Mafia TBT Mafia III: The Murder Before Christmas [Game Over/Town Win]

[kittenrobotarmy]

Great! Things are looking good for the Town now that one of the biggest distractions on the Mafia team is dead.

 

[Blu Rose]

Remaining Detective(s), all innocent checks can now be assumed to be true (with the tiny exception of a Bus Driver involvement).

- - - Post Merge - - -



I don't understand your posting. Are you suggesting we should look at you and Kippla? Are you being sarcastic? What is the point of this post?

There is this great thing called sarcasm. Gee, I should start using emoticons.

 

[BowserFanGurl1999]

Wasn't my fault I got modkilled. School was in the way, as well as the musical I was auditioning in. But still, rules are rules. I had fun playing, and good luck to the rest of you. To those that don't make it, I will see you here in the great beyond.

Yours truly,
BowserFanGurl1999

 

[Chris]

There is this great thing called sarcasm. Gee, I should start using emoticons.

Sarcasm isn't going to help us.

You mentioned Kippla's name. Do you genuinely suspect her or is that also sarcasm?

 

[Blu Rose]

I somewhat suspect her. Somewhat.

 

[KarlaKGB]

Today's vote was a bit unfortunate, in that it was so unanimous that it will be hard to pick out the scum. This is one reason I asked Trundle to push the Blu Rose case. A person who is already under suspicion, but most likely innocent, who would hopefully draw votes from VD's scum buddies as they attempt to save him from the lynch. This didn't work. Instead, I want people to go back and look for those who were fence-sitters or wishywashy towards the lynch.

In particular, look for people who subtly try to deflect the VD lynch, while hiding that they are trying to do that. People who are really saying: "I secretly don't want to lynch VD but I don't want you to know that so I'm going to, but maybe just maybe we can have him as a fallback option aka if my team can't get another suspect up there."

With this in mind, TheCreeperHugz immediately jumps out at me.

Although Karla made a very good post about VD with a lot of evidence, I think that Trundle is suspicious right now. He has said hinself, as Karla has, that people shouldn't automatically trust people enough to roleclaim straight away. Yes, we elected him as mayor, but that doesn't make him immediately trustworthy. So why would he bother asking veterans to roleclaim to him? As we saw last game, roleclaiming to Kayla and Jubs (in the scum chat we had made a list of people and their roles) was the town's downfall, so no one wo played the previous game is going to be stupid enough to risk the same situation if there is a chance we have elected scum.

I read this as "yeah VD's case is nice BUT GUYS LOOK AT WHAT TRUNDLE DID OMFG".

I think that it is very strange that he would refuse incarceration, especially as he wanted to be elected mainly for protection, but I'm thinking that he could be a vet, and not want to let on to Karla about it incase Karla was scum. This would explain why he wouldnt want incarceration night one as he wouldn't die if shot anyway. Or, he could be mafia, and not want the noticable decrease in KP

This is simply a theory, and I would like to wait for more evidence before I view people as being suspicious enough for me to vote, though.

Ignore all my other evidence, focus purely on the Incarceration Gambit, just like everyone else is doing. Then decides more evidence is needed, ok...

Well, I'll vote for VD since he hasn't came up with a good reason why he would refuse the incarceration besides not want a noticable KP drop if he is mafia, which seems incredibly scummy to me.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Also, looks like this could be a completely unanimous vote...

Time to vote for VD with the exact same reason everyone else is using, even though no new evidence has actually come up. Insert rather useless line about it being a unanimous vote. Unless you're scum and you're just reassuring yourself (and town) that it's just a safe vote.

- - - Post Merge - - -

There is this great thing called sarcasm. Gee, I should start using emoticons.

Or maybe you should improve your standard of posting. Sarcasm doesn't help us. Making clear points does.

 

[Princess]

Sorry guys, I was under the impression that voting would end 5 pm Pacific not Eastern.
I didn't vote earlier because I wanted to include a post with my reasoning for who I had the intention of voting for.

Good luck to town!

 

[oath2order]

Holy ****, this is worse than the Blue Massacre of Game 2.

Well, the Assassins didn't get to do anything. Kind of sad, isn't it?

I'm just glad no bodyguards got killed!

 

[BlueLeaf]

Awkward late Goodbye Winning post:

Hooray, I won with nearly no effort! I have to tell you ; my play through as an assassin was short, but it was fun! See you guys up in Heaven amd good luck!

 

[Thunder]

requiescat in pace

 

[Superpenguin]

Well, regardless of getting rid of two mafia players, we suffered a huge number loss. Plus, we are now in night time where more kills will be placed. Congrats to Blueleaf for outlasting the other two assassins, I guess. You got an easy victory.

VD has seemingly made a lot of relations through posts and possibly through PMs with a lot of players. Hopefully, that will help us locate the remaining mafia players. However, I don't suggest posting suspicions until after night is over, because they may be proven wrong with the Day post.

 

[Justin]

However, I don't suggest posting suspicions until after night is over, because they may be proven wrong with the Day post.

On the flip side, you may die before you can even post said suspicions in the day! I think for the most part, it's best to post towards the end of the night. Late enough where the Mafia cannot adjust their kills much at that point around your post, but still before Day instead you die.

 

[Trent the Paladin]

Thanks to Kayla(iLoveYou) for handling to Night 2 post. Was hoping to be home earlier than now, but what should have taken five hours max quickly became all day thanks to accidents and backups. If anyone is actually interested in a short story for the night post I might write one up, but to be honest it would be far to lengthy and annoying with the sheer amount of modkills that took place.

Night ends in about 20 hours as of this post, if you possess an action please PM me if you plan to use it or if you don't. The sooner all actions are in, the sooner day can start.

Also if you notice any errors in the main post, please notify me.

 

[SlaughterShy]

Oops! Sorry for joining the game on a surprisingly busy week, I got slammed with homework since the holiday is almost here. Nevertheless, good luck to the rest of the mafia!

 

[Beary]

Well, two mafia down! Exellent work sheriff.
Anyways, we lost a detective and a miller. The detective is a loss, but miller? Meh. A bit of a distraction.

We need to keep our eyes peeled and dig up more infos!
I'm not very good at that and am short on time...so...XD
This is the only post I can make today, so :3

- - - Post Merge - - -

I may make more. Don't quote me on that.

 

[Elijo]

Woah! Two mafia gone! I'm very surprised. I thought that VD was a townie! Oh well, because of all the modkills, we have made some progress. We should definitely be re-reading everyones posts, just incase some people are trying to hide something.

 

[Chris]

I think it could be worthwhile looking at the lurkers. SlaughterShy was an inactive and she turned out to be a goon - but there are a couple of other people who weren't really contributing who have survived the modkill. This means they obviously took the time to vote.

 

[Keen]

Just to be clear, I've mostly been active working with people outside of the thread, such as Karla and Jubs and a little bit of Trundle. I have been excused for inactivity since Monday due to surgery but I should start posting my ideas instead of relaying them to Karla, so he can post them.

 

[EpicGamer12]

Just to be clear, I've mostly been active working with people outside of the thread, such as Karla and Jubs and a little bit of Trundle. I have been excused for inactivity since Monday due to surgery but I should start posting my ideas instead of relaying them to Karla, so he can post them.

It's great that you're back and that you can start participating a bit again!

If any of you are wondering what's happening right now, we are basically waiting for night to end and, meanwhile, in our spare time, we've been analyzing some posts with the new suspicion availability after the two mafia died. It really isn't too much to go on. VD only had around 10 posts and SlaughterShy less than that.
Once day hits, we'll probably have a few minor leads to go off of, but I don't think we'll have anything as strong as VD's case was at this point.

 

[Horus]

Well, looks like I can trust Karla now




Yep, literally my only thoughts for right now