Mafia TBT Mafia III: The Murder Before Christmas [Game Over/Town Win]

[Keen]

Which is what a good host would say, because that would be reveling information.

Logically, I think the game would be too crazy with more than one bus driver so I can't see the hosts putting more than one bus driver in the game.

 

[KarlaKGB]

No reason, but you are going to be surprised by my actions

It comes down to this. To me, there's a 10% chance there are two bus drivers in the game. I would never put two bus drivers in a game.

So why would we be surprised? Most likely because the real bus driver would die. So Dolby has advanced knowledge of this? The ONLY way that's possible is that he's scum. But how he/they know Farobi was a bus driver? Maybe Farobi claimed to him. Farobi probably saw Dolby's user title and questioned him about it. Dolby may have fed him the same excuse he fed me and others - that it was a protective measure. Farobi may also have just slipped that he was the bus driver. Possibly because he was so certain that Dolby was not the driver, that Dolby deduced that could only mean Farobi was the real driver.

Farobi was probably happy to let Dolby take the heat, thus he didn't counterclaim when Dolby claimed in this thread. A reminder that the quote above was taken from VM exchanges with ITookYourWaffles, who isn't in the game. He probably figured that nobody would read those posts.

##Lynch: Dolby

 

[Horus]

So it looks like Dolby nominated himself to be the newest contender on the hit game show; "Who Wants To Get Bandwagonned?"

and/or possibly Creeper?

 

[Chris]

I just checked with Tom and he didn't confirm there would be only one bus driver. He basically said that there could be one or two.

In IRC, right? I saw that.

But Dolby has been acting strangely in addition to his bus driver claim (throwing out baseless accusations against other players) so I still think he should be our top priority.

 

[KarlaKGB]

Dolby just claimed to me he was roleblocked.

 

[Chris.]

It comes down to this. To me, there's a 10% chance there are two bus drivers in the game. I would never put two bus drivers in a game.

So why would we be surprised? Most likely because the real bus driver would die. So Dolby has advanced knowledge of this? The ONLY way that's possible is that he's scum. But how he/they know Farobi was a bus driver? Maybe Farobi claimed to him. Farobi probably saw Dolby's user title and questioned him about it. Dolby may have fed him the same excuse he fed me and others - that it was a protective measure. Farobi may also have just slipped that he was the bus driver. Possibly because he was so certain that Dolby was not the driver, that Dolby deduced that could only mean Farobi was the real driver.

Farobi was probably happy to let Dolby take the heat, thus he didn't counterclaim when Dolby claimed in this thread. A reminder that the quote above was taken from VM exchanges with ITookYourWaffles, who isn't in the game. He probably figured that nobody would read those posts.

##Lynch: Dolby

Isn't it just a little bit early in the day to cast a lynch for someone? I mean, we haven't even finished the first hour. Also, while there is a low chance that there are 2 bus drivers, there is still that, a chance. I don't think the hosts would try to act similar to us and make the amount of roles what we expect too. Also, that's a little of analyzing for a little quote. Where does he say that he has previous knowledge of it? You are really inferring that Dolby surprising us meant that an actual bus driver would die. Farobi could have claimed to him, but then again that is a lot of guessing for a lynch vote? Then again, the evidence of Dolby saying he is the bus driver both on comments between Waffles, and on the forum itself, is very heavy.

 

[Hikari]

I just checked with Tom and he didn't confirm there would be only one bus driver. He basically said that there could be one or two.

Hm... So Dolby could be telling the truth... But we can't be sure of that.

 

[Dolby]

Hello everybody, don't have much time today. Now let's think logical on how the hosts would design the game, do they like steady flow? Or do they like chaos? Now, i don't know anything about Tom but since their was a second bus driver then I would assume that he likes chaos. That would mean that their would be a increase in destructive and confusing roles.

And no for anybody looking at this, i have no idea on who is mafia.

 

[KarlaKGB]

This is not a game where you look at the obvious, you have to look much deeper than that. Why the hell would he outright tell us that a bus driver would die? I cast a vote whenever I want, and I change it whenever I want, there's no such thing as too early.

 

[Dolby]

Also, the only people i've pmed about mafia are Bellbringergreen, Karla, and Blueleaf

 

[Farobi]

Hmm I died, must've mean that I'm on the right track, or am crazy suspicious. I dunno.

Good luck town. I could've been more active if it wasn't Finals this week :c

 

[Chris]

Isn't it just a little bit early in the day to cast a lynch for someone? I mean, we haven't even finished the first hour. Also, while there is a low chance that there are 2 bus drivers, there is still that, a chance. I don't think the hosts would try to act similar to us and make the amount of roles what we expect too. Also, that's a little of analyzing for a little quote. Where does he say that he has previous knowledge of it? You are really inferring that Dolby surprising us meant that an actual bus driver would die. Farobi could have claimed to him, but then again that is a lot of guessing for a lynch vote? Then again, the evidence of Dolby saying he is the bus driver both on comments between Waffles, and on the forum itself, is very heavy.

Karla was very quick to nominate VD for the day 2 lynch and look at the result: we took out the godfather. I won't say I completely comprehend his way of thinking, but I think one reason Karla has been stating his suspects so early is that it gives everyone time to weigh in on it. If Dolby's claims are truthful (I'm personally doubting this) then we've plenty of time to prove that and move on to other potential suspects before day ends.

Just to confirm - day 3 ends Friday 5pm EST, right?

 

[KarlaKGB]

I just put my vote down to show where I stand at that point in time. I can always change my vote up until the deadline.

 

[Dolby]

Also, if I was mafia and knew that Farobi was a bus driver then i would want Farobi to live so that there would be no "there can't be more then one bus driver" accusations thrown at me. The mafia would never do that. The most logical explanations are that the mafia found out that Farobi was bus driver, killed her and not me so that i would be accused, or they struck lucky.

 

[iLoveYou]

Just to confirm - day 3 ends Friday 5pm EST, right?

Yes. Day 3 ends on Friday at 5 PM EST.

 

[Farobi]

Also, if I was mafia and knew that Farobi was a bus driver then i would want Farobi to live so that there would be no "there can't be more then one bus driver" accusations thrown at me. The mafia would never do that. The most logical explanations are that the mafia found out that Farobi was bus driver, killed her and not me so that i would be accused, or they struck lucky.

I'm a he.

*DIES*

 

[Dolby]

I'm a he.

*DIES*

Sorry

 

[Trent the Paladin]

I'm a he.

*DIES*

*whacks with a shovel* You're dead git outta here.

 

[kittenrobotarmy]

Also, if I was mafia and knew that Farobi was a bus driver then i would want Farobi to live so that there would be no "there can't be more then one bus driver" accusations thrown at me. The mafia would never do that. The most logical explanations are that the mafia found out that Farobi was bus driver, killed her and not me so that i would be accused, or they struck lucky.

How would you know Farobi was Bus Driver? Who would've told you?

 

[Dolby]

How would you know Farobi was Bus Driver? Who would've told you?

Either Farobi himself or a mafia member