Damniel
Openly Wolfing
But wouldn't the doctor counter claim?
-
Staff favorites and raffle winners have been announced for TBT's Season of Giving! See the latest announcement thread: TBT's Season of Giving 2024: Closing Ceremony. Thank you to everyone for sharing your creativity and generosity during this event!
Mafia TBT Mafia: Game of Thrones - A Crown for a King - GAME OVER
- Thread starter Minties
- Start date
But wouldn't the doctor counter claim?
oath2order
#Porygon2024
There's two questions I want answered though.
1) Endless, are you veteran or were you protected?
2) Trundle, was your shot refunded?
1) Endless, are you veteran or were you protected?
2) Trundle, was your shot refunded?
it's reasonable to expect there to be two medics, so each medic has no way of knowing if the other medic is the one who saved endless. counterclaiming will just be suicide
I'm not a veteran - I was saved by someone else's action.
(A jack of all trades or doctor, unless Minties threw in some weird unusual role.)
Don't king Sataric while I'm asleep, there was something I wanted to check up on w/r/t him. It's a relatively quick check and I should be able to easily and fluidly do it when I wake up. (His post/s about Starks being the town and Petyr.)
Side note for the interested: I had Ender as mafia due to a juxtaposition between his previous games with me and this game. In previous games he approached reading me with the hope that I was town. In this game he approached reading me by deciding I was mafia and generating reads to justify it. The difference wasn't as obvious as those two lines make it sound, but it was solidly there and I'd have most likely got him lynched. (And yeah, this investigation was sparked on his reaction to him saying he liked Ashtot's post. That single play by him was just off on so many levels.)
Unfortunately that meant trawling through multiple past games for content from Ender and it used up a lot of time I could've usefully spent elsewhere.
(A jack of all trades or doctor, unless Minties threw in some weird unusual role.)
Don't king Sataric while I'm asleep, there was something I wanted to check up on w/r/t him. It's a relatively quick check and I should be able to easily and fluidly do it when I wake up. (His post/s about Starks being the town and Petyr.)
Side note for the interested: I had Ender as mafia due to a juxtaposition between his previous games with me and this game. In previous games he approached reading me with the hope that I was town. In this game he approached reading me by deciding I was mafia and generating reads to justify it. The difference wasn't as obvious as those two lines make it sound, but it was solidly there and I'd have most likely got him lynched. (And yeah, this investigation was sparked on his reaction to him saying he liked Ashtot's post. That single play by him was just off on so many levels.)
Unfortunately that meant trawling through multiple past games for content from Ender and it used up a lot of time I could've usefully spent elsewhere.
With DT and Watcher killed we can't really confirm any claims made :/ It's like mafia knows this will confuse us.
I don't see what you're intending to do here because it's just kind of confusing town if you're claming vig at this time yet can't use your shot anymore so we can't directly confirm your role.
I'll be waiting for your thoughts.
If you're just a townie now I find it odd you would claim at this time. Me and Ness already read you as Town (though we're not reliable readers, I know) and with Ender's death I'm confirmed already so you should be fine if you keep contributing as town.
I don't see what you're intending to do here because it's just kind of confusing town if you're claming vig at this time yet can't use your shot anymore so we can't directly confirm your role.
I'll be waiting for your thoughts.
I'm gonna go to sleep so please answer these for me Trundle:
1. Why did you shot Endless on N1?
2. Why did you use your shot on N1?
I'm also getting flashback to when Tom is mafia and he claimed Watcher and said he saw Ness visiting me to frame him. That action didn't make sense to me before he flipped and Trundle's action now doesn't make sense to me either.
If you really are One-Shot Vig I'm finding it hard to believe you're not using it to campaign yourself as King and promise to use your shot to help town.
I also pointed out how odd that you praised Ashtot early in the game, who happens to be have a blue role, which also reminds me of how Dolby (who was GF) defended you as Town by pointing out that you play differently as scum in Forest Fire.
I'd like to hear everyone's else thoughts on this.
1. Why did you shot Endless on N1?
2. Why did you use your shot on N1?
I'm also getting flashback to when Tom is mafia and he claimed Watcher and said he saw Ness visiting me to frame him. That action didn't make sense to me before he flipped and Trundle's action now doesn't make sense to me either.
If you really are One-Shot Vig I'm finding it hard to believe you're not using it to campaign yourself as King and promise to use your shot to help town.
I also pointed out how odd that you praised Ashtot early in the game, who happens to be have a blue role, which also reminds me of how Dolby (who was GF) defended you as Town by pointing out that you play differently as scum in Forest Fire.
I'd like to hear everyone's else thoughts on this.
Damniel
Openly Wolfing
I don't get why Trundle's shot wasn't refunded if it didn't kill. If he is telling the truth, there's probably more vigs so no refunded shots would make sense.
Don't see a reason in why Trundle would shot Endless when the only suspicious person was me. Don't see why he would claim so early, even if he didn't get the shot refunded.
- - - Post Merge - - -
the only suspicious person he called out*
Don't see a reason in why Trundle would shot Endless when the only suspicious person was me. Don't see why he would claim so early, even if he didn't get the shot refunded.
- - - Post Merge - - -
the only suspicious person he called out*
The only way for it to make sense that Trundle shot Endless and didnt get his shot refunded would be if Endless was a veteran. He claims he was not, and it had to be a medic protect, in which case Trundle would have had it refunded. So the claim doesn't add up.
oath2order
#Porygon2024
Someone look at vigilante role PMs in minties previous games and tell us about shot refunding idk
Robb Stark, Sansa Stark, and Catelyn Stark should all be in the game and most likely have important roles. Rickon Stark is also a possibility, though not necessarily added.
And @ Endless - It is evening over here already and I think we're in very different time-zones. Please go ahead and ask your questions. However, I have not asked to be crowned king - Though if I am chosen, I will of course try my best to use the power wisely.
EpicGamer12
Senior Member
For anyone wondering, as far as I know, my shot was not refunded unless Minties forgot to include it.
I claimed to account for the shot on Endless, which is obviously helpful to the town because 1) Endless is now more trusted as town and 2) I should also be more trusted as town. Also, I'm not sure what you mean by saying you're confirmed already?
1) I shot Endless because I read EnderWiggin as a blue role (which ended up being mafia, of course), and Endless to me looked like he was attacking Ender for very little reason. Especially near the end of night (I sent in my kill as a last minute decision.)
2) I sent the shot in because, after feeling that Endless was mafia, I knew that a mafia flip is often detrimental and discouraging for the mafia team, so I thought the risk to be worth it. In a PM allowed game I would have questioned him in PM before shooting, but I obviously couldn't do that.
I claimed to account for the shot on Endless, which is obviously helpful to the town because 1) Endless is now more trusted as town and 2) I should also be more trusted as town. Also, I'm not sure what you mean by saying you're confirmed already?
1) I shot Endless because I read EnderWiggin as a blue role (which ended up being mafia, of course), and Endless to me looked like he was attacking Ender for very little reason. Especially near the end of night (I sent in my kill as a last minute decision.)
2) I sent the shot in because, after feeling that Endless was mafia, I knew that a mafia flip is often detrimental and discouraging for the mafia team, so I thought the risk to be worth it. In a PM allowed game I would have questioned him in PM before shooting, but I obviously couldn't do that.
oath2order
#Porygon2024
So Endless was savrd and not a vet and Trundle has no shot.
Trundle who you sus of
Trundle who you sus of
oath2order
#Porygon2024
Or both or none
Maybe I'm misremembering then. It's been a long time since I last played.
it even makes sense from a logical "lore" point of view. a limited shot vig fires a bullet. if they shoot a vet, the bullet gets absorbed. if they shoot someone who is protected, that person still takes the bullet but the medic performs first aid and saves their life. if they are roleblocked, they are simply prevented from acting and dont fire. and if their shot overlaps with another, then they essentially turn up to find the target already dead so they dont fire.
oath2order
#Porygon2024
that's a nice explanation but can you explain how jet fuel can't melt steel beams
