Mafia TBT Mafia III: The Murder Before Christmas [Game Over/Town Win]

[oath2order]

KARLA IS A HE. MALE.

 

[Princess]

Pallycake: Oh, they were teasing with each other. Thanks for clarifying. Anyway, I'm not voting for Karla because I think VillageDweller is really well-suited for the role. I'm not saying Karla would the most terrible mayor in all games of Mafia;I actually think she would make a good mayor. If I recall, Karla wanted to be a sheriff, so there's another reason why I'm voting for VD.

What's your reasoning for VD though?
I am genuinely looking for a reason from you guys but no one is providing me with any answers.
It's all starting to look like an elaborate plan to re-elect a member of the mafia again.

 

[Beary]

I'm voting for Karla. He seems to have experience (as he hosted the last two games :0), and he seems trustworthy.
VD just suspected somebody and then dropped it.
And then he died.
I suspected Kayla for a bit in the second game, but am I pro? No.
I am confuzzled D:
Anyways, I will change my vote if anything comes up. Sorry I haven't been posting! but I had a dance tonight

 

[Princess]

I do believe VillagerDweller would make a great candidate as much as any other I have to agree with Pally and VD and Kayla being friends so he through the accusation at her. It was a great accusation, but it's just a suspicious we all need to fear with the elected roles. It was just a prediction that he made and was hoping it'd come true like he stated in the observer's chat:
"IF DIS SHT COMES TRU I WILL FLIP A TABLE. I predicted Kayla was the Godfather on like flippin DAY ONE LOL
(but then i trusted her and NOW I'M DEAD. dis may all b coming together)"
Lots of people predicted Jubs as scum the second the game started due to instant votes, bandwagoning, he didn't even need to campaign since votes were already pouring in for him (WHY AREN'T WE ALL VOTING FOR JUSTIN THIS GAME? Are you all so scared of him since he was Mayor and scum last game? He won didn't he? If he was a town role, he'd win it for us wouldn't he?) Sure we obviously have learned from are mistakes, but can't you see why Karla is trying to hard to prove and defend himself to all of you? We're all paranoid. The Mafia is probably laughing at us all and manipulating us by allowing our doubts and paranoia get the best of us. Ever thought that the Mafia can be trying extremely hard to make damn sure that Karla doesn't get elected? Everyone knows where he stands. He's been an open book and has fought for his place since the very beginning, which many of the players here can't say for themselves.

Look guys. Look. Someone who's analyzing stuff and thinking critically.

 

[oath2order]

At least get the ball rolling on someone who makes a decent case for themselves!
There's tons of other players in this game who should step up for the position.

Should. Yes, they SHOULD. But do they? No. If I'm going to nominate someone and be looked at as suspicious for that, then I'm going to nominate someone who I believe would do a good job, not someone who hasn't even ****ing posted yet.

Or you! You nominate someone if you so strongly believe that there's someone else out there who makes a decent case for themselves. But no, you just sit here and attack me for nominating someone to the position so we don't have a Sheriff voted in who was just a placeholder vote. Here's a suggestion: Quit attacking me, and if you think there's someone who can make a good case, ****ing state it and hop off.

I'll probably end up voting Karla for mayor though. Why? Because I do like Karla. As much as he comes off as abrasive in his posts, if there's anybody who's done an excellent job of defending themselves, it's him.

 

[KarlaKGB]

Sure we obviously have learned from are mistakes, but can't you see why Karla is trying to hard to prove and defend himself to all of you?

Apparently to some, the harder I try to prove myself, the more it means I am Mafia.

 

[cannedcommunism]

Apparently to some, the harder I try to prove myself, the more it means I am Mafia.

You're getting me wrong. What I was trying to say is that you're almost putting yourself above everybody else like you're some almighty figure. At least that's how I see it.

 

[Laurina]

Look guys. Look. Someone who's analyzing stuff and thinking critically.

Duh. #Laurina4Sheriff. #Pally4Mayor. Sorry for the disturbing grammar mistakes. Was I half asleep? I'm embarrassed. But really, people need to think for themselves. I'm sure most of you are going to end up changing your votes tomorrow anyway. Read what people have to say, study what they're saying, and try to see things from their perspective and how they're holding up under the pressure. Would you handle yourself any differentl?

 

[Princess]

Should. Yes, they SHOULD. But do they? No. If I'm going to nominate someone and be looked at as suspicious for that, then I'm going to nominate someone who I believe would do a good job, not someone who hasn't even ****ing posted yet.

VD hasn't posted anything that would make him a good mayor...so you're voting for him because....?

Or you! You nominate someone if you so strongly believe that there's someone else out there who makes a decent case for themselves. But no, you just sit here and attack me for nominating someone to the position so we don't have a Sheriff voted in who was just a placeholder vote. Here's a suggestion: Quit attacking me, and if you think there's someone who can make a good case, ****ing state it and hop off.

I'm not attacking you, I am genuinely curious as to why you're voting for VD. You need to chill out brah.
Also I think Karla would be an excellent mayor, hence my vote for him.

I'll probably end up voting Karla for mayor though. Why? Because I do like Karla. As much as he comes off as abrasive in his posts, if there's anybody who's done an excellent job of defending themselves, it's him.

Thanks Sherlock.

- - - Post Merge - - -

EDIT: *Started the vote for him because...?

- - - Post Merge - - -

Duh. #Laurina4Sheriff. #Pally4Mayor.

I'm on board

 

[oath2order]

Oh for ****'s sake. As I said numerous times, I nominated and likely not going to vote for VillageDweller because it was someone else who figured out Kayla was godfather. I was the second known person to do so. People read my good-bye/death post in the last game, and thought I was dropping a hint.

There's a difference between nominating someone and voting for someone. Such as what I'm doing. Nominating VillageDweller to put someone else out in the public.Nobody else was really making a push, so I figured I'd do it on behalf of someone I thought would do a good job. You think Karla would do a good job for the reasons you stated, and I think VillageDweller will do a good job for the reasons I stated. Just to reiterate, again, I think he'll do a good job because I think he did a good job deducing Kayla, and obviously is feared by the mafia because he keeps getting killed early on.

Is that enough for you?

 

[KarlaKGB]

I am voting for Trundle. He has made good posts in this thread, did successfully push for Hikari to be lynched last game. From my PM exchange with him, he also appears to be person I can really work well with.

 

[oath2order]

I am voting for Trundle. He has made good posts in this thread, did successfully push for Hikari to be lynched last game. From my PM exchange with him, he also appears to be person I can really work well with.

Since Trundle hasn't posted, is there anything you can safely say to convince us to vote for Trundle?

 

[SlaughterShy]

I actually had a dance as well. Weird.

 

[KarlaKGB]

Since Trundle hasn't posted, is there anything you can safely say to convince us to vote for Trundle?

http://www.belltreeforums.com/showt...Murder-Before-Christmas&p=2051610#post2051610

http://www.belltreeforums.com/showt...Murder-Before-Christmas&p=2052564#post2052564

http://www.belltreeforums.com/showt...Murder-Before-Christmas&p=2053388#post2053388

 

[Princess]

Oh for ****'s sake. As I said numerous times, I nominated and likely not going to vote for VillageDweller because it was someone else who figured out Kayla was godfather. I was the second known person to do so. People read my good-bye/death post in the last game, and thought I was dropping a hint.

There's a difference between nominating someone and voting for someone. Such as what I'm doing. Nominating VillageDweller to put someone else out in the public.Nobody else was really making a push, so I figured I'd do it on behalf of someone I thought would do a good job. You think Karla would do a good job for the reasons you stated, and I think VillageDweller will do a good job for the reasons I stated. Just to reiterate, again, I think he'll do a good job because I think he did a good job deducing Kayla, and obviously is feared by the mafia because he keeps getting killed early on.

Is that enough for you?

I posted EDIT because I used the word vote instead of nominate.

The reasoning for VD is so...............................useless though....like I said before just start pushing votes for me because I'm cooler than Karla then. My reasoning for myself is equal to yours for VD.

 

[radical6]

well i def want karla to be our sheriff (u wanted to be sheriff right?) but i think i wont vote for him because i think he has enough votes. soooo ill vote for the mayor.

im leaning towards trundle!! but its his birthday so he probably wont post that much today, but i think he was pretty good last game. laurina is a good choice too yeah!!
maybe the town can try to make it so that karla gets sheriff and then trundle/laurina get mayor?

and about vd (love u bb) yeah he didnt really push it forward. maybe if he did, the game would've changed but ?. if i recall he told me he voted for beary because he was afraid mafia would target him for voting for kayla or someone else? i dunno. idk if he told kayla his role before he protected me (kayla was saying she was pretty sure he was medic. i think when he protected me on night 1 that kinda gave him away whoops) so yeah its kinda my fault he died uh// but if he could show us he can fix those mistakes then maybe i would change my mind. i dont really get they he trusted kayla afterwards ? if he could get on later and explain then maybe all would make sense idk ? but sorry bb !! as much as i would want u to be mayor i cant really vote for u..maybe next time :' ( i still love u tho

I actually had a dance as well. Weird.

what does this have to do with mafia...?

- - - Post Merge - - -

i dont really get why he trusted kayla afterwards *im sorry im tired

 

[Keen]

Karla seems to have everybody eating from the palm of his hand. It makes perfect sense for me that if he was mafia, he'd gun so hard for mayor or sheriff, and everyone is doing exactly what he wants them to do.

Did anybody learn from last game that the two who wanted the elected roles so bad were later found to be mafia?

 

[oath2order]

My reasoning for myself is equal to yours for VD.

Then stop attacking me for nominating him, if the reasoning is equal.

You're basically on me because you don't like VD.

 

[KarlaKGB]

http://www.belltreeforums.com/showthread.php?111874-TBT-Mafia-II-Mafia-Strike-Back&p=1990300&viewfull=1#post1990300

1. Pointing fingers is one sign. They know who the other members are, and they can try and kill whoever they want by that method.
2. Mafia are cowardly. They try not to post because they're afraid that they'll get suspected.
3. Going along with #2, they'll try not to have opinions to avoid suspicion, so they'll go along with a bandwagon.

Do I fit into points 2 and 3? (Point 1 is not useful for the purposes of finding Mafia, unless you mean blindly pointing fingers).

 

[Princess]

Karla seems to have everybody eating from the palm of his hand. It makes perfect sense for me that if he was mafia, he'd gun so hard for mayor or sheriff, and everyone is doing exactly what he wants them to do.

Did anybody learn from last game that the two who wanted the elected roles so bad were later found to be mafia?

That's valid River. Like I said though, if Karla starts acting suspicious the town can lynch him.
You're also a very experienced player I'd really like it if you made a case for yourself to be mayor/sherrif

- - - Post Merge - - -

sheriff*

- - - Post Merge - - -

Then stop attacking me for nominating him, if the reasoning is equal.

You're basically on me because you don't like VD.

DUDE I LOVE HARRY
I'm not even attacking you, you need to chiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiillllllllllllllll out