Mafia TBT Mafia II: Mafia Strike Back [Game Over/Mafia Win]

[Thunder]

Actually did anyone think about how the Mafia could have potentially framed iTookYourWaffles?

FireNinja mentioned this.

hate you guys

Actually did anyone think about how the Mafia could have potentially framed iTookYourWaffles? They are reading the thread too and could have watched Laurina try to make a move against iTookYourWaffles. Being Night One, they probably needed to pick hits that would have an effect on other specific remaining players, who are tied to the targets. Laurina was the only one to call out iTookYourWaffles. Easy affiliation on iTookYourWaffles if LaurinaMN died.

What if VillageDweller is right? What if they are both innocent players on the Town team?

How many posts did Pengu have before accusing Waffles? My gut tells me that if the mafia had this strategy in mind, they would've tried jumping on it sooner.

 

[BungoTheElf]

Lynn, why are you quoting my fallout boy thread? That is a completely different subject?

- - - Post Merge - - -

Also, i have given valid reasons to why I have been absent due to illness, university and I had a prior engagement to attend last night, so please use some relevant information not posts made in a thread I made about a band.

D: Sorry, I was looking through your posts and thought that it was for this one.

Oh, and Lynn, why did you make a case against Lauren and then vote for Waffles? I know you said because Waffles hasn't posted a defense yet, but still...

I said I voted for her because she hasn't posted for defense and it wouldn't help anyways if I voted for Lauren since most people have voted already for Waffles and Beary, still even as a thought I think I may re-think this on Lauren but for me I really can't think of any other suspects in mind besides 3DS fan and Waffles..

 

[Superpenguin]

How many posts did Pengu have before accusing Waffles? My gut tells me that if the mafia had this strategy in mind, they would've tried jumping on it sooner.

I still have suspicions toward Lynn and River. More so toward Lynn, though, since River has stated she was busy with school, but now that she is off for a little while, apparently she'll be more active, so we should give her some time to see how all that plays out.

I noticed no change in lynn's activity last game as opposed to this game. She was active in the mafia chat last game, so she does know what she is doing, and she views this thread often, so it can't always just be a "Quick Catch-up Read". I'm not saying I am going to vote for lynn or that we should even lynch her. This is just my suspicion.

Looking back at Laurina's posts, she was making arguments against ITookYourWaffles:


May also be a person to watch.

About two hours after the night post and my second post after the night post was the first time I brought up Waffles' name for today.

If you caught up with the Obs Chat, though, you'll notice that I accused Andy of being mafia last game because how quickly he decided to target 3DSFan after seeing the night's results.

After their little(Oaths and 3DS's) scuffle in the past days, I really can't help but point to 3DSfan. "Revenge" vote when Oath put his down.
And rather than explaining anything for it, leaves the vote as is.

I figured that the mafia decided to kill Oath to draw suspicion onto 3DSFan just like they had done earlier to Tsundere when she voted for Devious, except this time Andy would've wanted to point it out early on and get 3DS lynched, which when he was and flipped green, made me believe that Andy was mafia, which was not the case.

 

[Princess]

D: Sorry, I was looking through your posts and thought that it was for this one.



I said I voted for her because she hasn't posted for defense and it wouldn't help anyways if I voted for Lauren since most people have voted already for Waffles and Beary, still even as a thought I think I may re-think this on Lauren but for me I really can't think of any other suspects in mind besides 3DS fan and Waffles..

Were you trying to start a bandwagon on Lauren but then saw there were a lot of votes for Waffles so voted for him/her so you wouldn't stand out? Seems suspicious

 

[Superpenguin]

Well I think another name I'd like to see posting is Pallycake. Pally who do you find suspicious in general? Not necessarily out of Beary509 or iTookYourWaffles.

Welcome back, Pally, Kayla had a question for you earlier.

 

[BlueLeaf]

My thoughts on 3DSFan - I'll most likely vote for him since his vote post was fishy:

##VOTE: ITookYourWaffles

To be honest, Waffles is really the one who's from the mafia. It would be because he wasn't posting like from 3 or 4 days.

Excuse me? I believe, 3DSFan, that you didn't post for the entire game. I hope this doesn't offend you, and I'm sorry if it does, but I think you're capable of typing with a bad throat. I'd still like to see what 3DSFan has to say though.

 

[Princess]

Welcome back, Pally, Kayla had a question for you earlier.

Oh really? I'll look right away, thanks!

 

[Superpenguin]

Oh really? I'll look right away, thanks!

I quoted the question for you.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Well I think another name I'd like to see posting is Pallycake. Pally who do you find suspicious in general? Not necessarily out of Beary509 or iTookYourWaffles.

^^

 

[Princess]

Well I think another name I'd like to see posting is Pallycake. Pally who do you find suspicious in general? Not necessarily out of Beary509 or iTookYourWaffles.

I voted for Lynn. It seemed like she was trying to get others to start pointing fingers at Lauren, but one minute later she voted for Waffles. I have a feeling it's because she didn't want to stand out from everyone else since a lot of people have been voting for iTookYourWaffles, she even posted that she voted for him/her because other people were.

 

[Farobi]

Waffles isn't back yet. But yes we did indeed share roles as pointed out by SP. I want to prove her innocence but she did post a lot of random and unproductive stuff that would probably rise suspicion.

I said this in the last game about Kuma.. but this time it being Waffles. To me, this is just how he is.
I may be wrong, but from what I've seen.. it's Waffles being themselves.

AndyB's post here is spot on. Waffles isn't really the analyzing type, but she does have her number to semi-contribute to the town. If you look at Waffles's post out of the Mafia thread, you can see that she posts casually and doesn't seem to have a care of the world on what people think of her.

And about LaurinaMN's death, that was definitely a plot of the Mafia to increase more suspicion on Waffles. Even I know Waffles wouldn't be dumb enough to raise a red flag like that. And no Waffles did not kill her.

Her off-topic posts is probably her curiousity and a way of avoiding a modkill (because she thought that not posting in each day/night cycle = modkill). About the Dolby being a "newbie", KarlaKGB playing Dota, and other stuff is just her way of contributing to avoid the modkill.

I hope Waffles goes on to defend herself soon.

 

[Princess]

Thanks superpenguin!

Here's the quote Kayla:
"I said I voted for her because she hasn't posted for defense and it wouldn't help anyways if I voted for Lauren since most people have voted already for Waffles and Beary, still even as a thought I think I may re-think this on Lauren but for me I really can't think of any other suspects in mind besides 3DS fan and Waffles.."

Lynn is saying she didn't vote for Lauren because it "wouldn't help anyways" so she jumped on the waffles bandwagon. She then said, "I really can't think of any other suspects in mind besides 3DS fan and Waffles..". Why? Why does she find them suspicious? Just because they've been accumulating a lot of votes? I want an explanation.

(To be honest, I want an explanation from everyone who voted simply because everyone else was doing so.)

 

[Midoriya]

Waffles isn't back yet. But yes we did indeed share roles as pointed out by SP. I want to prove her innocence but she did post a lot of random and unproductive stuff that would probably rise suspicion.



AndyB's post here is spot on. Waffles isn't really the analyzing type, but she does have her number to semi-contribute to the town. If you look at Waffles's post out of the Mafia thread, you can see that she posts casually and doesn't seem to have a care of the world on what people think of her.

And about LaurinaMN's death, that was definitely a plot of the Mafia to increase more suspicion on Waffles. Even I know Waffles wouldn't be dumb enough to raise a red flag like that. And no Waffles did not kill her.

Her off-topic posts is probably her curiousity and a way of avoiding a modkill (because she thought that not posting in each day/night cycle = modkill). About the Dolby being a "newbie", KarlaKGB playing Dota, and other stuff is just her way of contributing to avoid the modkill.


I hope Waffles goes on to defend herself soon.

After reading this, and hearing AndyB and Horus's posts to why they think 3DSFan is supicious I'm starting to realize that this probably WAS indeed a trick set by the mafia to put blame on Waffles. One of the mafia kills LaurinaMN after she posts suspicions towards Waffles, making it look like Waffles is mafia. 3DSFan said they couldn't be on from Strep throat, but you can still type if you have it, and they've posted very little while not really contributing. Earlier they posted Waffles would be their vote with no clear reasoning.

I decided to change my vote to 3DSFan. I hope others will do the same since the evidence has shifted dramatically in the last couple pages.

 

[FireNinja1]

Now that I think about it, it seems more likely that it was just meant to be a frame. The little contribution could have been said for others, so I'm thinking 3DSFan and his excuse. After all, I did mention this last game in the mafia chat.

 

[BlueLeaf]

I changed my vote to 3DSFan for obvious reasons. Now that I read back, Farobi said that Waffles is just a non-contributor IRL. Plus, people have said it was probably a frame. Don't you think Waffles would protect herself better is she actually was Mafia? No Mafia would not protect themselves when under suspicion. 3DSFan's post vote and Waffle's innocence was pretty much the minimal amount of info. I'd still like to see what 3DSFan has to say about this.

 

[EpicGamer12]

Thanks superpenguin!

Here's the quote Kayla:
"I said I voted for her because she hasn't posted for defense and it wouldn't help anyways if I voted for Lauren since most people have voted already for Waffles and Beary, still even as a thought I think I may re-think this on Lauren but for me I really can't think of any other suspects in mind besides 3DS fan and Waffles.."

Lynn is saying she didn't vote for Lauren because it "wouldn't help anyways" so she jumped on the waffles bandwagon. She then said, "I really can't think of any other suspects in mind besides 3DS fan and Waffles..". Why? Why does she find them suspicious? Just because they've been accumulating a lot of votes? I want an explanation.

(To be honest, I want an explanation from everyone who voted simply because everyone else was doing so.)

To be honest I don't understand why everyone bandwagon'd when I brought up Waffles. It was probably because Jubs quoted and agreed with me, and people tend to want to believe the mayor says. From seeing voting patterns based on why I suspect, I don't actually want to vote for Waffles anymore. I'm trying to prepare my post for my next biggest suspect, though.

 

[BellGreen]

3DSfan has barely been active and his posts are contentless. ITYW would most likely be guarded by the votes that were rising but no one really guarded him while the votes rose. I'll change to him for now.

 

[Superpenguin]

Either one would honestly be nice to get out of the game. Still waiting to hear Waffles's defense, but I am growing more and more suspicious of 3DS, so I think I'll go switch my vote to him.

His posts are strange, he is not active, yet he posts everywhere else. He definitely seems like mafia.

 

[Beary]

She does not seem like the mafia type, because as a mafia, I'd probably be excited and active. I am changing my vote to 3DS fan as well.

 

[FireNinja1]

She does not seem like the mafia type, because as a mafia, I'd probably be excited and active. I am changing my vote to 3DS fan as well.

Uhm...no. You'd just agree and attempt to hide in the shadows. I still think it's dummy.

- - - Post Merge - - -

She does not seem like the mafia type, because as a mafia, I'd probably be excited and active. I am changing my vote to 3DS fan as well.

Uhm...no. You'd just agree and attempt to hide in the shadows. I still think it's dummy.

- - - Post Merge - - -

...and not scummy.

 

[Lauren]

we have a new bandwagon growing, most of which used the excuse "i agree..."