I reawoke again so yeah I can.
Cory- From what I'm reading, it seems like whenever he has a thought, he actually posts it on the thread(chain on post merges when he changes that thought too). It seems pretty genuine to me and he seems to speak what's on his mind and holds nothing back.
Entropy- Led a successful lynch on scum when if she was mafia, she could have just let town stay conflicted and probably mislynch.
Crys/Bango- Roughly the same as what I think of Cory. Not holding anything back and calls out anything scummy regardless of whether or not it's a fully developed thought or not. Looks like they're honestly trying to help town.
Dolby- Actively hunting for scum here. I go by the philosophy that "A silent Dolby is a dangerous one", and that's not present here. Seems to be making an actual effort to help town and not just coast by like he usually does as scum.
Miharu- Before I was unsure about how i felt about her. Her lack of posting actual thoughts and when she did, would be general to avoid picking at someone was off to me. But seeing she's a noob, it would make sense that she would. Obviously i wouldn't clear someone just for their experience, but her recent attempt to get more information out of players seems for town like. Now I'm thinking she's town.
WildBlueYonder- Probably my favorite new comer in the game. Has experienced in Mafia, and she shows it. Thoughts are rather developed and seems honest when it comes to answering questions. Even provides us her meta for both alignments, which I don't think she should/would have as scum.
Trundle/Bingo- I believe his claim, simple as that.
Ashtot- His play from when I've seen him as scum to here is different. Out of Sataric Vs. Ashtot, I like the posts Ashtot made. He's going by his own thoughts and states them as scum. There's a tone of honest in his post.(Is there a reason you wanted to know about this read in general?)
Shiida- I don't think she would have claimed as scum. Claiming VT early on seems like a pretty questionable thing and I believe her scum mates wouldn't have let her do that. Overall open to questioning and has honest answers.
Sataric- In his posts, he seems to just be trying to get on people's good side and give vague statments that don't really share what he actually thinks. I'm kinda disappointed in his play here. He doesn't give much to help town at all when he usually does.
Heyden- I actually didn't think he was scum until he got pressured and called as scum by the others, his reaction isn't good. His thoughts are either aggressive or all over the place. He's acting overall serious, which is very different from town heyden who sometimes makes fun of the current situations in a game. If Tardis flips red, I'll probably clear him a bit more.
Alexi- You say a lot and tend to act aggressive, but when it comes to giving reads, you don't deliver. You call me scum constantly, but you have actually not said why yet. Not sure if you're trying to get a reaction out of me or you really have no case against me. Because until i see a case(even your read on me doesn't say why you're suspicious), I'm inclined to believe that you're just trying to seem pro town by "scumhutning" when your reasonings on others are weak. I actually want you to make a case on me because that would show me you're actually town trying to lynch scum.
Cad- The thing that made me suspicious was this:
The thing with Cad's question is that it's something really odd to ask. The point of Mafia is "The informed vs the uninformed", it's pretty well stated that the mafia know each other and communicate to kill town. A question like that coming from a not so new player would be really off. I don't think a scum would ask that or tell their partner to ask that, because it's just so obvious a question.
Just by reading the introduction letter to mafia, it's easy to see that mafia can communicate with each other. I feel like this is an intentional attempt to noobslip, but I'm not sure if her or her scumteam would risk doing that. This is what conflicted me the most about her, because before she seemed to try to play better, but the posts seemed to be directed by a team. I'm starting to become null on her because there's just a lot of factors that could make her town or scum.