Blu Rose Mini-Case
I'm going to present to you all a case smaller than Harry's, but still worth observing.
Blu Rose
Roleclaim Status:
Townie
As we know, Blu Rose has kept creating havoc in the town over and over again, and here I will present you with some evidence as to why I believe she is mafia.
I, personally, after a long bout of PMs with another person who I am awfully sure is a Town member (NOT lynn105), that KarlaKGB is Mafia, or at least some kind of other bad thing. S/he (hey, ya never know) is trying to get us all to trust him/her, and keeps on giving believable arguments. Yeah, I read the plan and all, and think it might be beneficial to the Town, but KarlaKGB is just too shady, in my opinion. Go ahead: Toss my suspicions aside. I'm a newb. I just cannot help but feel suspicious.
When Blu Rose first started the game, she was quick to accuse Karla. If I were mafia right now, what would I be thinking? Well, if a town player is making good arguments trying to become mayor, the first thing I'd want to do is stop them, or at least draw towards them negative attention in the easiest way possible. Blu Rose is a new player, and I know that if she were mafia, the rest of the mafia would probably use her to post things like this, as a weaker player. The mafia's mindset would be that if she was not a great player anyways, people would either see her as a noob (which we already have) or, if they caught on, it wouldn't be that big of a loss. Also, looking at this post, Blu Rose is adding on in the end that she "cannot help but feel suspicious." I find this very disheartening that after everyone had posted so much about backing up your posts, she decided not be able to help herself feel suspicious. She is suspicious because Karla was giving her believable arguments. This is kinda sad, in my opinion.
Kippla, I thought the main reason we (town) lost last game was due to four people getting killed through inactivity... But that is just me.
Anyways, Karla, I think I am unfortunately with Kippla here... Sorry, Karla, it is just one of those too good to be true scenarios. You promise all these good things. BowserFanGurl1999, I think you are just inactive, but voting for Karla straight off the dot (I don't remember the saying) makes Karla and you suspicious. PikaSweet, I would convict you, just you unvoted. But, I am still suspicious. Go ahead, people. Lynch me, on Day 2. I don't care. I could be making a good point, I could be screwing around.
Blu Rose stated that she trusted Kippla - and quite early in the game. Is this just an early game spontaneous trust or is there more behind it? If we were to assume Blu Rose is mafia, what are some things we would expect of her to do with some of the more easily swayed/influenced players? Obviously gaining their trust is something they are going to do very quickly. In the above quote we see Blu Rose agreeing with something that Kippla said referencing the previous game. It
looks like Blu Rose is trying to build the trust of those that are easily influenced in the game. Kippla is a prime example of someone that is easily swayed when it comes to voting. Every vote counts in mafia, and the more trust the mafia has, the easier it will be for them to lynch town. If you want to see more of this, just check Blu Rose's posts in this thread. Also, at the end, she adds "I could be making a good point, I could be screwing around." What town member even considers making statements like these? As a town member, you don't want people to think you're just screwing around.
I just don't know. Don't Blu Rose's posts seem quite offsetting to any of you? Here are a few strange ones.
Even the post Blu Rose just made - Why are you making so much CrapLogic in this game, Blu Rose?
If anyone has anything to add on to this case, feel free.
