• Guest, can you feel the love in the air? Valentine's Week at The Bell Tree has begun with a new mini-event featuring four activities to enjoy -- new and returning collectibles are up for grabs! Dive in to the love here.

Mafia Squeaky Clean Mafia - Day 3 - Ends Monday May 25 at 7pm EST

Damniel said:
he changed his name to geoni for a reason. please stop calling him that

anyways as far as i’m aware janitor is the only role on the mafiascum wiki that has an action somewhat similar to what happened this day. but even then it that role doesn’t fit properly since they usually act at night. this is why i speculated kat had a passive role/the power role targeted kat before the game started. are you implying geo had knowledge that a janitor like role existed beforehand?
Click to expand...
If he was mafia, yeah I think he would. Last game, all mafia actions were submitted in quicktopic so it's possible they discussed this. Even so, there could be modifications to the role in order to balance out the game. It's obvious that the action was submitted before night 1 even began.
Post automatically merged:

Trundle said:
Antonio was not implying Geoni knew the role beforehand
Click to expand...
No, I wasn't directly but I do admit it did come to mind. He was so sudden with the claim and I saw it and was like "wtf is janitor" so i google'd it and stuff.
 
Bianca basically contradicted herself. She argued with me that Kat is TOWN because as mafia she wouldn't have given up on her team mates. And now she's saying we share the same opinions about Kat, ok 👀
 
Antonio said:
No, I wasn't directly but I do admit it did come to mind. He was so sudden with the claim and I saw it and was like "wtf is janitor" so i google'd it and stuff.
Click to expand...
Oh, okay. Well I was aware of the janitor role too but I just didn't remember the name of it. I don't think it's AI at all for Geoni to bring the role up lol
 
Seroja said:
Bianca basically contradicted herself. She argued with me that Kat is TOWN because as mafia she wouldn't have given up on her team mates. And now she's saying we share the same opinions about Kat, ok 👀
Click to expand...
yes they dont look very good right now, and id like to question them more on it but they dont seem to be here anymore
 
Trundle said:
Oh, okay. Well I was aware of the janitor role too but I just didn't remember the name of it. I don't think it's AI at all for Geoni to bring the role up lol
Click to expand...
Yeah you're right. I would agree it's not AI but I just mentioned it left my mind. I think him coming to a specific role conclusion was suspicious but looking back, it wasn't as suspicious as I originally though.
 
Seroja said:
oh okay I can see where she was getting at. But I still feel iffy about it :/
Click to expand...
even with what she said, its unclear what she thought Kat was at that point. She doesn't actually say she thinks Kat is town, but just says she's not mafia. But she also said she doesn't think Kat would give up as town. so... she's thinks Kat is TP? if so why was she still against lynching her when she should've known mayor leaf wouldn't be lynched, especially with her weak reasoning for a vote (literally flipping a coin)

my issue with a janitor is when they would've targeted Kat. Before the game start? During day? something about that seems off. But if she had a passive power and was aware of it, she wouldn't be town and not have admitted that. So she's maf or TP? not sure why TP would have that passive power tbh. im leaning towards maf being aware there would be no flip (whether they targeted kat or she was an aware maf with the power) or the wipe is a weird attribute of the game itself (i wouldn't put it pass toads)
 
bell account said:
they havent really changed
geo maybe trending down lately but ive still largely got the same town circle
Click to expand...

Mafia - Squeaky Clean Mafia - Day 3 - Ends Monday May 25 at 7pm EST

what you actually think and what early impressions you're actually getting instead of just commentary on thoughts that other people have voiced. I personally think we should consider everyone a suspect and not have any solid 100% reads unless confirmed in some sort of way. I think there should...
www.belltreeforums.com

Is this your most recent reads post? You don't even explain your reads at all lol..
 
Trundle said:

Mafia - Squeaky Clean Mafia - Day 3 - Ends Monday May 25 at 7pm EST

what you actually think and what early impressions you're actually getting instead of just commentary on thoughts that other people have voiced. I personally think we should consider everyone a suspect and not have any solid 100% reads unless confirmed in some sort of way. I think there should...
www.belltreeforums.com

Is this your most recent reads post? You don't even explain your reads at all lol..
Click to expand...
you can also put seroja into town leans
we still dont have any flips so i havent had much need to reevaluate anything yet but ill definitely post another read list when its time
 
Kat wasn't going to be voted off at the time she claimed so her claiming and being like "oh hey, I'm going to be voted off but I have a lot to do today so i'll claim" was suspicious. I personally believe she was actually busy with stuff. I felt like there was two options during the time she claimed, if she was not going to be voted off then she'll be back during the next day but if she was going to be voted off, she'll have the janitor to hide her role and frame the people who voted for her.

Most likely she wouldn't have been voted off if I didn't mention role stuff and the conversation stayed on her.I also agree with Dad that no counterwagon was suspicious so Mafia would've been on board the lynch, so why would the vote off one of their own? Was she already going to be voted off the time more people went and voted for her?
Post automatically merged:

I don't think i clearly stated this but I assumed she claimed because she assumed she wouldn't have been voted off.
 
Antonio said:
I felt like there was two options during the time she claimed, if she was not going to be voted off then she'll be back during the next day but if she was going to be voted off, she'll have the janitor to hide her role and frame the people who voted for her.

Most likely she wouldn't have been voted off if I didn't mention role stuff and the conversation stayed on her.I also agree with GEONI that no counterwagon was suspicious so Mafia would've been on board the lynch, so why would the vote off one of their own? Was she already going to be voted off the time more people went and voted for her?
Click to expand...

so do you think Kat was maf or not? im unsure of the point youre trying to get at here when you bring up why she might give up but also how the scumteam wouldn't vote off their teammate
 
Damniel said:
so do you think Kat was maf or not? im unsure of the point youre trying to get at here when you bring up why she might give up but also how the scumteam wouldn't vote off their teammate
Click to expand...
Yes but with some uncertainty. I would assume Mafia would hop on board if their was no luck in saving her. I just believe that she assumed she wasn't going to be voted off during day.
Post automatically merged:

Damniel said:
geo changed his name because of personal reasons. he does not want to be called dad anymore
Click to expand...
I was aware of this. I'll attempt to start calling him Geoni but it's kind of hard when he had the same avatar for years now.
Post automatically merged:

Antonio said:
was
Click to expand...
wasn't
 
Antonio said:
Yes but with some uncertainty. I would assume Mafia would hop on board if their was no luck in saving her. I just believe that she assumed she wasn't going to be voted off during day.
Click to expand...
im unsure she thought that as maf since there was no real other wagon that was apparent in being formed. i think at that point she had 2 votes on her and most people were questioning her behavior. i think the only other wagon that could've formed was on volt, but that never really happened since after the whole role name thing most people just agreed on her. i don't see why she wouldn't think she wouldn't be lynched. if she didn't think that i feel she should've tried to bring up another wagon instead of just disappearing
 
Damniel said:
im unsure she thought that as maf since there was no real other wagon that was apparent in being formed. i think at that point she had 2 votes on her and most people were questioning her behavior. i think the only other wagon that could've formed was on volt, but that never really happened since after the whole role name thing most people just agreed on her. i don't see why she wouldn't think she wouldn't be lynched. if she didn't think that i feel she should've tried to bring up another wagon instead of just disappearing
Click to expand...
She had one vote at that time and it was Trundle while Trundle had 2 votes on him.

And the part about providing another wagon, I stated that I actually believed her excuse was legit, that's why she wasn't here too.
Post automatically merged:

I take that back, I didn't know Dad voted for Arsto.
 
Anyone can die tonight, I know we only have 20 minutes left, but I just got off of work, so if anyone wants to ask me something, I'll try to answer it.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

N e s s
Mafia TBT Mafia - Darkest Dungeon (Cancelled)
Replies
15
Views
934
N e s s
N e s s
C
Review the Video Game Above You!
Replies
11
Views
244
Midoriya
Midoriya
ILoveAnimalCrossing123
Bell Tree Forums Profile Inventory Item + TBT Bell Giveaway Contest Game (kinda but it is also kinda a game)
Replies
4
Views
195
-Blue-
-Blue-
C
Write Me a Short Story About...
Replies
1
Views
113
CoolJhon
CoolJhon
C
Make a Mii of the User Above You!
Replies
0
Views
125
Chronos314_XD
C
Back
Top