Mafia TBT Mafia III: The Murder Before Christmas [Game Over/Town Win]

[FireNinja1]

He's not even in the game, don't mini mod yo he made a post by accident

Apologies, thought he was in the game, sorry.

 

[Dolby]

I agree that Karla is the best choice for mayor/sheriff because he has hosted both games before and has a lot of experience, so that is why i'm voting for him

 

[Princess]

I, personally, after a long bout of PMs with another person who I am awfully sure is a Town member (NOT lynn105), that KarlaKGB is Mafia, or at least some kind of other bad thing. S/he (hey, ya never know) is trying to get us all to trust him/her, and keeps on giving believable arguments. Yeah, I read the plan and all, and think it might be beneficial to the Town, but KarlaKGB is just too shady, in my opinion. Go ahead: Toss my suspicions aside. I'm a newb. I just cannot help but feel suspicious.

If you're a townie then enlighten us, who were you talking to? The game just started how can you be so sure?

 

[BlueLeaf]

We have plenty of time, my vote is probably coming in today. My vote is leaning towards VD, but he hadn't said anything about becoming mayor until Oath brought it up, so it kind of worries me. If memory serves, LaurinaMN, VillageDweller, Trundle, River, and KarlaKGB are running. My top two choices are VD and Laurina right now, Karla in a close third. I'd like to see Trundle and River post more (but Trundle's birthday is today I think). 4 said they analyze well, and 3 (Not Karla, unless you count the two chats) showed this well. VD's pop-in was kind of sudden, but Oath's reasoning was pretty good. River didn't say much about her campaign, so I can't really see her as mayor.
----
Aside from the mayoral stuff going on, I'd like to say that Blu Rose seems, a little, I can't really find a word for him. I have to go with people on this - His posts keep on telling us to shun him and he keeps on apologizing. We shouldn't really suspect anyone and keep on attacking them in the election period however. The first lynch (and maybe the second lynch in a worst-case scenario) won't have that much information, let alone any, to go off of other than the posts we have. People, if you don't want to get suspected and/or killed by the Mafia, don't post garbage! It's that simple, really.

Pallycake: Don't forget Mafia will be stupid not to frame the elected roles. Detectives and the Assassins have Millers, Bus Drivers and Framers in the way.

Blu Rose: I have some questions I'm pretty sure everyone is DYING to hear. Who is this person you have been PM'ing? How are you sure s/he is innocent if it's only the first day? Why are you bringing up Lynn?

 

[Princess]

Mafia can not frame the same individual two nights in a row, I would hope that the detective(s) would double check the elected members.

 

[kittenrobotarmy]

Fine. I admit it. I was. I asked Blu why exactly he had voted for me, then it basically turned into a discussion about the mayor candidates and suspicions about them. I did do it to quickly, so he suspected me. I did tell him I was Townie again, though. Blu also said he was Townie, but you guys seem to have your suspicions about him. He thought I was Town because I pointed out things that could have possibly signaled Mafia, but it wasn't really much of anything that would affect the game.

 

[Superpenguin]

Mafia can not frame the same individual two nights in a row, I would hope that the detective(s) would double check the elected members.

As stated by Karla earlier, this will cause the Detectives to waste valuable on the same person. If the mayoral roles are not giving any reason to be suspected of mafia, then why even bother inspecting them in the first place? Go for someone you KNOW won't be framed, bus drivered, etc.

 

[Princess]

As stated by Karla earlier, this will cause the Detectives to waste valuable on the same person. If the mayoral roles are not giving any reason to be suspected of mafia, then why even bother inspecting them in the first place? Go for someone you KNOW won't be framed, bus drivered, etc.

How would the detectives know that though? Unless role revealing has already started?

 

[kittenrobotarmy]

As stated by Karla earlier, this will cause the Detectives to waste valuable on the same person. If the mayoral roles are not giving any reason to be suspected of mafia, then why even bother inspecting them in the first place? Go for someone you KNOW won't be framed, bus drivered, etc.

Keep in mind they could also be hiding it well. A simple role like Mafia Goon is really easy to hide, and Godfather is even more easy because rolechecks do nothing. How would you know someone wouldn't be framed or drivered?

 

[Princess]

Fine. I admit it. I was. I asked Blu why exactly he had voted for me, then it basically turned into a discussion about the mayor candidates and suspicions about them. I did do it to quickly, so he suspected me. I did tell him I was Townie again, though. Blu also said he was Townie, but you guys seem to have your suspicions about him. He thought I was Town because I pointed out things that could have possibly signaled Mafia, but it wasn't really much of anything that would affect the game.

What things did you point out?

 

[kittenrobotarmy]

It was mostly the common stuff, like over-saying you were Town and such. Oh, and how the two officials last game didn't keep their promises but no one noticed was a sign. I cleaned out my Inbox because it was full anyways, so I couldn't tell you much because I don't remember.

 

[Hikari]

Anyways, it looks like Karla is leading in votes at the moment, with Harry in second.

I personally think this is a good pair since their both make good posts, and have good plans, as well. (Along with Trundle, too bad they haven't really made many posts yet.)

 

[Superpenguin]

How would the detectives know that though? Unless role revealing has already started?

Know who won't be framed or bus drivered?

They won't know for 100% certainty, but I think it's kind of a given the mafia will try to frame elected roles or people who definitely stand a chance of getting rolechecked(like people who randomly roleclaim).

Honestly, I think the Detectives' main goal should be inspecting a single person first to see if they can trust them. Then they can start building trust with that single person and give them their information they uncover in the case that they die. Once finding just one single person to trust, you should then go after the elected roles and main targets. Of course, if the elected roles start attracting some suspicion, inspect them sooner rather than later.

 

[kittenrobotarmy]

Know who won't be framed or bus drivered?

They won't know for 100% certainty, but I think it's kind of a given the mafia will try to frame elected roles or people who definitely stand a chance of getting rolechecked(like people who randomly roleclaim).

Honestly, I think the Detectives' main goal should be inspecting a single person first to see if they can trust them. Then they can start building trust with that single person and give them their information they uncover in the case that they die. Once finding just one single person to trust, you should then go after the elected roles and main targets. Of course, if the elected roles start attracting some suspicion, inspect them sooner rather than later.

I always thought about this. This is a smart idea, because then you can trust someone and discuss information with them. They might be Godfather, so you must be careful.

 

[KarlaKGB]

I pointed out things that could have possibly signaled Mafia, but it wasn't really much of anything that would affect the game.

Please don't tell me you were the instigator of the "too good to be true" nonsense.

 

[kittenrobotarmy]

Not really, no. I wasn't discussing that. But like I said, holding up promises is a sign. If they hold them up fully, they are Town. If they try to but don't really do anything, it's probably Mafia right there.

 

[Princess]

Just a little FYI if no one can give a solid reason as to why Karla shouldn't be mayor, I won't be switching my vote.
Not one person has provided evidence as to why he wouldn't make a good mayor.
Someone with his experience is needed to keep everyone on track.

 

[kittenrobotarmy]

Just a little FYI if no one can give a solid reason as to why Karla shouldn't be mayor, I won't be switching my vote.
Not one person has provided evidence as to why he wouldn't make a good mayor.
Someone with his experience is needed to keep everyone on track.

Everyone's scared he's Mafia, which will murder the Town. But if Karla clearly holds up his promises if he's Mayor, then I will believe fully that Karla is a Town member.

 

[Superpenguin]

Everyone's scared he's Mafia, which will murder the Town. But if Karla clearly holds up his promises if he's Mayor, then I will believe fully that Karla is a Town member.

Once again, you should be scared any candidate is mafia!

 

[Princess]

Everyone's scared he's Mafia, which will murder the Town. But if Karla clearly holds up his promises if he's Mayor, then I will believe fully that Karla is a Town member.

ANYONE COULD BE MAFIA
We need to elect someone that has experience and will keep everyone on track.

If Karla steps outta line we can lynch his ass anytime, I don't understand why everyone is so paranoid.