Mafia TBT Mafia III: The Murder Before Christmas [Game Over/Town Win]

[kittenrobotarmy]

Was there any other reason than "Trundle's posts were good"? I never posted a reason, gimmie a sec.

I voted for Trundle because he showed good performance in the previous game, and I have seen how he handles situations. There wasn't a lot to stop me from voting for him, because it's not like he kept saying "vote for me because ill do these great things" but posted good reasons without much pushing for us to vote for him.

 

[BlueLeaf]

Was there any other reason than "Trundle's posts were good"? I never posted a reason, gimmie a sec.

I voted for Trundle because he showed good performance in the previous game, and I have seen how he handles situations. There wasn't a lot to stop me from voting for him, because it's not like he kept saying "vote for me because ill do these great things" but posted good reasons without much pushing for us to vote for him.

Nope. I'll quote it:

I'm changing my vote to Trundle. All of the posts he has made are very good.

This doesn't scream Mafia, it's just fishy to see someone look like they're bandwagoning.

 

[kittenrobotarmy]

That's the same reason we lynched Beary last time, because of bandwagoning. Didn't Beary learn not to do that?

 

[Beary]

Was there any other reason than "Trundle's posts were good"? I never posted a reason, gimmie a sec.

I voted for Trundle because he showed good performance in the previous game, and I have seen how he handles situations. There wasn't a lot to stop me from voting for him, because it's not like he kept saying "vote for me because ill do these great things" but posted good reasons without much pushing for us to vote for him.

I was pressed for time when I made that post. It was mostly last minute and I was on my phone sorry D:
I voted for Trundle because he did very well in the last game, and seems very experienced. I trust him to track down the mafia successfully. Also, he didn't push us to vote for him, which was less stressful.

- - - Post Merge - - -

That's the same reason we lynched Beary last time, because of bandwagoning. Didn't Beary learn not to do that?

Above post.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Nope. I'll quote it:


This doesn't scream Mafia, it's just fishy to see someone look like they're bandwagoning.

ABOVE POST.

 

[kittenrobotarmy]

Your post was made after ours, Beary. You don't need to keep doing ABOVE POST when we haven't seen your posts yet.

 

[Beary]

Your post was made after ours, Beary. You don't need to keep doing ABOVE POST when we haven't seen your posts yet.

Sorry. I am having a hard day and got annoyed :c

 

[Chris]

Was there any other reason than "Trundle's posts were good"? I never posted a reason, gimmie a sec.

I voted for Trundle because he showed good performance in the previous game, and I have seen how he handles situations. There wasn't a lot to stop me from voting for him, because it's not like he kept saying "vote for me because ill do these great things" but posted good reasons without much pushing for us to vote for him.

Except the fact you originally voted for VD. What made you switch your vote?

 

[kittenrobotarmy]

By that, I meant there weren't roadblocks like being a new player or not spending time in game.

 

[SlaughterShy]

I personally voted for Trundle because I though he and Karla would make an excellent pair. Karla and Trundle are both keen on analyzing everything, which is seemingly a key component in this game. I would have voted for Karla, but he seemed to be better fit for the sheriff role. Trundle and Karla both put a lot of effort into their posts, unlike some of the other candidates. They both had great plans, and if they start to act suspicious we can just lynch them.

 

[kittenrobotarmy]

I personally voted for Trundle because I though he and Karla would make an excellent pair. Karla and Trundle are both keen on analyzing everything, which is seemingly a key component in this game. I would have voted for Karla, but he seemed to be better fit for the sheriff role. Trundle and Karla both put a lot of effort into their posts, unlike some of the other candidates. They both had great plans, and if they start to act suspicious we can just lynch them.

This as well. I've actually said before that if either of them is Mafia, we'll notice because their play styles will be different. If they lynch a bunch of innocents and only hit like, one Mafia? This is inconsistent with their plans and promises.

 

[Laurina]

Sorry for not posting very much. I've been watching my nieces since last night and was busy with the Vikings game. It's pretty upsetting what happened with the lynch. I understand that he's a gamble to keep whether he be town or Mafia, but nothing screamed Mafia about him at me. I was more frustrated in Trundle negatively analyzing River making most of us think he was going to vote River, but put him is vote minutes before it ended for FoxWolf. I know we were in a time crunch, but I was hoping you'd post your thoughts on here as well as Mumble or IRC. His name was never brought up in anyone's discussions, I know it was your vote 100%, but you did mention that you wanted us to agree with the lynch and had us tell you who we found suspicious. Well, what happened has happened and we all share blame on this one. Moving on.

Oh and if you are considering lynching me then I don't really care. It won't help you in any way.

Hoping we really do move away from Klinkguin. Honestly, she just seems like a useless townie. No offense. But for someone who signed up for this game she should realize to to put in an effort, contribute, and analyze just as much as the next person. As a repeat with the last game 3dsfan(?) was more interested in the fair and the rest of the forum and simply didn't care. I'm sure when it comes down to it Klinkguin is just going to get modkill, I wouldn't waste a lynch on her.

For other players listed I would avoid the excuses "I'm not experienced like the rest of you" "I'm new" "I'd rather observe and follow what everyone else says" being a new player and being apart of the Mafia can be an advantage for that reason. You can simply be used as a distraction. Or if you are a town, step it up, because your excuses are going to bite us in the ass. The Mafia are going to sit there and wait for you to something irrelevant and call you out on it and wait for the rest of us to jump on you.

I don't have any suspicions at this time since I'm waiting for the results after night ends. Hopefully it will give us a lot to go off us and help prevent another innocent lynch. Blue roles, don't get too ahead of yourselves. Use your actions wisely.

 

[KarlaKGB]

For other players listed I would avoid the excuses "I'm not experienced like the rest of you" "I'm new" "I'd rather observe and follow what everyone else says" being a new player and being apart of the Mafia can be an advantage for that reason. You can simply be used as a distraction. Or if you are a town, step it up, because your excuses are going to bite us in the ass. The Mafia are going to sit there and wait for you to something irrelevant and call you out on it and wait for the rest of us to jump on you.

This. I have emphasised this point continously, from when I had my encounter with Blu Rose. Presenting yourself as a noob who is probably wrong and should be ignored is incredibly scummy. It makes little sense from a Town perspective as you're not going to be helping town by saying you shouldn't be listened to. This makes more sense from a Mafia perspective -you want to find reasons why you are less suspicious and are just trying to help without actually helping or trying.

 

[EpicGamer12]

Well, everyone, I'm just going to make a short post of a few of my thoughts so far.
At the moment, Karla and I are PMing people, trying to find weak posts/links, and pretty much waiting for day to role around. We do have a little bit of suspicion that we are going off of right now, and doing our best to find potentially scummy people. Just to reiterate the above points, Klink should probably be dropped for the time being.
Next, I want to thank everyone for the forgiveness of the poor lynch yesterday. I never actually suspected River, but Justin was really pressuring me to post a suspicion I had, so I quickly typed up a quick case to get him off my back. He apologized afterwards (I think) for being so uptight. I didn't end up having time to analyze to any great extent and I wasn't aware I'd only have 5 hours to do so (I was away for 4 of the 5 hours). Naturally, I chose someone who was seemingly a problem to the town. I know some people are upset about the lynch of a townie, but in all honesty, he was a huge problem maker in this game and last. We probably actually gained more from killing him than we would gain lynching anyone else.

Again, thanks for the understanding. I'm going to try my best to give out new info after school tomorrow (~18 hours from this post). If night ends up ending early, I will try to give some out before I head to bed.

 

[Beary]

I suppose the only thing left to do is wait it out. Are you going to lynch somebody today? Do we have any leads? Everything seems to be a dead end :|

- - - Post Merge - - -

We* THAT IS CORRECT GRAMMAR YOU DUMB COMPUTER >:0

 

[EpicGamer12]

I suppose the only thing left to do is wait it out. Are you going to lynch somebody today? Do we have any leads? Everything seems to be a dead end :|

- - - Post Merge - - -

We* THAT IS CORRECT GRAMMAR YOU DUMB COMPUTER >:0

It's night time. We don't lynch at night.

 

[Beary]

It's night time. We don't lynch at night.

Omagosh, my sense of time is messed up. Sorry! XD

 

[oath2order]

I feel like I'm going to be on edge for the next two hours :/

 

[Justin]

I feel like I'm going to be on edge for the next two hours :/

I feel ya.

I'm assuming I'm dead meat tonight.

 

[Justin]

Remember... between 4 mafia KP, likely 2 vigs, and 3 assassins... There's a LOT of potential for deaths tonight. A lot of people are probably going to die. Even if the vigs/assassins are limited shots, people tend to be a bit jumpy on the gun.

 

[oath2order]

Remember... between 4 mafia KP, likely 2 vigs, and 3 assassins... There's a LOT of potential for deaths tonight. A lot of people are probably going to die. Even if the vigs/assassins are limited shots, people tend to be a bit jumpy on the gun.

For example, Superpenguin last game.