Mafia TBT Mafia II: Mafia Strike Back [Game Over/Mafia Win]

[Lauren]

Believe me, there's only one side. The accused aren't even defending themselves well enough. We're shifting around through Waffles and 3DSFan.

Psh, I think I defended myself when Lynn attempted to call me out with her half arsed quotes

 

[Superpenguin]

So much reading to catch up on!

Can anybody fill me in on both sides of the argument?

People being accused:

ITookYourWaffles
3DSfan
Beary
Lynn

ITookYourWaffles is being suspected because Laurina had died last night. Laurina's major suspect was Waffles. She even tried to get Waffles's name up there with Dolby and Beary at the lynch, but failed. Now that Laurina was killed, people think the mafia either did this to 1) draw attention to Waffles who is innocent just to get her lynched today, 2) Protect Waffles, their fellow mafia, from further suspicion caused by Laurina, or 3) The mafia did not kill lLaurina for any reason relating to Waffles. She has not defended himself

3DSfan He's inactive, when he does post it's really stupid or pointless. His vote in the voting thread made little to no sense and he is just bandwagoning. He has not defended himself.

Beary he's still a suspect from last lynch and not doing a good job defending herself. She continues to bandwagon and her posts constantly lack any purpose or content. Some believe she is just a newbie townie, others suspect her of being mafia, and a poor one at that.

lynn Not too well suspected, probably made the best argument for her innocence out of any of the previous mentioned suspects. She just appeared to be as inactive as last game when she was mafia, so she obviously knows what she is doing. Her arugment is here(click)

However, she also made an accusation against Lauren, but decided to vote for Waffles instead since that's what everbody else decided.


Good luck deciding who to vote for and catching up. Anybody else please add to what I said(only new things or corrected info) to add more than one point of view to these arguments.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Sorry, I totally mix up Waffles's gender. X_X She's a girl, sorry.

 

[unravel]

Farobi is right. If I was mafia he wouldn't protect me too much, because it would let people think Farobi is mafia too if I was killed (he’s also the only one defending me ). I was busy because of prod classes so I was not looking at this thread often at that time and yesterday so yeah.
And the reason why I say that Dolby is a townie and not a mafia is that you guys might think that I'm defending her and people might think I'm suspious (i was not really sure if dolby is a townie, i just thought so by the way shes acting in this thread)

 

[Trent the Paladin]

Farobi is right. If I was mafia he wouldn't protect me too much, because it would let people think Farobi is mafia too if I was killed (he’s also the only one defending me ). I was busy because of prod classes so I was not looking at this thread often at that time and yesterday so yeah.
And the reason why I say that Dolby is a townie and not a mafia is that you guys might think that I'm defending her and people might think I'm suspious (i was not really sure if dolby is a townie, i just thought so by the way shes acting in this thread)

Dead dogs can't act.

 

[Superpenguin]

Farobi is right. If I was mafia he wouldn't protect me too much, because it would let people think Farobi is mafia too if I was killed (he’s also the only one defending me ). I was busy because of prod classes so I was not looking at this thread often at that time and yesterday so yeah.
And the reason why I say that Dolby is a townie and not a mafia is that you guys might think that I'm defending her and people might think I'm suspious (i was not really sure if dolby is a townie, i just thought so by the way shes acting in this thread)

Dolby is dead, stop bringing her back into the picture.

 

[Midoriya]

Here's my reasoning that made myself (and others) change our votes to 3DSFan:

After reading this, and hearing AndyB and Horus's posts to why they think 3DSFan is supicious I'm starting to realize that this probably WAS indeed a trick set by the mafia to put blame on Waffles. One of the mafia kills LaurinaMN after she posts suspicions towards Waffles, making it look like Waffles is mafia. 3DSFan said they couldn't be on from Strep throat, but you can still type if you have it, and they've posted very little while not really contributing. Earlier they posted Waffles would be their vote with no clear reasoning.

I decided to change my vote to 3DSFan. I hope others will do the same since the evidence has shifted dramatically in the last couple pages.

That is just my side of the coin though. It is the best possible lynch I can identify right now, and I am sure other people have reasoning for voting for the other three suspects.

 

[Prof Gallows]

3DSfan He's inactive, when he does post it's really stupid or pointless. His vote in the voting thread made little to no sense and he is just bandwagoning. He has not defended himself.

Is this really a good enough reason to lynch someone? >.>

Really, I think you're all wasting a lynch. We need to be looking for good players who might be mafia, not crappy players who probably aren't.

 

[Midoriya]

Is this really a good enough reason to lynch someone? >.>

Really, I think you're all wasting a lynch. We need to be looking for good players who might be mafia, not crappy players who probably aren't.

Do you have anyone in mind? We're all just trying to get some leads.

 

[iLoveYou]

3DSFan134, not to mention you went from:

Who will end up being lynched?

.. to ..

##VOTE: ITookYourWaffles

To be honest, Waffles is really the one who's from the mafia. It would be because he wasn't posting like from 3 or 4 days.

.. without any posts in between to explain your thought process or motivation to go full out on iTookYourWaffles.

No explanation, jumping on iTookYourWaffles after the thread exploded on her, no participation in the Town discussions, no defence even though people are currently voting for you. If you are an innocent Town player then we need you to step up so we do not make a bad lynch. Otherwise it just looks like you are trying to take advantage of a situation here (iTookYourWaffles looking guilty).

This raises a red flag for me, and I see that it's raised a red flag for others. Again, if you are an innocent town player please do not encourage us to lynch you (the way you currently are acting is too much reason to get you lynched) and step up.

 

[Prof Gallows]

Do you have anyone in mind? We're all just trying to get some leads.

I still think Kayla is making huge fools out of all of you but going down that road isn't going to get me anywhere.

I thought beary at first but I think I may have just jumped onto that off of misunderstanding the posts. Waffles hasn't done really anything I can see that would make me go for them, other than a few people mentioning one or two things.
So I dunno. Right now the only things to go off of are lack of posts and supposedly weird votes.

Think people should go back and look at the previous game. This happened last time.

 

[Midoriya]

I still think Kayla is making huge fools out of all of you but going down that road isn't going to get me anywhere.

I thought beary at first but I think I may have just jumped onto that off of misunderstanding the posts. Waffles hasn't done really anything I can see that would make me go for them, other than a few people mentioning one or two things.
So I dunno. Right now the only things to go off of are lack of posts and supposedly weird votes.

Think people should go back and look at the previous game. This happened last time.

Just because something happened once doesn't mean it's guaranteed to happen again.

And what do you mean she's making huge fools out of us all? It seems like you have more advanced knowledge when you posted this statement.

 

[Prof Gallows]

Just because something happened once doesn't mean it's guaranteed to happen again.

And what do you mean she's making huge fools out of us all? It seems like you have more advanced knowledge when you posted this statement.

I've already stated my case against Kayla. If you want to see it go back to the start of the game. But that fight was then, new fight is now.
And I'm saying that lynching 3dsfan is a waste. But I seriously doubt anyone is going to listen, and I don't really see a point in continuing the debate on it as, just like everyone else, I have no real evidence to support my claim.

 

[oath2order]

Is this really a good enough reason to lynch someone? >.>

Really, I think you're all wasting a lynch. We need to be looking for good players who might be mafia, not crappy players who probably aren't.

I still think Kayla is making huge fools out of all of you but going down that road isn't going to get me anywhere.

I thought beary at first but I think I may have just jumped onto that off of misunderstanding the posts. Waffles hasn't done really anything I can see that would make me go for them, other than a few people mentioning one or two things.
So I dunno. Right now the only things to go off of are lack of posts and supposedly weird votes.

Think people should go back and look at the previous game. This happened last time.

Okay, so first you say we're wasting a lynch by voting for crappy players.

Then, when pressed on who you're considering, you give two names of the crappy players >.> I'm not accusing you of anything, but if you're going to claim we're wasting a lynch, give us a new name or something

 

[Prof Gallows]

Okay, so first you say we're wasting a lynch by voting for crappy players.

Then, when pressed on who you're considering, you give two names of the crappy players >.> I'm not accusing you of anything, but if you're going to claim we're wasting a lynch, give us a new name or something

Neither of those people I mentioned are people I suspect?
I gave reasons why I kind of suspected beary, but I'm not sure, and why I don't suspect Waffles.

I've only said I suspect one person for sure.

 

[oath2order]

Just seemed like you were, that's all. Sorry!

 

[Beary]

Im just saying, but everyone is pointing fingers.
STAY CALM AND USE YOUR HEADS.
Any of us could be friendly with a mafia. We have to stay on our toes.
No lynch is useless or wasteful, because when one suspect is lynched, you can move onto another.
Its as simple as that.

 

[Trent the Paladin]

Either way, it's day two and none of us really have solid leads. Waffles may or may not be mafia because they may or may not have been set up to look like they cause Laurina's death. 3DSfan doesn't contribute well or much, Beary is actually improving, lynn is acting weird, and we don't have much of a reason to suspect Lauren. Day two really blows guys.

 

[Prof Gallows]

Im just saying, but everyone is pointing fingers.
STAY CALM AND USE YOUR HEADS.
Any of us could be friendly with a mafia. We have to stay on our toes.
No lynch is useless or wasteful, because when one suspect is lynched, you can move onto another.
Its as simple as that.

Then you have no objections for me keeping me vote for you then?
If you're townie, we've still got a fighting chance, right?

 

[iLoveYou]

I still think Kayla is making huge fools out of all of you but going down that road isn't going to get me anywhere.

Spoiler: snip

I thought beary at first but I think I may have just jumped onto that off of misunderstanding the posts. Waffles hasn't done really anything I can see that would make me go for them, other than a few people mentioning one or two things.
So I dunno. Right now the only things to go off of are lack of posts and supposedly weird votes.

Think people should go back and look at the previous game. This happened last time.

Spoiler: snip

Neither of those people I mentioned are people I suspect?
I gave reasons why I kind of suspected beary, but I'm not sure, and why I don't suspect Waffles.

I've only said I suspect one person for sure.

That's completely fine. Everyone is entitled to their doubts and suspicions in this game. For the record, when you jumped on Beary509 it just felt like you were trying to encourage the town to make a bad lynch on a clearly inexperienced player who shouted " Look! I'm bandwagoning y'all ". It was the same logic which got Dolby the Townie out of the game, just before that.

Feel free to keep that vote there, by all means. I do admit, I would like to get Beary509 out of the game too since she is a bandwagoner & is messing with the votes (constantly flip flopping) as well as not contributing to the town side at all. Just definitely not now, this player can wait to be lynched and we have more suspicious players to target. We need to aim high, not low such as players playing poorly.

You said it yourself, Gallows:

Is this really a good enough reason to lynch someone? >.>

Really, I think you're all wasting a lynch. We need to be looking for good players who might be mafia, not crappy players who probably aren't.

& yet you decide to keep your vote on Beary509, even though you admitted that you:

I still think Kayla is making huge fools out of all of you but going down that road isn't going to get me anywhere.

I thought beary at first but I think I may have just jumped onto that off of misunderstanding the posts. Waffles hasn't done really anything I can see that would make me go for them, other than a few people mentioning one or two things.
So I dunno. Right now the only things to go off of are lack of posts and supposedly weird votes.

Think people should go back and look at the previous game. This happened last time.

So either you're throwing your vote away, trying to delay the Town and hoping for a bad town lynching episode, or you really do believe Beary509 is mafia even though the majority of the Town have come to their own conclusions (each person individually) that she is simply a new player, playing poorly. Again, by all means keep your vote there. This is not to discourage you to remove your vote from Beary509. It just shows a little contradiction on your part.

 

[Beary]

Then you have no objections for me keeping me vote for you then?
If you're townie, we've still got a fighting chance, right?

I have no objections. If I die, its only going to hurt the town.