Mafia TBT Mafia III: The Murder Before Christmas [Game Over/Town Win]

[BungoTheElf]

These questions?
1. Is something in real life affecting the game? I have seen all of you active on the forums, especially Klinkguin.

Uhh I was gonna get my internet switched today but then my dad said that the cable company doesn't work on Sundays after lunch D: (Tomorrow morning is the only time I'll be active for a while)

2. Are you a disinterested Townie?

No, I like playing the game. My way of playing is staying quiet, sorry if it doesn't help much. I only bring out big paragraphs when I can confirm something specifically.

3. Why aren't you contributing?

Kinda what I said above

4. Why didn't you guys give a reason for voting? (I'm sorry if you did post a reason)

I did

 

[Klinkguin]

Yeah I answered those questions in the previous page like 10 mins ago ^^^^^^

- - - Post Merge - - -

Oh yeah I do also like staying quiet in games(I am shy irl)

 

[radical6]

1. No, there isn't something in real life that is affecting anything. I am just really wanting my last dreamie and paying more attention to the cycling threads.
2. No I am not disinterested. I am very interested about what is going on.
3. I am not contributing as much as you would think because I am not always sure on what to say.
4. My reason for voting was because I have been observing the thread rather than posting. I made my decision on what people have said in this thread.
I hope this solves your problems.
This is my first time playing this game so please bare with me.

i never see you reading the thread? like ive never seen you view the thread.

and its fine if youre looking for your last dream villager, but that shouldnt take up all your time should it? and hey i second guess myself a lot when i post and im not always sure what to say either. but its always worth giving a try y'know! but if youre going to observe cant you at least tell us why you voted? its kinda too late now but next time would be good.

 

[Klinkguin]

It kinda does take up all my time because I have time limits on here.

 

[Chris.]

It kinda does take up all my time because I have time limits on here.

Why would you sign up for the game then? I'm just taking a guess that since you really want this dreamie, you would have been paying attention to the cycling forums before the game actually started. So if it takes up all your time within your time limits here, why did you sign up for the game? You say you are very interested in what's going on but right before that you said you are paying attention to other forums more.

 

[Chris]

About the day 1 lynch...
I don't think anyone is bothered too much about who was lynched - but more that we had no input on the first day lynch when that was one of the things we were promised in voting for Karla and Trundle. If you're unhappy with their decision isn't it because you feel like they broke their first promise, rather than actually being angry about FoxWolf being lynched?

I'm personally not annoyed with them or their decision. There genuinely wasn't enough time to properly discuss the lynch with the town, so I don't think it's fair of us to put all of the blame on the elected roles for an innocent being lynched. We are just as much at fault as our mayor and sheriff: we didn't use our first day wisely and as a result we failed to provide the evidence needed for them to make a more sensible decision.


About inactives...
Thanks BlueLeaf for taking the initiative to contact them. I think it would be better if we heard directly from them before deciding whether or not to be suspicious of them. If they can't provide a good reason for their inactivity then that's when we should start investigating: are they lurkers or is life simply getting in the way?


My own suspicions...
The person who seems most suspicious to me right now is Klinkguin. Being active on the rest of the forum but not properly contributing in here doesn't look good.

 

[Klinkguin]

Why would you sign up for the game then? I'm just taking a guess that since you really want this dreamie, you would have been paying attention to the cycling forums before the game actually started. So if it takes up all your time within your time limits here, why did you sign up for the game? You say you are very interested in what's going on but right before that you said you are paying attention to other forums more.

I signed up because it was before I only had 1 dreamie left. I also wanted to try something new that I haven't done before. I mean I am learning from my mistakes so thanks everyone for telling me what to do.

 

[kerryelizabeth]

I have to say, personally, my FOS points to Klinkguin. She says she has been an observer of the game instead of a participant, and yet whenever I check the people viewing, she's never actually viewing it whatsoever. Also, she seemed to really try and avoid answering any of our questions until completely and utterly pushed to do so. She's posting one liners more often than not, and also cast her vote with no reason whatsoever. Saying "I was observing the thread" doesn't explain WHY she voted for who she did. So at the moment, my FOS is cast on her.

 

[BlueLeaf]

We now know that lynn105 had her internet things. Tina is right about Klink - active on the rest of the forum, but not on here. Doesn't scream "mafia," but the fishiest out of everyone. However, I'd really like to wait for the BFG, SlaughterShy, and BowserFanGurl for their input before moving on too far.

- - - Post Merge - - -

*BFG, SlaughterShy, and PikaSweet

 

[kittenrobotarmy]

Klink, it says right on the first post that this game requires a time commitment. Why are you so active on anywhere but here?

 

[KarlaKGB]

Regarding Klinkguin not viewing the thread - I believe she was on invisible mode for the majority of yesterday. I know this because I was trying to check her last activity time during my lurker analysis and couldn't.

 

[Klinkguin]

Regarding Klinkguin not viewing the thread - I believe she was on invisible mode for the majority of yesterday. I know this because I was trying to check her last activity time during my lurker analysis and couldn't.

Yeah! I was on invisible mode. I forgot to turn that off. Oh and if you are considering lynching me then I don't really care. It won't help you in any way.

 

[SlaughterShy]

1) I'm sorry, this past week has been pretty busy for me. I had a performance and dance which both ran later then expected.

2) I'm not necessarily disinterested, but I'm a tiny bit nervous to post in fear it'll just get ripped to shreds by someone. This game is kind of intimidating when you know so little. I would have read the previous games, but was occupied with reading what I had missed.

3) When the majority of the election was going on I was busy with other things, and when I was available the thread was rather slow and struggled to find anything I could post while attaining relevancy.

4) I was at a press for time when voting commenced and it was kinda last minute with the timer mishap.

 

[kittenrobotarmy]

Yeah! I was on invisible mode. I forgot to turn that off. Oh and if you are considering lynching me then I don't really care. It won't help you in any way.

That just proves further you don't care about the game. "I don't care if you lynch me"? You're showing you're not interested to be a part of the game.

 

[BellGreen]

Yeah! I was on invisible mode. I forgot to turn that off. Oh and if you are considering lynching me then I don't really care. It won't help you in any way.

Why play a game when you don't want to see it through the end? If you are really pushing people to lynch you, that only proves you just don't want to play and you should let someone much more committed to play.

 

[kittenrobotarmy]

I think we should simply lynch Klink. She's not showing any interest in playing the game so there's no point in keeping her even if she is Town, because it's clear she won't do her part in killing the Mafia. Besides, Klink said she didn't care if we lynched her. Why should we keep someone who doesn't care?

Feel free to add. Klink probably isn't Mafia, but she's not showing anything that encourages us to keep her when she how disinterested she was in the game.

 

[BellGreen]

I think we should let BowserFan speak for herself first, she has posted a small 7 posts most not contributing anything worth. Klink is just a player who's not interested much. She wouldn't be dumb enough to join a game where she knows she will not play much.

 

[KarlaKGB]

We should move beyond the Klinkguin issue now, we aren't getting anywhere with her. She's an awful lynch for tomorrow, we have better candidates for that. I'm 90% certain she's innocent, possibly assassin I don't know. A vig can shoot her I guess and try to confirm themselves off that, but I don't think even that is a good idea.

 

[kittenrobotarmy]

You have a point. Klink, if you don't want to play the game, just don't post and you be killed. It's clear you aren't interested.

Is there anyone here (who's already spoken) that we could have a lead on? We won't have anything much until Night is over in about 6 hours.

 

[BlueLeaf]

All lurkers except BowserFanGurl and PikaSweet have responded to my PM. River and Blu Rose have already been considered innocent for the time being from our elected roles. Beary, Klink, and Slaughter all said they were unsure of what to say, which is just a beginner move. I suggest we all read back and look. I, myself, will be taking a look on voting and report back.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I didn't understand Beary's vote change. It was after the landslide of votes Trundle had, when it was obvious he was going to win. This seems like a bandwagon effort. The vote change was pretty useless and had no reasoning I believe.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Actually, she did post a reason. It said Trundle's posts were good.