Mafia TBT Mafia III: The Murder Before Christmas [Game Over/Town Win]
- Thread starter Trent the Paladin
- Start date
Superpenguin
Penguins! <3
You've got to stop backing off your positions once someone begins questioning you. Can you please answer the questions?
Okay, okay, sorry. Because my reasoning is flawed: I'm a distraction to Town, like FoxWolf. I think Kippla would want me dead due to my rumor, which easily spread to at least Dolby, I'm pretty sure that there is more, though...
Superpenguin
Penguins! <3
Here's the thing. If you truly are a distraction to town like you say you are, then no mafia is going to want to kill you. You're basically helping the mafia by distracting the town. They'll want to keep you around for as long as possible.
Since you admitted to thinking you are a distraction, could you please try to work on shaping up? It'll help the rest of town greatly!
I don't think your survival has as much significance as you're making out. There were 34 players alive at the beginning of the night phase and although you accused Kippla you're probably the least threatening person to do so: your arguments against her have been weak and since your initial accusation further events have transpired that point fingers to her (e.g. the way she voted in the election). So, assuming in this situation that you're innocent, then I imagine that the reason you're alive is because they simply don't consider you a threat.
To put it in a more direct way: I believe your survival has little weight in assessing Kippla's (or your own) innocence.
As I said, flaws in my logic. Thanks, I guess.
@Tina: Okay. Well, I guess I'll just watch things unfold. Leave it to the experts!
Actually, i've been waiting for five days to post that about Kippla
EpicGamer12
Senior Member
Blu Rose Mini-Case
I'm going to present to you all a case smaller than Harry's, but still worth observing.
Blu Rose
Roleclaim Status: Townie
As we know, Blu Rose has kept creating havoc in the town over and over again, and here I will present you with some evidence as to why I believe she is mafia.
Blu Rose stated that she trusted Kippla - and quite early in the game. Is this just an early game spontaneous trust or is there more behind it? If we were to assume Blu Rose is mafia, what are some things we would expect of her to do with some of the more easily swayed/influenced players? Obviously gaining their trust is something they are going to do very quickly. In the above quote we see Blu Rose agreeing with something that Kippla said referencing the previous game. It looks like Blu Rose is trying to build the trust of those that are easily influenced in the game. Kippla is a prime example of someone that is easily swayed when it comes to voting. Every vote counts in mafia, and the more trust the mafia has, the easier it will be for them to lynch town. If you want to see more of this, just check Blu Rose's posts in this thread. Also, at the end, she adds "I could be making a good point, I could be screwing around." What town member even considers making statements like these? As a town member, you don't want people to think you're just screwing around.
I just don't know. Don't Blu Rose's posts seem quite offsetting to any of you? Here are a few strange ones.
Even the post Blu Rose just made - Why are you making so much CrapLogic in this game, Blu Rose?
If anyone has anything to add on to this case, feel free.
I'm going to present to you all a case smaller than Harry's, but still worth observing.
Blu Rose
Roleclaim Status: Townie
As we know, Blu Rose has kept creating havoc in the town over and over again, and here I will present you with some evidence as to why I believe she is mafia.
When Blu Rose first started the game, she was quick to accuse Karla. If I were mafia right now, what would I be thinking? Well, if a town player is making good arguments trying to become mayor, the first thing I'd want to do is stop them, or at least draw towards them negative attention in the easiest way possible. Blu Rose is a new player, and I know that if she were mafia, the rest of the mafia would probably use her to post things like this, as a weaker player. The mafia's mindset would be that if she was not a great player anyways, people would either see her as a noob (which we already have) or, if they caught on, it wouldn't be that big of a loss. Also, looking at this post, Blu Rose is adding on in the end that she "cannot help but feel suspicious." I find this very disheartening that after everyone had posted so much about backing up your posts, she decided not be able to help herself feel suspicious. She is suspicious because Karla was giving her believable arguments. This is kinda sad, in my opinion.
Blu Rose stated that she trusted Kippla - and quite early in the game. Is this just an early game spontaneous trust or is there more behind it? If we were to assume Blu Rose is mafia, what are some things we would expect of her to do with some of the more easily swayed/influenced players? Obviously gaining their trust is something they are going to do very quickly. In the above quote we see Blu Rose agreeing with something that Kippla said referencing the previous game. It looks like Blu Rose is trying to build the trust of those that are easily influenced in the game. Kippla is a prime example of someone that is easily swayed when it comes to voting. Every vote counts in mafia, and the more trust the mafia has, the easier it will be for them to lynch town. If you want to see more of this, just check Blu Rose's posts in this thread. Also, at the end, she adds "I could be making a good point, I could be screwing around." What town member even considers making statements like these? As a town member, you don't want people to think you're just screwing around.
I just don't know. Don't Blu Rose's posts seem quite offsetting to any of you? Here are a few strange ones.
Even the post Blu Rose just made - Why are you making so much CrapLogic in this game, Blu Rose?
If anyone has anything to add on to this case, feel free.
BungoTheElf
Senior Member
Hi guys! Internet is workin now thanks to my uncle! I've been on for a while, thinking of what to say lol
Blu: I think you really need to make better posts. I don't know if you're mafia or not but they don't really help to the town much if you're the townie you say you are...
I'll be keeping my vote for now until I can think of a good suspect or someone people can persuade me into.
Blu: I think you really need to make better posts. I don't know if you're mafia or not but they don't really help to the town much if you're the townie you say you are...
I'll be keeping my vote for now until I can think of a good suspect or someone people can persuade me into.
@Trundle: I don't remember saying I trusted Kippla... Nor does it say I did in the post.
I said later on that, instead of awfully, it should be skeptically.
Okay, if I were Mafia, which I assure you, I am not, then the only "easily swayed" person I have contacted is Kippla. Even then, I don't think she was--or is-- easily swayed. I don't think she trusts, or even trusts, me at all. The "I could be making a good point; I could be screwing around." was more of a stupid trait that I have: I like to put people on edge. Y'know, get them suspicious. I even do it in real life, It's part of my speech pattern. I try to share my suspicions with logic that makes sense to mebeing the Village Idiot, and Kippla, you were right: Just one sentence wrong, and you can put the whole town on edge, even if it was meant to be harmless.
Yeah, I'd want to stop them, too, I perfectly agree with this statement. But, I wasn't trying to stop Karla. As I have stressed many a time, I was only sharing my suspicions. Yeah, I was quick to accuse Karla, but I said that everybody can just toss my suspicions aside... I should have added the word might to that post. Look, people, I'm sorry. Seriously. If the Mafia were just trying to sacrifice me, I would have claimed Mafia by now. As Karla relayed, "Blu Rose was seriously thinking about fakeclaiming Mafia, at one point." Ugh, I am so siick & tired of being accused of being Mafia!
Lastly, I say I can't help but feel suspicious because I was, and, well, can't help but feel suspicious! Lastly, all I did was agree with Kippla! I say one last thing: I'm the easily swayed player, not anyone else.
I said later on that, instead of awfully, it should be skeptically.
Okay, if I were Mafia, which I assure you, I am not, then the only "easily swayed" person I have contacted is Kippla. Even then, I don't think she was--or is-- easily swayed. I don't think she trusts, or even trusts, me at all. The "I could be making a good point; I could be screwing around." was more of a stupid trait that I have: I like to put people on edge. Y'know, get them suspicious. I even do it in real life, It's part of my speech pattern. I try to share my suspicions with logic that makes sense to me
Yeah, I'd want to stop them, too, I perfectly agree with this statement. But, I wasn't trying to stop Karla. As I have stressed many a time, I was only sharing my suspicions. Yeah, I was quick to accuse Karla, but I said that everybody can just toss my suspicions aside... I should have added the word might to that post. Look, people, I'm sorry. Seriously. If the Mafia were just trying to sacrifice me, I would have claimed Mafia by now. As Karla relayed, "Blu Rose was seriously thinking about fakeclaiming Mafia, at one point." Ugh, I am so siick & tired of being accused of being Mafia!
Lastly, I say I can't help but feel suspicious because I was, and, well, can't help but feel suspicious! Lastly, all I did was agree with Kippla! I say one last thing: I'm the easily swayed player, not anyone else.
@Dolby
I understand why this would make you suspicious, but my role makes sense. I can see why Tom chose it for me reflecting the last game. I am sure that all people who played in last game will get it, if they think hard.
Anyways, we lost three townies?!? I know that they don't do much, but they keep up our numbers. We are closer to hitting mafia, but more at risk of them hitting a blue.
I know that this is outlandish, but based off this post i'm going to assume that beary is a assasian and not mafia if we find any suspicious posts by her in the future
- - - Post Merge - - -
because she said that she didn't want to be a assasian[/QUOTE]
- - - Post Merge - - -
Omagosh, horrible quoting there. Only pay attention to the middle bit xD
- - - Post Merge - - -
I meant first bit o.o
I understand why this would make you suspicious, but my role makes sense. I can see why Tom chose it for me reflecting the last game. I am sure that all people who played in last game will get it, if they think hard.
Anyways, we lost three townies?!? I know that they don't do much, but they keep up our numbers. We are closer to hitting mafia, but more at risk of them hitting a blue.
I know that this is outlandish, but based off this post i'm going to assume that beary is a assasian and not mafia if we find any suspicious posts by her in the future
- - - Post Merge - - -
because she said that she didn't want to be a assasian[/QUOTE]
- - - Post Merge - - -
Omagosh, horrible quoting there. Only pay attention to the middle bit xD
- - - Post Merge - - -
I meant first bit o.o
...Yeah, I was quick to accuse Karla, but I said that everybody can just toss my suspicions aside... *Because they were made really early in the game! ...
- - - Post Merge - - -
Oh, and because I was a noob.
Lastly, lynn, I know. It has only been pointed out by so many other... Enthusiasts. Kidding, kidding.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Oh, and because I was a noob.
Lastly, lynn, I know. It has only been pointed out by so many other... Enthusiasts. Kidding, kidding.
You are like the beary509 of this game. My advice-
Improve grammar. Get serious. Stop goofing and defend yourself.
Note- I got lynched last game :/
NO. We trusted iloveu last game and look what happened
Beary: Tom didn't choose your role 100%. It was tweaked so mostly everyone would have a new role. It is not affected by your performance.
Anyway, looks like Blu Rose and VD are the new candidates in the meantime. With Blu Rose keeping us on the edge, as he wonderfully pointed out himself I should mention, we aren't anywhere NEAR Mafia ground. Since Mafia won't kill distractions, we might as well do it ourselves soon, not later. It does seem like a useless lynch, but getting rid of a distraction helps us.
