel-so that's what happened with me ..I see volt as scummy but you came in and made justifications and made townies posts- am I just supposed to separate what happened with volt and you?

Post automatically merged: May 20, 2020

if youre willing to vote yourself im willing to vote you too on policy

that was random

 

[bell account]

you can make anything fit a theme if you try hard enough. donald trump has cleaned SOMETHING at least once in his life i'm sure. also, he's literally the president of the USA so i could honestly see him fitting in as a role name in ANY mafia game

the paris accords comes to mind but that still seems to imply the opposite of cleaning, the point though is that if the op says character names arent indicative of anything then trying to figure out what donald trump is indicative of is an entirely fruitless endeavor and people doing it are just using it as a way to provide fake content

 

[Damniel]

@Damniel-so that's what happened with me ..I see volt as scummy but you came in and made justifications and made townies posts- am I just supposed to separate what happened with volt and you?

imagine that volt is town for a sec and try to think why volt would post the things they did as town. that is what i am doing. I can only go so far to explain volts actions as I am not them and didn't talk to them

its fine to use volt's behavior as part of your case on me, but if that's the main reason, its poor. if volt was scum, that means both our play styles are consistent in being scummy. if you have issues with what ive posted, id rather respond to those because im getting tired of having to defend volt

 

[Biancasbotique]

i mean you can put your role flavor but just dont put it in color ..i dont see harm in putting it out there. And i really don't take it seriously as others..everyone could just put green in their role flavor.

Post automatically merged: May 20, 2020

imagine that volt is town for a sec and try to think why volt would post the things they did as town. that is what i am doing. I can only go so far to explain volts actions as I am not them and didn't talk to them

its fine to use volt's behavior as part of your case on me, but if that's the main reason, its poor. if volt was scum, that means both our play styles are consistent in being scummy. if you have issues with what ive posted, id rather respond to those because im getting tired of having to defend volt

I am not even pressing on you lol. you were the one who asked me if what do I think is scummy about you. and I told you being a replacement is but you appear towny so you are not even on my radar for now..because of bias lol

 

[Damniel]

I am not even pressing on you lol. you were the one who asked me if what do I think is scummy about you. and I told you being a replacement is but you appear towny so you are not even on my radar for now..because of bias lol

this was more directed at everyone sussing me just because of volt

but id rather you be pressing me than no one tbh. it seems you're playing to passively. didn't you vote for mayor leaf? why aren't you pushing them?

Post automatically merged: May 20, 2020

basically bianca your making a bunch of comments but not really questioning or pushing anyone except for me who you seem null on

 

[Biancasbotique]

this was more directed at everyone sussing me just because of volt

but id rather you be pressing me than no one tbh. it seems you're playing to passively. didn't you vote for mayor leaf? why aren't you pushing them?

Post automatically merged: May 20, 2020

basically bianca your making a bunch of comments but not really questioning or pushing anyone except for me who you seem null on

huh..i didnt push on you both after EOD...because volt got replaced by you..

Huh? when did I push you? I was answering questions by you. I thought you wanted me to answer questions. Now that I'm here on the forum now....

 

[bell account]

bianca i have a question for you, which players are you most comfortable in being town

 

[Damniel]

huh..i didnt push on you both after EOD...because volt got replaced by you..

Huh? when did I push you? I was answering questions by you. I thought you wanted me to answer questions. Now that I'm here on the forum now....

i mean that you're questioning me not pushing me

but anyways, what're your thoughts on Mayor Leaf since you voted for them? have any new suspicious on different players arisen?

 

[Antonio]

if youre willing to vote yourself im willing to vote you too on policy

 

[g u a v a]

huh..i didnt push on you both after EOD...because volt got replaced by you..

Huh? when did I push you? I was answering questions by you. I thought you wanted me to answer questions. Now that I'm here on the forum now....

does anyone else get the feeling that bianca doesn’t really answer questions/contribute to sussing out mafia? could she be third party? shes given the weakest analysis of people by far and she’s more just not helpful than fishy like mafia. i mean that behavior def helps mafia but it’s just kinda all over the place and i cant seem to find any motivation.

bell and epona have both pointed out weird behavior with her that i agree with.

 

[Biancasbotique]

bianca i have a question for you, which players are you most comfortable in being town

Seroja- she had the same thinking as me as to why Kat didnt care about the lynch. so townie points for her but then I said it first but comfort level i think so.

Dan- when Dan is town, he is really helpful. The fact that he is questioning people right and left and looking at all possibiliites i think he is trying to help town

 

[bell account]

remind me what the logic is behind kat not caring about the lynch

 

[Biancasbotique]

i mean that you're questioning me not pushing me

but anyways, what're your thoughts on Mayor Leaf since you voted for them? have any new suspicious on different players arisen?

I sussed her based on her interaction with you. but it seems she is racking townie points by talking about roleclaiming and stop talking about it like its a big issue. and also her questions on you about your volt/dan-identity

 

[DinoTown]

remind me what the logic is behind kat not caring about the lynch

You mean Kat's logic, or?